Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

Posts

Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#1

Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

Dominic Greco in Richboro, PA

>Hi everyone,

I was wondering if anyone could recommend an electric chainsaw. I want one for use inside the shop to cut up logs for bowl blanks. If you know of an online source for purchasing these, please tell me.

I imagine these babies can really draw some amps. Are there any restrictions for the length of extension cord to use? I was also wondering how loud they are. I would assume that they are less noisy than the gas powered ones.

Thanks,

Dominic

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#2

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

Gary R

>I have also been looking into getting something. Info I have found so far:

-- Based on archive, BEST model is the STIHL electric. New one from my local dealer is almost $400.00!!!

-- Models from Sears / HD / Lowes are similar

-- Have not verified, but Sears may offer an extended warranty option - seems that plastic drive gear likes to strip on this type of saw.

-- Posts I have seen had no problem with 25' to 50' extension cord - be sure it's a 12ga

-- $89.00 model at Lowes has an automatic oiler - thought that was a good feature

PS I have also been looking at smaller Stihl saws - for $229 I can get the model 180 quick start. Only using it for lathe work, so I'm not sure if I want to spend that much. Any additional info from the group would be appreciated. I only have a Jet mini, so I'm not going to be cutting any 3' maple trees.

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#3

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

Jerry Hall

>For low cost and great performance:

Ryobi RY43006 18" 13 amps. Got it from Lowes for under a $100. Has worked great for cutting my logs and blanks. Quiet, no smell, in shop use, and easy startup is sure a pleasure. I find I use this more and my band saw less. At first I thought the 18" blade was a bit long, but have come to appreciate it on many occasions. It is safer to keep the tip out of the log, and the 18" helps a lot there.

I have heard that Stihl is the gold standard, but at 3 times the cost so far I don't know why I would go there. Ryobi does the job perfectly for me. This model had the most power of the lower cost products, which I believe makes a big difference.

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#4

Brad Vietje

YUP - Stihl it is.

Brad Vietje

>I have an older Stihl E20. Rugged, reliable saw that's quiet and powerful. It runs on regular 120V and draws 15 Amps. I have heard that the newer ones aren't as rugged (?), but I can't remember what the differences are. Noise is much less than gas-powered saws.

Safe sawing,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#5

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

Jim King

>I have a pair of Stihl 220�s that have run 8 hours a day for many months now on at least 50 foot cords from a transformer. They are 110v and we operate here in the Amazon on 220v. Have changed brushes several times but nothing else.

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#6

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

Russell L. Babbitt Jr.

>I have two Stihl's one gas one electric. Had a inexpensive electric really had no complaints about it. Had a Craftsman gas and found it hard to start after it sat around for a while. I definetly feel that you get what you pay for. Stihl is just about the best you can buy. I might suggest you get a gas saw if you only have one. When you find a tree somewhere with no access to electricity you will wish you had a gas saw.

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#7

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations? *LINK*

Rick Allen

>Husky also makes an electric chainsaw.

Note that oil will fly off the chain. So while you won't get oil and gas fumes there is the chance of an oil mess going places that you might not expect.

Good Luck


Here is one place

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#8

Mid priced electric?

John Lucas

>Is there a mid priced electric. I have been warned away from all the $49 electrics but the next step seems to be Stil And Husky at over $200. Can't justify that. Anybody know of one inbetween that's any good.

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#9

Re: Mid priced electric?

David Breth

>Sears/Craftsman has a few that are in the in-between range. I've been using one for a while, and have been happy with it. Maybe a little light on power, but not terribly so.

Not as happy with the Sears/Craftsman gas one that I picked up - the gas one offers more power, but it bites it more regularly, and I end up reverting to the electric.

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#10

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

robo hippy

>I have been using a Husky for 3 years or so, and it works fine for when you don't want to wake up the neighbors, or disturb the family. They can also be used indoors. I did find out that you can't push them. With my gas Husky, I can bear down while cutting. With the Husky, I burned one up while pushing it. I heard that they were going to put an overload breaker on it to prevent this. Now I have a Laguna, so don't use the electric at all any more.

robo hippy

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#11

Re: Better *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Husky 316 for $200 + free shipping, extra chain, and T-shirt.

[Sheoote, man, tha shurt's wuth thet much all by its ownself]


http://www.southwestfastener.com/

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#12

Re: Mid priced electric?

Jerry Hall

>I really think the Ryobi is worth looking at as "midpriced". See above post. Two year warrantee caught my eye. See following for specs:

http://www.ryobitools.com/index.php/outdoor/tool/ry43006

A little more midpriced is the Makita. I considered this one but it was more expensive, shorter blade, and s little less power. See below for info and reviews:

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/customer-reviews/B00004TI0N/ref=dp_nav_0/002-9533679-2304836?%5Fencoding=UTF8&n=228013&s=hi

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#13

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

Bob Lemon, Sacramento CA

>Dom, I picked up a 3.5 hp Remington Electric with 16" bar from Home Depot about two years ago. I have cut quite a bit of stock over 16" and the saw handled the load just fine. It has an automatic oiler and does use quite a bit of oil. I found out that Walmart has pure mineral oil in the automotive department for about 93 cents a quart, but it is probably over $2.00 by now! If I remember correctly, the saw was about $90.

