Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Something different

Posts

Something different

#1

Something different

Kudzu

>I read and don't post much here. But I know you can get an honest critique here.

I am not sure what you would call this? But it started out as very rough piece of loctus I was playing with. I am luke warm on it but wanted to get some input from others. I have still not finished sanding all the edges or put a finish on it other than some BLO.




Re: Something different

#2

Re: Something different

Russell L. Babbitt Jr.

>It's interesting. I like it, I think. Great piece of wood. I think I would have taken it to a "regular" bowl shape, just my opinion.

Re: Something different

#3

JL

Re: Keep the irregular shape..

JL

>but smooth it out some. Maybe deepen the bowl portion just a shade? It is a nice chunk of wood.

Re: Something different

#4

Re: Something different

john lucas

>I'm guilty of this as well but Ideally if you decide to cut the sides there should be some reason to it. In other words the cut sides should somehow work together or work with the piece. It's a difficult thing to do. My last platter had cut sides. They were that way when I got the piece. It was OK and sold this weekend so someone liked it. I really should have re-cut the sides to create some lines for you eye to follow or a pattern that fits some shape we know.

Good job on the turning and it's quite nice the way it is. I'm just throwing out suggestions for possible improvement. The same kind of critic I do on my own work.

Re: Something different

#5

Re: Something different

Kudzu

>John, I think you hit on what I don't like about it. Its the sides, there is no flow to it. If they were more natural edged or had a better flow. I had not been able to decide what it was but I think that is it.

I am not sure how it ended up with shape it did. I started with a (more or less) square blank?