Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Ebony or Blackwood

Posts

Ebony or Blackwood

#1

Ebony or Blackwood

Allen Neighbors

>Hope this question isn't too dumb.... I know Jennifer and Carole sometimes use Ebony or Blackwood? in their turnings. Please explain to me what Blackwood is, and also explain the differences between Ebony and Blackwood as far as turnability, and costs.

Thanks for your replies.

Allen

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Allen. They are different species, both heavy, dense, and usually black in color.

Typically, I find the African blackwood harder and denser of the two, and since it is rather oily, harder to glue. there are several different ebonies, some almost pure black, some streaked with brown and white tones. Both turn well, and are among my favorite woods to turn. Some turners say blackwood is too dense to cut, scraping methods work better. With sharp tools, I find it cuts cleanly.

They are both expensive.

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

#3

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

Carole Valentine

>Allen,

I have only used Blackwood so far. I have some Ebony, but I am in love with African Blackwood so I just have not tried the Ebony yet. I will try some for a collar tomorrow and let you know which I like better. Keith is right, they both are very expensive. I do know that Blackwood turns beautifully. If you turn it properly, no sanding is needed. I do NOT scrape it...I use a gouge and it comes off in crinkly black ribbons. I use the flexible CA glue and so far (which is not saying much since it hasn't been that long) I haven't had a problem. I was a tad miffed the other day when someone asked me if a Blackwood collar on one of my pieces was plastic!!! I still am not quite sure if I should take that as a compliment or an insult! LOL

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

#4

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>There are many different ebony species, worldwide, all in the genus Diospyros. These include the persimmons, including one that is native of the Eastern US, and another that is grown here commercially for the fruit. I have turned some of these, and I like the results I get. Persimmon is also used for golf club heads.

African blackwood is a single species, Dalbergia melanoxylon in the rosewood genus. It is confined to two or three countries in East Africa, and is endagered, due to over harvesting and poor management techniques. This is the wood from which clarinets and other woodwinds are made. I haven't worked with it.

Many of the ebony species have some lighter colors than black. Some remind me of partially stirred cafe au lait. For example, the third from the top in this photo. The top one is also made of an ebony. The other two are rosewoods, specifically cocobolo. I don't know if the pores in African blackwood are as open as other rosewoods, and I don't know if they need to be filled. Maybe someone else can help out? The ebony I have worked with does not need to be filled to yield a perfectly smooth surface.


Re: Ebony or Blackwood

#5

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

john lucas

>Carole I turned an ebony finial once and polished it to a high grit. I was a little miffed because it looked like plastic. I didn't like it and knocked down the gloss until it looked like wood again.

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

#6

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

Ron in Drums PA

>Carole said, "I was a tad miffed the other day when someone asked me if a Blackwood collar on one of my pieces was plastic!!! I still am not quite sure if I should take that as a compliment or an insult! LOL "

I've had the same happen to me on some box lids turned from ebony. Now when I buy ebony, I look for pieces with brown streaks.

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

#7

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

Jorge Castaneda

>William,

I have just started using black wood, I have what looks like two diferent species, or perhaps just a case where some of my pieces were made from small branches, and have sapwood in one or both sides, and some pores, not objectionable, the other pieces are totally black and smooth as the provervial princess ... no pores, both machine very well with sharp tools and burnish beautifully with the skew.

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

#8

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

Mac

>Jorge....What's a SKEW?

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

#9

Re: My thanks to all of you

Allen Neighbors

>for the many different responses.

Carole, I thought that too... :o) once... until you named the wood.

William, where'd you learn all that? That's some really good information, but when I want to remember it, I probably won't.

I know I'm going to have to find some of both, somewhere... I want to try it for finials and lids... I now know it will be worth the hunt.

Thanks again, all.

Allen

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

#10

Re: My thanks to all of you

Mark Kauder. Phenix City, AL

>Alan,

You can find African Blackwood, and Gabon Ebony (the blackest Ebony). I have used both. In Segmented turning, I generally am searching for the color so there is no real difference for me in the color relm. Most Blackwood has at least a little brown streaking.

The Prices are much different. Blackwood is in the $30-40 a board foot. Ebony is $70-100 a board foot. Keith is right, ebony is a little harder and denser.

I enjoy turning both.

All that said. What we all call African Blackwood, is the original Ebony - when you hear of Ebony in historical texts (like the Bible, or in ancient Egypt), the writer is actually talking about African Blackwood.

Mark

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

#11

Jorge

Jorge Castaneda

>Mac, It is a particular case of the bowl gouge where excentricity equals zero... : )

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

#12

Re: My thanks to all of you

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks, Mark. That's good to know. I get into researching the Old Testament, and recently became interested in the woods mentioned (go figure). :o) I recently fell heir to a chunk of Chittum Wood, and I'm bringing some of it to TD's. It's beautiful and hard, and polishes really well.

Allen

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

#13

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>You won't have that problem with Black and White Ebony. It's mostly an ivory color, with streaks of black. Many of the black streaks seem to start at borer holes, however, and run up and down the wood, so when you run into these, you will probably want to fill them. I use epoxy with some vegetable black pigment mixed in, because it also takes a nice polish. Black and White Ebony is also called Indian Persimmon, Diospyros embryopteris.The biggest problem I have with using this stuff is calling it "Ivory" instead of "Ebony".

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

#14

Re: My thanks to all of you

Ed Moore

>Great info! Where does Mun Ebony fit into all this? I bought some to make small boxes with, but got sidetracked. Some day ...

Ed

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

#15

Re: African Blackwood vs Ebony differences

K.S.SONG

>I import and sell African Blackwood(with other African species) in Korea and enjoy woodturning.

I hope these photos could be helpful for you about African Blackwood vs Ebony differences.

Left side of photos is 'Afrcian Blackwood', right side is 'Ebony'.

"Afrcian Blackwood" = "Mpingo" in Swahili language, East Africa.

This 'Mpingo' species has very much defects and so very poor yield ratio & productivity than 'Ebony', and caused higher price-up than 'Ebony'.

I love 'African Blackwood'(Mpingo).

K.S.SONG / Seoul Korea

-----

Please help!!!

I failed to uproad photos. It says 'Graphic Too Large!'

I will send my two photos to webmaster@woodcentral.com.

Re: Ebony or Blackwood

#16

Re: My thanks to all of you

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>I have some research strategies I use, mostly books and Google. For North American trees, I use an old Golden field guide. For exotics, there are other books that provide photos, distribution maps and, most important, the scientific names of the plants. Both species and genus are important. Then I ask Google to find the scientific name. If I can't find the scientific name, I ask Google to find it for me, by searching for the common name and "species". Usually, I have to read several of the links that Google gives me to sort out the ones that know what they are talking about from those who don't. After a while, you can tell. Note also that even with species and genus, there is the issue of synonymy, so sometimes that has to be sorted out, too, and there are enormous numbers of mistakes and overlaps with the common names. (Try searching for "ironwood species" if you want some "fun" trying to sort things out. )

I think someone mentioned "Mpingo" as a local common name for D. melanoxylon. Another is "Mufunjo", so you might want to Google that one as well for more information.

Another great resource is the USDA Forest Products Laboratory Wood Identification Center. It's the place to go to find out what turning characteristics you can expect from a wood you've never turned. If you study it for a while, and compare the physical properties of woods you have turned and understand well, to the unfamiliar wood, you can get lots of valuable clues. That's how I figured out I wanted to find some hophornbeam to use to make a carving mallet. I found it, turned the mallet, and it works as well as I had expected.