Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

Posts

TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

#1

TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

Ed Moore

>TD,

I hope to be in a position to buy a lathe soon. If one aims high there is the Oneway 2436, the Robust 25 - 28, and the Stubby 1000. Your choice there? Why?

But suppose reality strikes and I have to aim a little lower. It would seem like a Oneway 1640 with extension would be about the same as a Vicmarc VL300 with the bells and whistles, or a Stubby 750. Your choice there? Why?

The impact of your answer will depend on the quality of the Why's.

I know that you aren't busy right now, but thought that you might like to chew on this one. ;^D

Thanks,

Ed

Re: TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

#2

Honestly.....

TDaniel

>I have no experience with the Stubby or the Robust so I cannot comment on them. The Vicmarc VL300 I do have and use it daily. It could be one of the best lathes out there but it falls short in a couple of areas and it excels in a couple of areas. The toolrest banjo needs redesigned; it isn't the worst one out there but it sure isn't the best either. Another thing I do not like is there is no interlock switch to prevent starting the lathe with the spindle locked. This is especially bad when I have a student because they will forget to unlock the spindle and start the motor back up....not good on belts. On the other hand, the factory cabinet and motor/controller are tops. Vicmarc could make a few changes and improve their crating and service and become one of the best lathes available.

One-way is tops; they listen to their customers, they help their customers, and they are a pleasure to do business with. This may not be important to some but to me it is very important and worth more of my money. I was also impressed with the crating; the machine got here without a scratch. Unfortunately, almost every Vicmarc I received was scratched, had broken switches, etc because of the poor crating. When I make a big purchase the company behind the product is just as important as the product. Which would I buy? No doubt at all it would be a One-way if I wanted a bed lathe; of course I would not give up my VB. Before you make a decision you should try all these lathes and see which has the features that are important to you becuase your needs and mine make not be the same.

TD

Re: TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

#3

Re: Honestly...../ W^5

Ed Moore

>W^5 = Which Was What We Wanted

Thanks, TD. I came on the Robust when I was researching a Vicmarc. It has intrigued me because I like the design principles and its obvious sturdiness. That said, my current lathes are a Oneway 1016 and a Stubby 500 (no longer imported) and I like them both, no complaints about either, I just need something for bigger bowls. So I have no prejudices against any of the lathes that I listed.

If money were no concern (yes, I'm kidding) I think the Robust 25x28 with the tilt-away feature would be my first choice. And it does have the spindle-lock disconnect, which is a good feature as you said.

But money may be a concern, and I find the Vicmarc to be my probable choice, but your comments about the 1640 got me thinking there and the outcome is by no means certain. I appreciated your frankness about the shipping problems. (I'm the dummy who let his new 21" bandsaw slip out the back of his pickup on the way up our hill. Yes! Shipping crates matter. I lucked out with LeNeave.)

Thanks for your answer. I hope others will chip in.

I hope that you and lots of my electronic friends have a great time at your Gathering. Wish I could have been there, maybe next time ...

Ed

Re: TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

#4

Re: Honestly...../ W^5

Phil Powell

>Ed,

I have a Robust 25 and have been turning on it since early fall. Like you I

had a tough decision. I was between the Vicmarc and Stubby. I hadn't heard

of Robust.After seeing the add in the back of the AAW magazine, I contacted

Brent English at Robust and from the first moment I was impressed with the

personal service he offered. The entire lathe is made in Wi. and the warrenty

is iron clad for 7 years. Several times since my purchase Brent has contacted

me by email asking if I had concerns. The machine is an animal and will do

anything I've asked and then some. The tilt away tail is worth the investment

and that's a fact. The moveable head stock, adjustable legs, stainless steal

ways and the many other standard features make this lathe an excellent purchase.

Re: TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

#5

Re: Honestly...../ W^5

Ed Moore

>Phil,

TD was concerned about banjos and slipping. Does the Robust banjo hold as securely as the vaunted Oneway's? (Note: I have absolutely nothing against Oneway lathes.)

I will also send you a private post.

Thanks,

Ed

Re: TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

#6

Re: Honestly...../ W^5

Phil Powell

>Ed,

I have absolutely no problems with the the banjo or the tail section

moving while working. The locking mechanism seems very strong

and fool proof. I've turned on a OneWay and a Vicmarc...not a Stubby.

In most cases I prefer my Robust. But then I assume owners of other

lathes would say the same.

Re: TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

#7

Re: Honestly...../ W^5 - Go Robust

georgetroy

>I think highly of the American Made Robust lathe. I have the 18"x25". I would sell my other 3 and use the money to purchase a Robust 25x28 with 3hp and tilt-away tailstock. My 3 lathes that I would sell are and I'm really not listing them at this time. Who knows: they are in Central Kansas.

DVR with stand for $1400 see at this sight. http://groups.msn.com/NovaOwners

Vicmarc 175 Longbed. with outboard turning attachment and extra 16" tool rest for $2800.

http://groups.msn.com/VicmarcOwnersGroup

Vicmarc 300 shortbed from Australia with outboard and extra toolrest. $3500.

http://groups.msn.com/VicmarcOwnersGroup

If any of this is of interest to you, let me know and we can discuss details and you can see them in my shop. George Troy Hurlburt

Re: TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

#8

The offer was made...

TDaniel

>to have a Robust here for our Gathering so we could evaluate it.

Re: TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

#9

Re: TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

Russell L. Babbitt Jr.

>If you intend to do long spindles you choice would be Oneway or Vicmarc. Both are excellent. I have used the Vicmarc, liked it and have heard good things from others. I heard of one turner turning a long bed post on a Oneway 2436 and he felt it had a vibration when using the bed extension. My experience with the Stubby 750 was very nice. Incredibly stable, rock solid. Very versatile the way the bed slides to accept different size pieces. I would consider the Stubby a "bowl" lathe.

Its nice to hear someone considering lathes like these instead of something from HF.

Re: TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

#10

Re: TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

Jim Pugh, Ohio

>This has been a nice discussion where folks, for the most part, attempted to answer the question asked. I feel that too many times when a person asks about a specific lathe all the answers are that "my brand" is the one to buy.

In the last sentence the word "lathe" can be changed to chucks/turning tools/finish/etc.

Hope ya'll have a great time at TD's this week.

Jim

Re: TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

#11

Re: The offer was made... - Question

Ed Moore

>TD,

Did Brent English offer to bring a Robust to the Gathering?

Or did the Gathering offer Brent a chance to bring a Robust?

Ed

Re: TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

#12

Re: TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

Ed Moore

>Thanks to each of our contributors. I know what I want, I can justify that choice, now where did I hide that money? ...

Thanks,

Ed

Re: TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

#13

Re: TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

Brent English - Robust Tools

>Hi - first thanks to all for the kind words and Thanks to Terry for his invite. Unfortunately, another commitment keeps me from Terry's gathering, but do look for a Robust lathe at the Southern States Symposium in Gainesville GA this weekend,

Ed, send me an email, I'm cooking up something you might really like. I haven't told you about it yet. You could be first.

Brent English - Robust Tools

Re: TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

#14

Brent! You have my attention!

Ed Moore

>Okay, lay it on me. I sent you a private e-mail.

Ed

Re: TD - 1640 vs Vicmarc VL300 vs Stubby 750 ??

#15

The Gathering offered to let Brent bring a Robust

TDaniel

>