Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Should Pro's have special treatment at galleries?

Posts

Should Pro's have special treatment at galleries?

#1

Should Pro's have special treatment at galleries?

Greg Haugen

>Even though I may get hate mail from this posting, I still must post it. I'm live in the Midwest where there is a gallery show that has gone from one city to a bigger one. The gallery consisted of "invited" professionals and juried regional artists. Now before I even get start I know they were "invited" so there was no jury to judge. There is a WELL known turner from PA, one of the biggest names in the world, who was invited to enter. The piece that was sent has been described by alot of turners as an absolute disgrace. I'm not talking a lumpy form, a texture instead of a sanding, simply a piece that would be compared to someone's first attempt at hollowing. Nothing was intential as far as "art." "A down-right shameful piece to enter for anyone," was a quote from a up and coming turner.

The point I'm trying to make before I get tar and feathered in the town square is this- Have we become a craft where the name on the bottom is more important than what is above it. A gallery should be for the art, for the craft. Not for the autographs on the wood.

I'm sure I will be hung at dawn for this but as someone who thinks alot of the craft and those who do it for a living I don't think its right.

Any feedback on this.

Thanks

Greg

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleries?

#2

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleri

Russell L. Babbitt Jr.

>Prepare to be hung. I think what you say may be valid, but....

Many of the name turners like any other artists are known because of their names. They have earned it by a life of contributing to the art. Many of them brougt the art to where it is today. We may not like what they do but they have earned it. I know of may "amateur" turners that do incredible work. I sometimes think what they need is a marketing manager.

I was recently accepted in the California Contours show. I had to submit a photo of my work to be judged. One piece out of three was accepted. Did my work deserve to be there? Only the public will decide. Only time will tell if I am ever "invited" to a show.

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleries?

#3

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleri

Ron in Drums PA

>When my wife and I where first dating, we took a drive into NYC to visit the Metropolitan Museum of Art.

While we were at the museum, we noticed a crowd around a painting and I decided to take her closer. When we finally had a good view of the masterpiece, I could see the surprise on her face and I knew from that look she was very impressed. I was pleased that I was able to show her the work of a great and very well known artist.

As we where walking away she said to me, "Why is everybody so excited to see a child's painting?"

...... I told her it was a Picasso.

Art is in the eye of the beholder

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleries?

#4

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleri

Greg Haugen

>I do understand that point and agree with there is some "earned" points out there for Pro's. And yes they do deserve it. The craft wouldn't be where it is without these people and the years that they have committed to it. I have no problems with the Pro's out there. I was just shocked to hear the hype for the piece then to see it, it was a big bummer. I mean no disrespect to any pro by "taking them lightly," they are where they are for the things that they have done.

I do also agree I made a valid point and met for it to be a topic of discussion.

thank you very much for your time and feedback.

Greg

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleries?

#5

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleri

Greg Haugen

>A Classic, point taken. Well done.

Thanks

Greg

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleries?

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleri

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Greg, I can relate to this post for a couple of reasons. First I believe the exhibit is titled "Contemporary American Woodturning", and the show travelled from Rochester Art Center to the AAW headquarters. I must say up front that I was invited to participate in this show as well, so some may feel I have a conflict of some sort here.

You have given us a pretty good idea who the turner is, but we cannot see the piece in order to form our own opinions. This seems extremely unfair to the turner in question. It's always important to remember that a piece one person absolutely hates another person may love dearly. Now, ......you mention "a lot of turners" and "an up and coming turner" gave their opinions of the piece. My question is: Did you personally view the piece in question? What is YOUR opinion or critique of this piece. Right now, that is the only opinion we should be concerned with. The rest is just "heresay". Many "up and coming turners" have their own axe to grind, and may be resentful of the success of the bigger name turners.

Next, I am a member of the "Professional Outreach Program" (POP), and I have commented on the topic you bring up here to the Board of Directors. Specifically, should exhibits that are juried, such as "Step up to the Plate", include invited turners as well? MY opinion here is no, each piece should stand on its own merit. Otherwise, a piece that may be invited in(and not meet the critera) may cause a very deserving piece to be excluded from the show. There should be no "glass ceiling",everyone should have an equal chance to participate in these events.

After all, there are many "invitation only" exhibits, such as the one you mention here, for the big-name turners to participate in. If someone indeed submitted a sub-standard piece to this exhibit, he's hurting nobody but himself....I'll reserve judgement until I see the piece for myself.

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleries?

#7

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleri

RussFairfield

>The answer to your question depends on which side of the issue you are on, whether you are an "invited artist", or you are having to go through the jurying process with the masses.

