Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Some sharpening confusion

Posts

Some sharpening confusion

#1

Some sharpening confusion

DD

>I'm hoping someone here can clear up some confusion I am having with sharpening scrapers. When sharpening scrapers, particularly round nose scrapers, I have always been told (and read) that one is to put a curl on the edge by burnishing it. This will produce a small hook that provides all of the cutting power for the scraper.

I have watched a couple of videos from tool manufacturers (Sorby in particular) that describe how to sharpen their scraper tips (like a teardrop shape for instance) that can be used with their hollowing tools. There they use a diamond file across the top flat of the scraper tip. That, to me, would eliminate the burnished edge entirely. Why the different treatment between two tools that are used to provide exactly the same cut? What am I missing? Any help appreciated.

Doug

Re: Some sharpening confusion

#2

Re: Rolling a burr on a scraper....

JamieDonaldson

>... works for both flat and turning scrapers. I know that most users flatten the top of the scraper before raising a burr, but the actual burr is the desired edge that does the work. When cutting with a scraper without the burr the cut is much less agressive and efficient, but that could be the desired effect.

Re: Some sharpening confusion

#3

Re: Rolling a burr on a scraper....

E Tabachek

>I watched Del Stubs and Mike Hosaluk put edges on their scrapers by honing (diamond filing) the top of the scraper. This "sharpened" the cutting edge without making the scraper too agressive. These turners could/can get the whispiest shavings off soaking wet wood with a tool prepaired this way. This is great for cleaning up torn grain and making final cuts, with the grain. If more cutting power was required the honing stone (diamond steel) would be gently stroked "up" the bevel. If your patience is running out roll the edge with a burnisher.

Re: Some sharpening confusion

#4

Re: Some sharpening confusion

Jake Niedling

>On my scrapers, I go right from the grinder to the wood. No honing and no extra step with a burnisher. Especially, when making some final cuts, go to the grinder before you make these. This burr does not last forever, so you need to touch it up as you are turning to keep it sharp and minimize any torn grain.

Re: Some sharpening confusion

#5

Re: Some sharpening confusion

GaryG in MD

>Doug,

Great question. There is no simple or single answer. There are many different kinds of scrapers and many different applications for scrapers. It all depends on what you want to do and how you want to do it.

Scrapers may be used for bulk removal as well as final finishing, and everything in between; they are used flat or tilted in shearing mode; they may have flat tops or dropped noses; they are used inside and outside of bowls and hollow forms; they are used with burrs (usually) and without burrs; they are used more often on hard woods than on soft woods. There is a wide range of shapes, styles, and sizes. Finally, of course, there are personal preferences and experiences, which will differ widely from turner to turner.

FWIW, I believe that most turners often just use grinder burrs for many applications. On the other hand, Don Derry, in his demos, points out that grinder burrs are, by nature, weak and irreproducible -- he strongly recommends the use of a burnisher to produce a nice even, consistent hook on the end of the tool (after grinding and honing off the grinder burr).

The best advice is to keep an open mind, experiment, and see what works for you.

...Gary

Re: Some sharpening confusion

#6

Re: Some sharpening confusion

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>A lot of the time it depends on the indivual piece of wood. Sometimes you can get a better finish with no burr, a small burr or a larger burr. If you have trouble with tearout on a pices try each way, one will work better.

Re: Some sharpening confusion

#7

Re: Some sharpening confusion

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>And if you still have trouble with tear out try putting oil, wax, or sanding sealer on the wood before scraping.