Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Negative Rake Scraper

Posts

Negative Rake Scraper

#1

Negative Rake Scraper

Russell L. Babbitt Jr.

>Does anyone have a picture or drawing of a negative rake scraper? I have read what they should be but cannot seem to get a proper cut. Bonnie Klein demos it and I have seen her tools she uses on acrylic but I cannot duplicate the cut. My pictures do not show enough detail. I thank you all in advance.

Re: Negative Rake Scraper

#2

Re: Negative Rake Scraper

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA.

>Check out this site, there are several good pics of a negative rake scraper>> http://www.woodturnersofswmo.org/Newsletters/WSWMO%20Newsletter%20October%202004%20Page3.pdf

Re: Negative Rake Scraper

#3

Re: Negative Rake Scraper

GaryG in MD

>Russell, Gil,

Gil's referenced article indicates that in using a negative-rake (drop-nose) scraper, one is to lower the handle and ride the bevel of the lower surface. I believe that most people might disagree with that. It is a 'catch' looking for a place to happen.

There have been quite a few Wood Central posts on this subject in the past -- with many differing and confusing viewpoints. They are in the Turning Archives.

I think that most would agree that Stuart Batty is the recognized expert in this area. Unfortunately, Stuart Batty's website "negativerakescraping.com" is still under construction, but he has an article about it in the current (Spring 2006) edition of the AAW Journal ("American Woodturner"). In this article, Batty says nothing about riding the bevel (indeed, it would be impossible on two of the three profiles he illustrates), and furthermore says: "As long as you don't point this tool uphill, you'll find this a user-friendly grind." and "However, do not drop the handle too low or it will catch."

I also think a number of turners would disagree with the information presented on the Sorby site.

...Gary

Re: Negative Rake Scraper

#4

Re: Negative Rake Scraper

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I recently posted on WC on my recent experiences using the neg. rake scraper. I've been using it with much success since. The NR scraper should be used level on the tool rest. It is not aggressive if used in this manner. It would become much more aggressive if the handle was lowered. It is used with a light touch, not to remove wood but give a clean, smooth surface.

Wally

Re: Negative Rake Scraper

#5

Re: Negative Rake Scraper

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole GA.

>My experience with a NR scraper has been good. As Wally said, I only use it for smoothing, finish cuts. No scraper bevel riding here, just allowing a well formed burr to do the fine cutting (and the burr does not last very long before it needs reforming). I have not tried to use this tool handle down, on the bevel, nor am I likely to.

Re: Negative Rake Scraper

#6

Re: Negative Rake Scraper

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>The negative rake scraper is ground pretty much like a skew chisel. In order for it wo work well it must have a very heavy burr. More than you can get from a 60 grit wheel. I use a 1-inch 60 grit belt sander. The burr doesn't last very long and the tool doesn't work without it.

Wally