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleries?

#8

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleri

Greg Haugen

>Very well written response, and I do agree with alot of you have to say. I definately agree that a show should be juried or invited. Not both, absolutely I agree with that. That may have been more of the topic at hand. I have seen the piece, my opinion of it, for what its worth, is the same as others. I went to see the piece along with a few others. Disappointed by that piece and blown away by the juried pieces. After seeing it, I felt another regional artist should have had that spot light. You bring up the a good point. One gallery, one show, should be one set of rules. Invited or juried? That's more of a calm topic.

In no blunt way am I saying David is sub-par or anything else. If I ever met him I would bow down because of what he has done for the craft. I just think in a gallery where space is an issue, it could've been a different piece. On other hand though if the show was one or the other, juried or invited, feelings may not have been as disappointed. Going to a juried show it whould be juried and you see the cream of the crop. There is no hard feelings either, I did not have anything on show or even attempted too.

Still its a point of discussion.

Thanks

Greg

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleries?

#9

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleri

Greg Haugen

>a better question and fairer to everyone. Should a show be both, juried and invited? If a show is going on and you have a 50 spaces, is it good ethics for the craft to have 30 invited and allow 20 pieces juried if some of the juried pieces are more deserving of a spot or two. Is it good practice to have a combo show?

I don't think so, its my opinion, and yes I know the saying about opinions and other things we all have.

thanks Russ for your feedback,

Greg

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleries?

#10

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleri

Binen

>There is a very good reason to have both invited and juried entries. The �gallery show� is a business and the promoter needs to make enough profit. If the promoters putting on the shows do not make money then there will be no new shows. Inviting one, two, three or even ten well know Pros will create a buzz. This buzz will turn into a couple local and maybe not so papers doing a write-up for publication. If they are very lucky, a local TV news program may have an interview. All of this media attention will directly affect the number of people who decide to attend the show. A high attendance will generally equal a successful show for both the promoters and exhibitors. Fair or not the best piece made by �Joe Nobody� will draw no one into the exhibit while a poor piece produced by �Star Name� may bring in 100s if not 1000s of viewers for the show.

Binen

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleries?

#11

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleri

Doug Trembath

>Well, Greg, I can understand your feelings, and if I may, I believe I can put it into a different perspective. I disagree that a show needs to be one or the other. I fully support the organizers of a show, and their right to use the format they choose. That being said, invited artists add tremendous value to the show through drawing power. As you said, you were eager to view the work, and were blown away by most of it.

As an artist, of sorts, I reserve the right to display that which I choose. Sometimes it's my best work, sometimes not. Sometimes it's a piece that is flawless in technique, but maybe it's a piece of wood that lacks the pizzazz to complement the execution. These don't sell, generally, except to turners. Why? They're focused on technique, as they grow, and maybe haven't made that quantum leap to discriminating artist yet, if they ever will. They are simply focused on the craftsmanship, because that's what they are working toward, and may view the artistic piece through the wrong filter.

I tend to view most turned work in these terms, myself. I took part in a new member screening recently for the Craftsmen's Guild of Pittsburgh. I had to take a back seat to the potters when we were viewing ceramic work, and the jewelry makers to help me judge the jewelry. I initially disagreed with some of their opinions, until they shared the knowledge of the technique. I learned a lot more than I thought I knew about craftsmanship. They depended on me for the wood work guidance. Some of the work was incredibly artistic, but the execution was lacking. Others were well executed, but lacked the artistic flair to really grab you. As we are an organization of craftsmen, rather than artists, that is the major criteria we judged the work on, our primary focus, if you will, our filter.

As far as art versus craft, you gotta admit there's no common ground, no conventional wisdom or frame of reference. Craftsmanship is more easily recognizable to a craftsman, or a wannabe, than the general public. If you disregard the craftsmanship, it's art if it strikes you, and crap if it doesn't.

Each is allowed their interpretation.

I'm not going to flame anyone, I don't do that anymore. I will say I want the right, if I ever make that leap, to set out anything I choose, because in all fairness and truth, it's my presentation, and my message, and I have no option but to stand behind it.

Doug Trembath

Studio in the Woods

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleries?

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleri

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Greg, I believe one point of the show was to show the direction that wood turning has taken on the national level, and how regional turners fare in comparison. It's possible that an unknown regional level turner will get some national-level publicity because of this event.

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleries?

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleri

Keith Tompkins

>Well said, Doug! I am fortunate to hang out with several artists in various craft mediums. It's great to see things from someone else's perspective.

Most turners never get past the craftsmanship part, and learn to create what comes from the heart....a huge leap.

