Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Help on chucking bowl with new G3

Posts

Help on chucking bowl with new G3

#1

Help on chucking bowl with new G3

Wayne Leach

>Hi All,

This is only about the 6th bowl I have turned (and the largest at about 8"diameter)as I was waiting for a chuck which I thought would make the job more enjoyable.

After turning the basic shape using a faceplate and recessing a dovetailed bottom for the chuck, I chucked the bowl in my new Nova G3 and supported the tailstock end with a live center before hollowing the bowl. While hollowing, the bowl started wobling and upon investigation, the jaws had split the recessed area as shown in the photo.

I did not think I tightened it too much but have a history of overtightening everything according to the wife? Perhaps I removed too much material which weakened the bowl. The material is black ash with no visible cracks?

Any help on how to chuck a bowl to preclude this from happening would be much appreciated!


img

Re: Help on chucking bowl with new G3

#2

Re: Help on chucking bowl with new G3

Barry Turner

>Hold the bowl with a 2" stub tenon instead. No splitting. I suspect you tightened too tight and removed too much material on this one.

Re: Help on chucking bowl with new G3

#3

Re: Help on chucking bowl with new G3

georgetroy

>You could use your chuck in the compression mode. 3/8" tenion will do the trick. In the expansion mode less is much better using a dovetail of 1/8-3/16". On small platters I have done only 1/16". If you had more wood left where you used the expansion mode the bowl you just made would not have cracked. You can recover the job by using button jaws or a jamb chuck, made a new bottom and go from there. GT

Re: Help on chucking bowl with new G3

#4

Re: Help on chucking bowl with new G3 *LINK*

john lucas

>Wayne You would need more wood on the base of the recess to keep from breaking the lip. Expansion is not the best way to turn a bowl but will work if done properly.

Here's my procedure. Mount the bowl between centers. Turn the outside and turn a tenon for the chuck with the bottom of the bowl at the tailstock end. At this stage don't be super particular about the finesse of the shape because when you reverse it to put it in the chuck it may not align perfectly. Turn the foot if you can and then turn the tenon for the chuck. Make the tenon shorter than the jaws of the chuck and it should be square where the tenon meets the bottom of the bowl. Also leave the area where the tailstock had been but turn it down so it will fit inside the center of the chuck. This will be used to align the bowl when reverse turning.

Now mount the bowl in the chuck. True up the outside. Now you can hollow the inside. Sand the inside and the outside after hollowing.

Now reverse turn the bowl to turn the foot. I do this on smaller bowls by simply putting a rubber sink stopper over the chuck, putting the open end of the bowl over this and then moving the tailstock up to go in the same hole you had when you started turning the bowl. Now you can turn most of the foot leaving a very small tenon where the tailstock had been. Carve this off and hand sand the bottom and you've got a bowl.

for other methods of holding the bowl to reverse turn it see the link below. Look under methods of reverse turning bowls.

This is only one way to do it. I like starting bowls between center because if there is a defect I need to get rid of, or a particulary nice feature I want to save I can turn a little and see where it will be and then move the centers if necessary to position that feature for best presentation.


http://www.cumberlandwoodturners.com/tips.asp

Re: Help on chucking bowl with new G3

#5

Re: Help on chucking bowl with new G3

Bob Fawcett

>I like to use tenon instead. doesn't have to be that big. My Talon chuck grips fine on as little as 3/16". make the part next to the tenon flat to match the top of your chuck jaws. Most chucks have at least 2 points for the key to engage. tighten some at one, rotate the chuck to the next, tighten some more, and repeat. You don't need to tighten that much, but you want to make sure you take the slack out of the mechanism evenly. There is not a lot of slack in a quality chuck, but you still do this. Also, do it on your jacobs chucks with key.

This is how master machinist taught me many years ago in the machine shop where I worked. I have seen it since in some woodturning videos and books

Re: Help on chucking bowl with new G3

#6

Re: Help on chucking bowl with new G3

Bill Howatt

>Perhaps you tightened too much and perhaps the amount of wood around the inside tenon is a little too light. However, it could be a characteristic of the wood. My preferred method of holding is an external rather than internal tenon but I have seen ash bowls shear an outside tenon off leaving a nice sheared-off circular piece of wood in the chuck jaws. Doesn't happen a lot but it does happen.

Anyway, you have a piece to practice recovery techniques on. Not a bad exercise because sooner or later you will have a problem with a bowl you want to save and your skill level will be improved - trying to see the positive side of this.

