Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

My turn to ask a question...

Posts

My turn to ask a question...

#1

My turn to ask a question...

Doug Trembath

>A really good friend gave me two HUGE sections of Holly today. I could just get my arms around them. On the ground for two weeks, and not a single crack of any kind. Now, I've turned a lot of wood, but have never even seen Holly this large. For those experienced turners who have, should I turn it really thin wet, or rough it out? Seems so stable that I think I could turn it thicker, and not have much distortion, but I really don't know, What do y'all think?

Doug Trembath

Studio in the Woods

Re: My turn to ask a question...

#2

Re: My turn to ask a question...

Chris K in MD

>Doug,

There are several people looking for 8/4 or 12/4 holly. you could get some nice slabs out of one of those. I have never heard of a Holly tree getting that big. I have seen 14" dia max.

Re: My turn to ask a question...

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: My turn to ask a question...

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Doug, I can share what I know about Holly. It's hard to find kiln-dried holly in any thickness over 8/4, because it is difficult to dry successfully. The mills who have tried it tell me it's unstable, and ended up with mostly unuseable lumber when attempting anything thicker.

It will also tend to turn blue quickly as it begins the spalting process. I have wondered if a solution of clorox and water would prevent this in a rough-turned bowl.

It will distort quite a bit as it dries, I guess it depends on what results you are looking for. One of my favorite woods to turn.

Re: My turn to ask a question...

#4

Ask Barbara Gill

Barry Irby

>Barbara had some large pieces of holly and managed to turn them and keep them white, I think. If she does not jump in, she posts often, you could look through the list and find her and send her an e-mail.

Re: My turn to ask a question...

#5

Re: My turn to ask a question...

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>For some reason I have always had good success with drying holly, even 16/4. This time of the year adds the problem of staining. Last summer someone brought a huge holly log to be sawn into boards. There were branches I could not get my arms around so you can imagine the size of the trunk. Since the logs had to be trimmed up before I could put them on the mill, I decided to turn several large holly bowls. I used the alcohol method of drying them because the weather was warm and I wanted them to dry fast enough so as not to stain. It worked.

For some reason most of my holly dries flat and I have no idea why.

So my advice is to turn as soon as possible. You can turn green to finished with thin walls and all should be ok except for a little warping. You can also rough per Dave Smith's instructions and soak, etc. according to the same.

Re: My turn to ask a question...

#6

Re: My turn to ask a question...

Bob Ballard

>I have had the most success turning it green & thin,wet sanding and one coat of oil finish,when bowl is dry, complete finishing.

Dell Stubbs would hold a wet paper towel to the outside of very thin bowls while making the finishing cuts on the inside,this helped prevent the end grain from drying & warping the bowl.

Re: My turn to ask a question...

#7

Re: My turn to ask a question...

Doug Trembath

>Thanks to all! Barbara, I felt like I could do what you suggested, but wanted to get a quality hollow vessel out of some of this. I have turned too many "drunken sailors", and of course have to give them away. As always, I appreciate you all chipping in, and verifying my guesstimate!

Doug Trembath

Studio in the Woods