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleries?

#14

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleri

Craig Daymon

>I have a friend who is an artist. Those that know him and his work have no issues with qualifying him as such. He says that all it takes to be an artist is to call yourself an artist. (I'm not ready to do that when it comes to turning...not yet.) Sometimes it just helps with marketing to call yourself an artist.

Sometimes, and possibly something that applies to this piece, is the artist's perspective on the piece. This is frequently something that is guessed at by observers and frequently guessed at incorrectly. Proper perspective can make a big difference. I was never a fan of Picasso until I saw a show (PBS or Discovery channel) on him talking about how his style changed and for what reasons. That he believed that a photo can take a picture of a scene and that he wanted to show more sides/views than a photo could do of a subject. There was more to it than that, but I can now appreciate and enjoy a great number of Picasso's works than I did previously.

To be honest (and this is PERSONAL OPINION), I have never really considered the mentioned turner's pieces as much art as an expression of technical mastery of his craft. I'm certain there is a great deal of his work that I have not seen, but what I have seen has varied little. He is a skilled technician and as a turner that adds a great deal to my appreciation of his work. If he wants to call himself an artist, fine. I'm still free not to like pieces of his work (or anyone elses) without feeling that I don't know what I'm talking about.

-Craig

P.S. There is a great deal of value in showing work by recognized talent at a gallery. It helps bring people in and may very well help to bring recognition to others showing at the same gallery.

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleries?

#15

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleri

RussFairfield

>My opinion, and that is exactly what it is - an opinion.

The promoters need the "names" to give credibility to their exhibition, so they invite them. This is a fact of life, and we need to get used to it. Every exhibit, art fair, or show that we enter or attend will have them.

The problem arises because the work by the "names" is always something everybody has seen before, and the work by the "unknowns", whose entries go through a jury process, is always fresh and new because nobody has seen it before. That is just the another fact of life. The "names" can't do much work without our seeing it. The "unknowns" work is rarely seen outside of their own shop/studio or area.

Another fact of life is that there will always be those who think the work of the "invited artists" isn'e worthy.

Hopwever, this is a self-correcting problem. If the "name" artist sends crap to the exhibit, or their work starts getting old and dated, they won't be invited again; and a new "name" will take their place for the next exhibit or show. That's how new "names" become known.

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleries?

#16

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleri

Chris Wright

>Greg, I have been to and in both types of show and it is a hard thing. As a juried artist, you feel that everyone should have to jury; name or not, but when you're invited you find yourself with a sense of validation, (not to mention big headedness). I agree with whoever said that it is up to the invited turner to essentially put their best foot forward or embarass themselves with the work they submit. The invited artists are usually for draw of the crowds and money spending collectors. I have also seen where a top (invited) artist will for one reason or another show a piece I didn't particularly care for, but again that's just my opinion, worth 2 cents or not, it doesn't matter...someone else wanted them there.

The only advice I can truly give based on experience is always put what you feel is your best work out there for the crowds to see. If a show has 50 spots and 20 are invited, then you know you're competing for 1 of 30, not 1 of 50...the invited artists will be there whether you make it or not, so shoot for the moon and get your work in there. The worst thing that can happen is a collector comes to see someone else's work and is exposed to yours at the same time. If your work is up there in quality & execution, they will remember you as well and may even come back to see you next time.

Everyone's biggest rivalry for greatness should start inside, because if we're not striving to challenge ourselves and do the very best we can, who really cares whose pieces we are next to. The work will speak for itself and reputations will soar or suffer because of it.

Chris Wright

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleries?

#17

Can Only Artists.............Recognize Art?

Barry Turner

>We may soon get to the place where only "artists" are able to recognize works of art. And if we do.......is it really art? Actually, art is in the eye of the beholder.

Everyman's Gallery (refrigerator doors across this great land) hold the works of many budding young artists. Doting parents and grandparents are all convinced that these young artists are the next Picasso, Renoir or Monet's. I figure its art if the beholder appreciates it.

As for juries, the ultimate jury whether it sells or not. If it sells, its good. If it don't, it ain't.

Re: Should Pro's have special treatment at galleries?

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: Can Only Artists.............Recognize Art?

Keith Tompkins

>You bring up a good point, Barry. Nobody is born a "great"artist, or even a great athlete, scientist, whatever. We all are born with a certain amount of ability, it's what we decide to do with it that counts. As turners, we all make decisions that affects our careers. We can attend demos, take classes, spend more time in the shop. We can look at the work we produce and say "good enough", or we can strive to improve. We all started as novices, even the great ones.