Bill

Re: Help on chucking bowl with new G3

#7

Re: Help on chucking bowl with new G3

Earl Eyre

>I have found recesses work great on things like platters or even bowls if you have a large base and small recess. But hollowing the inside of a bowl puts a tremendous strain on the recess and I have found with that little wood around the recess you will almost always split it. Go with the tenon unless you can leave plenty of wood to support the recess.

Earl

Re: Help on chucking bowl with new G3

#8

Re: Help on chucking bowl with new G3

Rick Davenport

>You got a lot of good advice here as usual.

Another factor is the type of wood.

They make baseball bats out of ash.

It's hard stuff which means you will put a good amount of stress on either a tenon or a recess when gouging the inside of the bowl.

Aren't you glad it didn't fly off the chuck and bounce off anything soft?

Rick

Re: Help on chucking bowl with new G3

#9

Re: Help on chucking bowl with new G3

Jorge Castaneda

>Wayne,

You just discovered why I don't like using the recess, I have better luck using a tennon and better yet, a glue block as recommended by Wally, and this route does not need a chuck!

$0.02

Jorge

Re: Help on chucking bowl with new G3

#10

Re: Help on chucking bowl with new G3

Wayne Leach

>John,

Thanks for taking the time to give me suggestions as I am basically a rookie and need help. I will do as you suggest and try saving the bowl if not for the practice?

Everyone on the WC forum are so helpful but I do not write much as I have not much to offer YET but am working on improving skills.

Regards,

Wayne

Re: Help on chucking bowl with new G3

#11

Thanks for all the help

Wayne Leach

>I really appreciate all those who are so helpful to us "newbies". I hope to soon be able to do so for others as my skill improves. Until then, I may have lots more questions and hope not to be a "pest".

Regards,

Wayne

Re: Help on chucking bowl with new G3

#12

Re: Thanks for all the help

robo hippy

>Well, I never had much luck with the tenon method, it kept shearing off. I found with the mortice/recess method, after a bit of experimenting, there are a few important things to do. I have 2 chucks (Vicmarc) and have a dedicated set of calipers for each chuck to mark the bottom of the bowl with. The adjustable screw is glued into place as it will expand with the vibration of marking. I mark while the bowl is turning. Take care to ues only the inside point to mark, and the outside to help show if the cirlce is the right size. (if you touch both points, or the outside point, since the wood is moving up, so will the point, and it will come around, hit the tool rest, and turn into a pretzel). You want the recess width to match the jaws as closely as possible. I made the recess about 1/16 bigger than the minimum size of the jaws. this gives a better metal to wood contact ratio than it does if the hole is 1/4 inch or more wider. You want the angle of the recess to match the angle of the jaws as close as you can. I use a dedicated dove tail tool. The angle of the dove tail is ground so that it matches the angle of the jaws when it is lined up paralell to the ways of my lathe. This gives an easy way to line it up. The final cut on the outside of the mortice isn't a plunge and then move it over to make the dovetail, but a plunge at the angle of the dovetail. I also will let the tool barely rest at the bottom of the cut so that it just barely cuts. This helps remove any uneveness so that when you reverse the bowl, there is little or no wobble. Before reversing and remounting, make sure that there are no chips in the mortice, or on the jaws, as this will contribute to the wobble.

How deep does it need to be? That depends. I can turn and core a 18 inch by 8 inch deep bowl, with no tailstock with about 1/4 inch depth.My big set of jaws are about 2 1/4 inch wide. I left about a 2 inch collar around the mortice. Smaller bowls, I will go 1/8, to 3/16 inch deep (I never measure, I just go until it is right). With your bowl, I would have left a bit more shoulder and not have gone so deep. I don't have any rules on how much shoulder to leave, but on anything that I will hog out material fast, I will leave something in the order of about 1/2 the width of the jaws (min. jaw opening is 1 1/2 inch, then about 3/4 inch shoulder). You can do it with a more dainty shoulder, but then you have to go more gently when you turn the inside.

You can over tighten it when remounting. I did have some problems with this armstrong method (when all else fails, it is good to be able to rely on brute strength). Just get it snug, and use both or all of the keys to tighten it a little at a time, not all at once from one key. This will put a lot of stress on the chuck and the wood.

You will want to experiment, as this is how I learned, some several thousand bowls ago. One other advantage of the mortice, is that it doesn't have to be turned off. You can sand the bottom of it out add some detail if you wish, and then finish it.

robo hippy