Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Steel comparison?

Posts

Steel comparison?

#1

Steel comparison?

Bob Fawcett

>Has anyone done a comparison of all the steels available in tools?

Most seem to be M2, some M4, and various powder metals. Some claim extended time between sharpenings. Are there really big differences or just a way to sell more tools?

Re: Steel comparison?

#2

Re: Tool steels - Part 1

RussFairfield

>It just happens that I have a rather long article in my working file. It follows in its entirity. There is a follow up and that is in the next message. My analogies will drive a metallurgist nuts, but that will be their problem.

Points to ponder - #1

Too many woodturners are looking for that magical tool that never needs sharpening. Like the 200mpg carburetor, they think that modern technology should be able to provide this to them. The tool manufacturers have capitalized on this desire with "new" tools that are sold on basis of advertising claims such as "new and better", "Powdered Metallurgy" because it is better, "durability", greater hardness, and a lot of technical terms that nobody understands. It must be working because all of the catalogs are filled with these tools. They are purchased solely on the basis that they don't have to sharpened as often.

We never consider such things as whether the steel alloy is even suitable for use as a tool, that it may be too brittle for a small diameter tool, how sharp and edge we can get on it, what grinding wheel and speed should be used, or whether we should be using a coolant for grinding these steels. Only Jerry Glaser and a few lesser known manufacturers have continued to make turning tools whose metallurgy is matched to the size and use of the tool.

Making a scraper from the new high-alloy steels is a step in the wrong direction. I doesn�t matter if the burr is put on a scraper with the heat from a grinding wheel or by displacement of the steel at the edge with a burnisher, the sharpness and quality of the burr decreases with the increasing alloy and particle sizes in the steel.

We can use a rather simplistic analogy. Think of a piece of high carbon tool steel as a package of "corn flakes", and the high alloy as the same box filled with BBs and golf balls. When softened by the heat from a grinding wheel, the "flakes" at the cutting edge are bent upwards to form a burr that is the thickness of a single flake that is still attached to the other flakes in the package. The "flakes" have enough ductility that they can also be bent with the pressure of a burnishing tool.

The farther we get away from the box filled with "flakes", and more towards the box that is filled with BBs and golf balls, the more difficult it is to form a thin burr on the edge. Some of these high alloys will have 50% of the flakes replaced by the BBs and golf balls, and there aren't enough of the "flakes" remaining to form the burr.

Using a burnisher depends on the ductility of the steel. The higher alloys have a stronger bond between the BBs and golf balls, they are less ductile, and it becomes more difficult to move the metal as their number increases.

We have to consider what we are trying to do. These tool alloys were developed for cutting steels and not wood. The machanics are different. When a steel is cut with a tool, a small crack is propogated ahead of the cutting edge. The tool wear is then the result of errosion of the tool surface behind the cutting edge. It is not unusual to have a burr of metal bonded to the cutting edge to fill the void that is created by that small crack.

Wood is separated by two mechanisms. The cellulose is either sliced with apart with a very sharp edge, or it is ripped apart with a tearing action. We can use the comparison of "shearing" a sheet of paper with a scissors as opposed to "tearing" it apart with force. We would always prefer the "slicing" to the "tearing". But the "slicing" starts to become the "tearing" as the edge loses its ability to cut through the fibers. It doesn't matter whether the change is because the edge of the sharp "flakes" has worn away, or that the edge was never sharp because it is filled with BBs and golf balls, the result is the same.

This same analogy can be applied to describe the differences in the cutting edge in a "sharp edged" tool that doesn't require a burr. It has to do with the sizes of the particles and how many of them are in the alloy. The edge of a single flat "flake" of steel is sharper than that same edge with a lot of BB's and a few golf balls in it. These BBs and golf balls are harder and will wear less than the "corn flakes", but they will never be as sharp.