Bob

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#14

Re: Mid priced electric?

Darryl Hansen

>I have a Makita. Burned up two Remingtons one my fault the other theirs. The Makita is quiet and powerful. I have used it quite a bit and find it performs exptremely well. Bought it at Amazon.com after comparing others on line. In my estimation there is little reason to spend extra for some of the others.

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#15

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

Barry Irby

>I had a Remington from Lowes and stripped the plastic drive gear when a log snapped shut on it. Bought a Sears?Craftsman with a 16" bar to replace it. About $89 a year ago and paid $12 extra for a 2 year warranty. The salesman said that if it quit for any reason they don't fix them, they just give you a new one. ?????not too sure about that.

I also have several gas saws including a Stihl. The electric saw is a different animal. Quiet, smokeless. I can cut in the shop. Don't need gas. Starts without fail and without pulling the rope, just plug it in and it goes. Keep it sharp and it cuts better than I expected. Great for prepping blanks or hacking them down enough to get them to the bandsaw.

I looked at the Stihl electric, but for $400 I couldn't stand it. rather run through a few of these cheap ones. For a $100 I can treat it as a disposable. I run it on a 100' No. 12 stranded cord and it's fine.

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#16

"Quiet" alternative to gas powered

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>I guess I should have been a bit clearer. I already have a gas powered chainsaw. I've been using it for years. But as I stated in my original post, it would be nice to have a small one to use inside the shop. Not much fun using a gas powered chainsaw in the shop. Fumes and noise and all that, don't cha know.

Dominic

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#17

The proof

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>As if you needed proof! (Now you know why my neighbors look at me funny when I fire this bad boy up.)

See ya around,

Dominic


img

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#18

Wow!

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Thanks for all the great recommendations!

I really appreciate all the personal accounts and tips. I think I'm leaning towards the 137/P16 Husqvarna (Thanks Rick and Mark). That free T-Shirt, (2) bottles of chain oil, blade and free shipping is hard to beat! Plus the $200 for a chainsaw with the Husqvarna name is pretty impressive in itself.

While I'm not ready to buy just yet, I will keep this list handy for Father's Day (what's it worth for one of you to drop a hint to my wife?)

:>)

See ya around,

My ugly mug


Dominic

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#19

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

Dick Gerard

>After reading all the recommendations about electric chainsaws, I have just one question: How do these electrics do when cutting well seasoned dry wood? :ike a length of cherry, 16-20 inches in diameter?

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#20

Dave Shombert

Re: Mid priced electric?

Dave Shombert

>John - I have a Milwaukee electric that was "mid-priced". I bought it about eight years ago or so and honestly can't remember what I paid, but I do remember that it was priced between the Sears cheapos and the Stihl. It's held up well under moderate use, works great, no problems, I'm happy with it. But I don't know if it's still available or not. I think I got it from Tool Crib, back before they were part of Amazon.

Dave Shombert

Elkins, WV

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#21

Brad Vietje

EEEEEK !!!

Brad Vietje

>Mommy, Mommy, there's a angry-looking, purple-headed creature out there with a noisy chain saw !

(...I sure wish he'd get one of those quiet electric models...)

Help !

- a scared neighborhood kid

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#22

Brad Vietje

Wow -- great deal.

Brad Vietje

>

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#23

Brad Vietje

Stihl Steal (Old gloat)

Brad Vietje

>Well, I gotta come clean and gloat a little, too...

I was keeping an eye out for a good electric saw, and my local lawn mower repair guy had a used Stihl E20 on hand, and in great shape. Seems he thought electric saws were toys, and really didn't respect them much. I bought it for $ 50.00 with two brand-new chains fitted -- one cross-cut and one ripping chain. I had a turning buddy offer me $ 250.00 for it within 24 hours !

I don't think I could afford a new one either. A friend that's a marine carpenter uses electrics all the time in all sorts of odd positions to remove Oak timbers from down inside big boats he's rebuilding. He said they went through quite a few cheap saws until they got two Stihl's, so that's what I went looking for. I know I was real lucky to find such a great deal, but checking with lawn & garden centers wouldn't hurt.

It's a LOT easier to use than my &$#@&%$ McCulloch, and it starts every time!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#24

Chucky's Back!!!!!!!!!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>And he's packin' Power Tools!!

R-U-NNNNNNNNNNNNN!

Re: Electric Chainsaw recommendations?

#25

Re: Wow -- great deal.

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>[Saw's pretty good, too] |;-}}}}