Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Advice for Sandpaper Purchase

Posts

Advice for Sandpaper Purchase

#1

Advice for Sandpaper Purchase

Jerry Hall

>I have been turning for a couple years, and have about used up the odds and ends of sandpaper from my flat work. I am about to make a big purchase of sheets and bulk H&L stock and am somewhat overwhelmed by the variety of products and choices. I have bought individual sheets and have formed some tentative opinions. I would appreciate comments, recommendations on the following:

8-1/2 by 11 Sheets: I have narrowed it down to Mirka and Norton 3x. I like both but Norton 3X paper seems softer, more flexible, a bit lighter and is real tough. I don't understand the Klingspor choices in sheet paper and their differences so I have ruled them out. Opinions?

Hook and Loop Stock: I have come to prefer cutting my own disks to fit and overlap my shop made Roloc based disk pads based on foam and leather. I dedicate one pad to each grit. I have been using my stock of sticky PSA rolls to make the disks. I plan to convert them to hook and loop, cutting my disks as I need them to the size I need from sheet or roll stock. I am considering the Industrial Abrasives 1M x 1Yd sheets, and the Klingspor Stearate Kling-on 4-1/2" rolls. Each is about 1c per sq inch. I like the rolls from a storing and handling perspective. I know nothing about the softness of the backing and the quality of the abrasive for each. Opinions?

Grits: Russ recommends getting them all: "...start with 60 or 80, and proceed through 100, 120, 150, 180, 220, 250, 280, 320, and stop at 400" Is this a consensus? That's a bit more stock to get! I have been doing 60 or 80,100,150,220,320,400 but have to admit that I still fight and often live with the migration of subtle scratches into finished pieces, altho I am getting closer to the standard I want by improving my technicue. Opinions?

I know this is a lot to ask. Any help in any of the areas will be much appreciated.

Jerry

Re: Advice for Sandpaper Purchase

#2

before you do all this....

TDaniel

>try a couple of the new purple ceramic discs bt 3M. You can get them at: www.the sandingglove.com

I like them much better than hook and loop as the heat generated in aggressive sanding doesn't hurt them nearly as much. They also clean are easily cleaned with a rubber stick.

As far as sanding, be prepared for a cloud of dust like you have never seen because these discs are very aggressive. If you would normally start with 80 grit you might start with 120 with these. I still use the Norton 3X for 400 and Klingspor 600, 1000, 1200.

I don't worry about trying to save by cutting my own as I can make more while turning than I can save while cutting discs.

TD

Re: Advice for Sandpaper Purchase

#3

Re: Advice for Sandpaper Purchase

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>I use the same grits you have been using. I usually start with 180 or 220. But that depends on the wood and the skill level. I sometimes start with 80 to 320, so you need them from 80 on up.

Re: Advice for Sandpaper Purchase

#4

Re: before you do all this....

robo hippy

>I buy 10 yard rolls 12 inches wide from Klingspor. They aren't advertised, but when I asked, they said that they could make the rolls wider, as the rolls they cut their stocd from are 60 inches plus wide. I also have access to a small clicker press (some leather shops have them). I do like my discs slightly oversized also.A piece of 3, 2, and 1 inch inside diameter pipe, ream the inside out slightly, double bevel the cutting edge (like a skew chisel, not like a bench chisel), harden it, use a 3/4 thick piece of poly whatever for a board. On the press, I can cut out 2,000 pieces (punch out 5 layers thick) in about an hour. You can use a sledge (with wood block on top of the cutter), or large arbor press, and still cut out several layers at a time. I haven't tried the purple sanding discs. I heard that Klingspor has their gold paper in h and l now, but haven't tried that out. I have grits from 80 to 400, and use the 80 the least.

robo hippy

Re: Advice for Sandpaper Purchase

#5

Re: before you do all this....

Jerry Hall

>Terry, you said "....I still use the Norton 3X for 400 and Klingspor 600, 1000, 1200."

Thanks for the good ideas. I will give purple a try. I note that the purple disks are PSA. Are materials you mentioned above (400 and above) disks of PSA, H&L, or is it sheet stock for hand sanding? Or are you mixing PSA and H&L depending on grit.

I have been happy with the PSA I have been using in many ways, so this direction you suggest can work for me. The PSA has no hard edge as you can get with a H&L pad. It just seemed that most people use H&L. Maybe it's because they don't have a dedicated pad for each grit as I do with my 3M Roloc system.

Jerry

Re: Advice for Sandpaper Purchase

#6

no H & L for me

TDaniel

>I quit using hook and loop. It is much cheaper to use adhesive back material because it will tolerate a lot more heat without damaging the paper or the pad. I dedicate a separate pad for each grit. You can get spray adhesive for the finer grits.

Re: Advice for Sandpaper Purchase

#7

Re: Advice for Sandpaper Purchase

Steve Worcester

>I will leave the comments on the actual paper choice to others, but I would say 60, 80, 120, 180 ,250, 320, 400 and up if you would use it. I don't see a need to go 220,250,280, the micron sizes are close enough that on in the mid 200s is sufficient.

Steve Worcester

www.turningwood.com

Re: Advice for Sandpaper Purchase

#8

Thanks. Here is my next move

Jerry Hall

>Thanks for the great responses. As a result of this feedback, and my experience to date I plan to make an incremental change:

1. Keep using my Roloc based, foam/leather covered pads. I like their softness and conformability, they are fast to change and easy and cheap to make in multiple sizes.

2. "Stick" with PSA/spray adhesive attached disks for now, and postpone H&L. I like the way the disks wrap around the leather for a soft edge.

3. Try a few of the purple disks TD recommended in the lower grits, and Norton 3x for my basic stock

4. Go with grits: (60,) 80, 120, 180, 240, 320, 400

5. Work on my technique: tool control, get to a higher beginning grit, slower sanding speeds, better light and examination between grits, sand with the grain by hand after I have power sanded across the grain.

This incremental change means a modest investment in new materials, and then I can reassess when my new inventory runs out.

Thanks again, Jerry