The far end of the alloying spectrum is a "carbide" where all of the flakes have been displaced from the box and it is filled with nothing but the BBs and golf balls. They are bonded very tightly together, they are very durable, but they don't make a very sharp edge for "slicing" through wood fibers.

Where we want our tools to fit into this specturm of "corn flakes" to BBs and golf balls is the choice of the user. My choices are as follows....

SKEW -

This is a tool where the sharper the edge and the smaller the bevel angle, the better it cuts. It is impossible to make the edge of a skew "too sharp". For this reason, any alloy greater than an M-2 HSS is detrimental to having a "sharp" tool.

SCRAPERS -

High Carbon steel makes the better burr, but M-2 HSS is a good compromise between the sharp edge and durability. An M-4 steel is marginal, and anything of a higher alloy than that is a waste of money because the tool is no longer useful.

GOUGES -

An M-4 or similar HSS is the best compromise between durability and sharpness for most turning, and I have slowly replaced nearly all of my gouges with the M-4.

I have a 3/4" diameter high-alloy that I reserve for roughing cuts on large pieces, abrasive woods, bark edges, and nails; all places where I want a durable tool and the surface finish and tear-out aren't important. This is also a large diameter tool where strength is more impoprtant than flexibility, and I sometimes wish that I had one of them that was 1" diameter.

I still use a High Carbon tool steel as a finishing tool for spindle work because the sharper edge will leave a smoother finish on the surface of the wood.

PARTING TOOL -

Like the skew, the parting tool is better when it is sharper. I use a parting tool a lot for spindle turning, and the quality of the cut is important to me. For this reason, I prefer an M-2 steel for this tool. I purchased a 2030 alloy parting tool, but the sharpest edge that I can get on it is about where I would take the M-2 tool back to the grinder. There is no advantage in having an almost dull tool that will stay that way for a longer time.

ROUGHING GOUGES -

This is a tool that truely needs to be redesigned. It was originally made to be used as a curved skew for spindle turning where we are riding the bevel and all of the cutting forces are straight back into the handle; and there is very little bending force at the tang. Any use that puts a bending force on the tool can cause a problem and using a less ductile alloy for the tool only increases the problem because then it will break, rather than bend, at the tang. The larger this tool is made the worse the problem becomes because the thickness at the tang remains the same.

The modification of adding a piece of brass rod across the tank is a good one. Besides being a stiffer tool, the added weight is a benefit. It doesn't even have to be brazed in place to be beneficial. Bedding it into the tool with a flexible epoxy works as well as brazing. I have always wondered why some tool manufacturer hasn't started making them. I used to make this modification to the tools. It seemed like a good way to make a couple dollars, but I had to give up because I couldn't charge enough to compensate for the tool cost and the time required to modify it.

I see that P&N now makes a roughing gouge that is machined from a piece of round bar stock.

This message has become too long, but I hope that it will add something to the discussion.

Re: Steel comparison?

#3

Re: Too Steels - Paert 2

RussFairfield

>Points To Ponder-No.2

I was trying to convey a simple description without writing a textbook on the metallurgy of tool steels, and bringing such words as martensite, austenite, boundary layers, eutectic, and a few others into the discussion. A thorough discussion of tool steels will require more educational background than a lot of the folks reading this will have, and more time than I am willing to give. Thus the corn-flakes, BBs and golf balls analogy. I could have added "sugar" and "raisins", but I have preferred to use the BBs and Golf Balls analogy because of their relative size and hardness as compared to the "corn flakes". The problem with such an analogy is that it reduces the complex to simplified terms, and not everything will fit. I will be the first to admit that it is a crude analogy and that a metallurgist would crings at the analogy; but it is suitable for a non-technical discussion of the metallurgy of tool steels. The subject of tool steels is far more complex than can be discussed on this forum. If anyone wants a course in metallurgy, I am available on a fee- basis for individual or group instruction. There are also suitable textbooks available on the subject.

To expand on this discussion a bit...

