Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

First posting for Critique

Posts

First posting for Critique

#1

First posting for Critique

DaveAnderson (Pac NW)

>Hi to All,

A while back my wife told me to buy a bigger lathe. I bought a Jet 1642 1 1/2 HP. I really like this lathe. The varible speed is wonderful.. I am attaching pictures of the first completed bowl I have done ( many more roughed out on the drying rack ). This bowl id 9 1/2 by 5 inches with 1/4 inch walls. The side wall becomes a reverse curve where it meets the foot. I did this to try and make the piece sit a little lighter. Between my photo skills and trying to resize the picture for the right posting size, I hope enough detail come across for veiwing. All comments welcome.

Dave Anderson (Pac NW)


img

Re: First posting for Critique

#2

Steven Antonucci

Looks like you did pretty well with it

steve antonucci

>My personal taste in this shape would have been to continue the curve into the foot, a la the classic hawaiian calabashes. I've never been much for footed bowls, so it's probably just me, but I tried covering the foot and I immediately thought of Bill Luce's work.

my 2 cents after taxes...

steve

Re: First posting for Critique

#3

Re: First posting for Critique

Bill Howatt

>Very nice. I think I have the same opinion of footed bowls as Steve but yours seems fairly small with regard to height unless the tablecloth is hiding it.

I wonder sometimes if the general public likes obviously footed bowls better than I do because they don't realize they are a reminder of a chuck tenon (whether the foot really was part of the tenon or not). However a lot of far better turners than I, seem to like them too.

The one thing to be avoided IMO is a sharp transistion from the curve to the foot.

Bill

Re: First posting for Critique

#4

Re: First posting for Critique

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>Dave

Nice piece Nice shape Nice finish Nice wood

I believe I would like to either have no foot or a little taller.

Good job.

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: First posting for Critique

#5

Brad Vietje

Great looking bowl !

Brad Vietje

>Hey Dave -- that's a very pretty bowl ! A very nice piece of wood and nicely done, with an excellent flowing shape.

I may have to differ with Bill & Bill on the foot -- though a closer pic would help. It LOOKS like your foot has a gently curved transition, and not an abrupt change, and I like that. I often make footless bowls, and some with round bottoms, but I like a very subtle foot, too. I hope you can post a closer view of the profile and/or foot so we can see.

We can't see the rim, but most people will tell you they like a shaped rim, either crowned, dished, or undercut better that a flat-top rim. You may have done some of these, but I can't tell from the picture.

Sure looks like a mighty sweet bowl to my eyes...

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: First posting for Critique

#6

Re: First posting for Critique

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi Dave,

Really well done! That's a great bowl. I like the form a lot. Great looking piece of wood as well. What finish did you use? The curl seems to stand out nicely.

Since you say all comments welcome :) Here you go. Keep in mind that this is just me. While I do like the way you raised the bowl with the inward curve of the foot and it seems to be executed fine, I am not sure that it was really needed for this piece. I actually like the way I imagine it would sit if you just continued the curve from the side on down underneath the bowl and let it just sit on that. imagine looking at your pic and just letting the two sides of the bowl continue their curve on under the bowl until they meet. Then flatten that area out a bit for a foot and you are there! Again, just my opinion and worth what you paid for it :)

Technically, I think the bowl is a real winner and you should be proud of it. I have found that most times it is the form/shape that is the hardest for me. I can usually get a decent cut and smooth finish, but it is a nice shape that I struggle with.

Thanks for the pic, that really is a great looking bowl.

Mike

Heading to the woodshop this afternoon in Apex, NC...

Re: First posting for Critique

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: First posting for Critique

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Dave, thanks for posting this piece...it is a well balanced form. Nice!