Re: Negative Rake Scraper
GaryG in MD
>Russell, Gil,
Gil's referenced article indicates that in using a negative-rake (drop-nose) scraper, one is to lower the handle and ride the bevel of the lower surface. I believe that most people might disagree with that. It is a 'catch' looking for a place to happen.
There have been quite a few Wood Central posts on this subject in the past -- with many differing and confusing viewpoints. They are in the Turning Archives.
I think that most would agree that Stuart Batty is the recognized expert in this area. Unfortunately, Stuart Batty's website "negativerakescraping.com" is still under construction, but he has an article about it in the current (Spring 2006) edition of the AAW Journal ("American Woodturner"). In this article, Batty says nothing about riding the bevel (indeed, it would be impossible on two of the three profiles he illustrates), and furthermore says: "As long as you don't point this tool uphill, you'll find this a user-friendly grind." and "However, do not drop the handle too low or it will catch."
I also think a number of turners would disagree with the information presented on the Sorby site.
...Gary