Steel is not a homogenious solution of molecules such as we would get by dissolving sugar into water where the molecules of the sugar are fit in between the molecules of the water. Rather, it is an mixture of many larger particles. These are the the corn-flakes in my analogy, but properly referred to as "grain" particles. The properties of the individual "flakes" or grains are determined by the crystalline structure of the iron itself, and by the size of the individual "flake". These "flakes" can be identified by their size and properties. We can further separate them into some of the flakes being very hard and brittle, while others will be soft and ductile. Some will be larger or smaller than the others. All of these various "flakes" will be present in a steel, and their quantity and whether they are isolated into even larger chunks or distributed throughout the mixture will determine the properties of the steel.

Carbon is added in various quantities to change the iron into a steel. In the simple terms of the "corn flakes" analogy, the Carbon fits between the individual flakes, bonds them together by retarding the movement the movement between them. It is the "sugar" that we can add to the "flakes". The higher the carbon content, the greater the retardation of movement between the "flakes", and the less ductile and harder the steel becomes. Add to that the variations in the size, structure, and different properties of the individual "flakes", and the groupings of flakes and the subject of Carbon Steels becomes a very complex one.

Adding the alloying metals (the BBs and golf balls) is the same as adding the carbon particles to the steel mixture. The primary alloying metals in tool steels are Vanadium, Molybdenum, Tungsten, Silicon, and Chromium. These alloys are not distributed homogenously or uniformly throughout the structure of the steel. Instead, these alloys are distributed along the boundarys and the voids between the grain structure (the "corn flakes") of the steel, they do retain their separate identity in the mixture, and they do accumulate into much larger quantities between the "flakes" (the grain boundaries) and further separate them. As their quantity increases, the steel will be dominated by the alloying metals, and it will start to assume their properties. In sufficient quantity, the "flakes" of steel will become separated to the point where they will lose their magnetic attraction and the steel will no longer be magnetic.

The quality and type of the steel depends on the type and size of the "flakes", and the quantity and distribution of the alloying metals and elements. Mixing all of this together in a molten pot, and then cooling into a predictable result requires a skill and control of the process that approaches "magic". There are also a few things that cannot be done with alloying metals in a process that requires a molten state.

Enter "Powdered Metallurgy" (PM). The size and composition of the individual grain (the "corn flake")of the steel, the particles of Carbon, alloying metals, and other elements are all determined by the individual particles that are used. The prescribed quantities of these particles are mixed together while they are in a dry powder form. Then they are placed in a mold where they are heated under pressure until they are bonded (welded). The mixture never reaches the molten state, and individual particles are not melted into a uniform solution. Instead, they retain the size and distribution in the mixture that they were in while still in the powdered form.

There is nothing really different or magical about the end product from a PM process. The result is a Quality Control issue through control of the kinds, sizes, quantities, and distribution of the various particles that are used to make up the alloy. It allows for molding the steel into complex shapes without machining. And, it allows the formation of alloys that could not be made if the mixture were allowed to reach the molten state.

Throughout all of this infinite number of combinations of steels and alloys with their different structures, particle sizes and distribution, there are some that are better suited for use as a cutting tool for wood than are others. The V-15 that Jerry Glaser uses is an example of a steel that was selected to yield the better properties of the tool steel while making the least number of compromises of edge and cutting quality. For having done this for us, we will have to pay a $100 premium over the cost of the next most expensive tool on the market.

The V-15 is a 15% Vanadium, which is still a rather mild alloy compared to many on the market. This steel is well suited for the tools that Jerry makes from it, but like all alloy steels, it is not suitable for everything. We should notice that Jerry uses a softer A-11 (11% Vanadium) steel for his scrapers and skew chisels. This steel has similar properties to the M-4 that I prefer, and my preference is to a milder M-2 alloy for these purposes.

Unfortunately, not all of the tool manufacturers have given such care in matching the steel to the tool. Instead of doing this, they are making every tool imaginable from every available tool steel alloy, making all kinds of claims about their improved durability, and leaving it up to the user to determine which steels are suitable for which tools and uses.

My opinion is still that, other than Jerry Glasers selection of alloys, the M-2 and M-4 High Speed Steels make the better woodturning tools. I could argue the case for using High Carbon tool steels for gouges used for finishing cuts, and for all skews and scrapers. A case could be made for using the 2030 steels. But, the 2060 is not suitable for any tool other than one that is used for cutting abrasive wood, bark, and nails.

This is my final message on tool steels. Any more than this, and I will be writing a book on the subject; and I will do that only when somebody offers to pay me for the effort. {8>)

Sorry, but there is not a quick answer to your short question.

Re: Steel comparison?

#4

Thanks Russ

Bob Fawcett

>Great articles. You offer a lot of insight into the steels and what tools they should be used for. A beginer like me is easily convinced that a good steel is good for all tools. Obviosly not the case after reading your article.

Much of this reminds me of the never ending arguments amoung knifemakers over what to use to make knives.

All steels are a compromise the trick is to find the best one for the job at hand.

I should concentrate on the turning and forget about the steel of teh tool, just keep it sharp.

Thanks again.

If you do right the book, I will buy it.

Re: Steel comparison?

#5

Re: Too Steels - Paert 2

Dave Belser

>Thanks for taking the time Russ.

I was considering the purchase of a new gouge for roughing bowls - primarily for a longer handle. I'll think twice before springing for an extra fancy alloy now.

- Dave

Re: Steel comparison?

#6

Re: Tool steels - Part 1 Clarification

RussFairfield

>I need to clarify the grinding of the tools.

I read through the articles again, and I think I am giving the impression that the high allow steels cannot be sharpened sufficiently to use them as a cutting tool for wood. The truth is that it is possible to grind a sharper edge on the high alloy steels, and even a carbide tool. The problem is that most of us don't have a grinder in our shop that is capable of abrading the hard alloy particles and making them smaller. This will require a harder wheel than the Aluminum Oxide wheels that we use on our grinders, and in most cases would require a coolant. They could be easilly sharpened to a keen edge with a diamond wheel.

In the case of a carbide tool, it takes a diamond wheel to achieve the sharp edge that we need for cutting wood; and that would also be used with a coolant mist while sharpening the tool.

So, within the constraints of the grinding wheels and other abrasives that we have in our shops, and what we are willing to pay for, everything I have said is valid.

Re: Steel comparison?

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: Tool steels - Part 1 Clarification

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks Russ, From a practical , non-scientific viewpoint, I find my M2 tools are the ones I find myself using on a regular basis. I have found that some of the "longer lasting" alloys such as 2060 are brittle, and dull quickly as the edge seems to chip away. I just like the way my M2 tools take an edge. All of my carving tools are old, old, high carbon steel and are a joy to use.

Re: Steel comparison?

#8

Re: Too Steels - Paert 2

Bill Crommett

>Russ: On the contrary, you have given a short concise answer to the problems of woodturners and their steels. It was a much more understandable text than I have gotten from discussions of austentites carbites, etc. in the several texts I have perused. We owe you !

Bill

Re: Steel comparison?

#9

JL

Re: Thanks for the dissertation..

JL

>It's much appreciated. Could both parts go in the articles section?

Re: Steel comparison?

#10

Re: Tool steels - Part 1/Excellent analysis

Ed Moore

>Russ,

I found your comments "spot on" as the Brits would say. You mentioned that you have switched to gouges that are all M4. I have been working on some bowls lately and have become really impressed with some bowl gouges I had gotten from Oneway. So, I checked their website a few minutes ago and sure enough, Oneway uses an excellent M4 steel for the gouges. They get sharp and they stay sharp for a long time.

Thanks for a good overview,

Ed