Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Negative Rake Scraper.....

Posts

Negative Rake Scraper.....

#1

Negative Rake Scraper.....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>A couple of years ago a friend told me about the negative rake scraper, and how well it worked under certain conditions. A negative rake scraper is ground on both sides, similar to the way a skew is ground. I happened to have a heavy duty 1-inch, square nosed tool. I ground away one side of the cutting edge a bit and tried it. I wasn't impressed with the results, so I put it on the tool rack and forgot it.

At the recent Phoenix symposium, I watched a demo by Suart Batty on the negative rake scraper, and later I read the article by Stuart in the American Woodturner. He emphasized that the burr must be substantial. I decide to get out my NR scraper and give it another try. This time I re-ground the cutting angle to a steeper 45 degrees, and instead of grinding it on my 60 grit wheel, I ground it on my 1-inch belt sander using a 60 grit belt. This gave a much heavier burr.

I mounted a dry, rough-turned piece of quilted maple on the lathe. In my experience, quilted maple is just about impossible to turn without having areas of rough surface, due to the fact that the grain is constantly changing.

After doing the best I could with the bowl gouge, I carefully shear-scraped the piece. There were still several rough areas that would require a lot of sanding. I then tried the NR scraper, using a very light touch. It produced very light, feathery shavings. I had to touch up the grind a few times, as the burr disapeared in about 10 seconds. In a few minutes the rough areas had disappeared, and the surface was very smooth.

Needless to say, I am very impressed with the performance of this tool. According to Stuart, the harder and denser the wood, the better it works. He says that it won't do well on soft and spalted wood. The tool works best when held level. When the burr is gone it doesn't work at all. Because of the way it's ground it's not nearly as aggressive as a scraper that's ground the regular way. It's not used for removing wood, just used with a light touch for smoothing the surface before sanding. Sanding is much easier after using this tool.

Wally

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

#2

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

Ron in Drums PA

>Thanks Wally.

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

#3

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

GaryG in MD

>Thanks Wally, There has been a lot of discussion and a lot of confusion about this tool -- its theory, form, and application. Your comments are very helpful. ...Gary

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

#4

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

Dick Anderson

>Wally:

I have used the negative rake scraper dozens of times, especially on the thin winged natural edge red mallee, brown mallee and collibah burl bowls. I also have use it with and without a burr on maple, walnut and euclyptus with great success. The first negative rake scraper I used was my oval skew chisel, which requres care since it can have a tendency to rock if not held firmly. I do not like the oval skew (as a skew) thus this is a good way to use it up with all the grinding required to keep a burr on a negative rake scraper. The skew is ground with a 40-degree cutting edge and since it is a skew it can be used with the burr on either side, which ever offers the best presentation position.

I also demo the negative rake scraper over a year ago at our club meeting.

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks Wally, good info...have you tried it on edge, with one side of the tool raised from the tool rest? It works well that way too.

I find a bowl that's cleanly cut looks better than one that has been heavily sanded to the same level of smoothness. I believe I can tell the difference in the final results. Any comments on this? I would be curoius on your opinion.

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

#6

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

Bill Neddow

>I picked up one of Stuart Batty's negative rake scrapers from him at a symposium in Albany last year. And I am impressed. This was not easiy as I have had a hate/hate relationship with scrapers going back to my early days as a wood turner. I got some scrapers, and also picked up a Veritas burr device, designed to put a good solid burr on the tool. You sharpen the tool, take off the grinder burr, and rub the sharp edge along the Veritas jig to fold back a solid burr similar to that you put on a cabinet scraper. I thought it was a wonderful idea.

Of course, I am of the school that claims is something is good, more must be better. So I really leaned on the veritas burr maker, got a wonderful burr and tried it on a bowl. I put the tool half way through the side of the bowl with the catch I got. After multiple failures, I realized I had to ease up on my burr making efforts. But I was still catching fibers and pulling them out all the way from China (or at least from the other side of the rim wall). Eventually I learned how to sheer scrape with a fingernail bowl gouge and the dedicated scrapers went in the bottom drawer.

It was only a little over a year ago that I started to rethink my use of scrapers. First, there were some good articles, especially in the AAW magazine, on how to use them. Then I read an article Joaz Hill had on his website about taking a shallow spindle roughing gouge, turning it over, and resharpening it as a scraper. It is grabby if you use the point (which he warns about) but a dream to use if you concentrated on the sloping(downward) sides of the tool. It seemed to me that it contained the best traits of my bowl gouge sheer scraping and the regular scraper (If I could ever have gotten it to work). The problem was that it did not stay sharp very long as it was M2 steel.

When I saw Stuart Batty at work, I realized his sheer scraper worked on a principle closer to what Joaz was trying, rather than my bowl gouge sheer scraping technique. With the double bevel, and the hard steel, he had solved the mysteries around this.

Now, I will never be as good as Batty with that tool. But it has become an important part of my routine on almost every bowl (except the really soft woods). It really smooths things out, does not catch fibers, and you can do the inside of a whole bowl abut 16 inches in diameter without multiple trips to the grinder.

It is the first time I have ever bought a tool at a demo that actually performed exactly the way the demonstrator said it would. Definitely worth the money.

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

#7

Brad Vietje

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

Brad Vietje

>Thanks Wally.

When grinding/sharpening on the belt sander, which way was the belt going -- away from, or toward the cutting edge ?

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

#8

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

George Van in WI

>Thanks Wally, you may have convinced me to break the bank and get one to try. I am leary of new tools but your success is good enough for me!

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

#9

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Brad, the belt was coming down, that is, toward the cutting edge.

Wally

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

#10

I must say....

Barry Irby

>I read Batty's article in AAW. I have some sort of left right orientation issues, or maybe I am just thick headed, but to me, the article left out something. Couldn't there have been even one picture of the proper application of the tool? Maybe I need to read it again, but whadidhesay? Do what? Put it where? Grind it how?

Sounds like a great tool, but it seemed like a poor article. I need a demo. Of course, ten minutes with David Ellsworth changed my opinion of the "Ellsworth Bowl Gouge" from something to be used to kill terrorists to my favorite turning tool.

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

#11

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

john lucas

>I took a segmented turning class with Don Russell and John C campbell and he had everyone using a skew as a negative rake scraper on segmented vessels, inside and out. He sharped them by creating a conves radius on both sides using a stationary 6" belt sander. It created fine shavings and was really quick to sharpen. I don't remember putting a burr on them. It was used flat on the tool rest the same way Stewart used his.

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

#12

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

Pat Mulligan

>Thank's for telling us about this,Wally.Another thing to improve our work.

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

#13

Skew

Bill Howatt

>John,

You have mentioned what seems to be one of the mysteries of life to me. I was always told that a scraper cut by the burr and while you can hone other tools, never hone a scraper because you need the burr. Then I found out about using a skew as a scraper and it works very nicely for some applications. My problem is that my skew has no burr that I can see or feel before or after honing.

Perhaps somebody can explain this apparent contradiction to me.

Thanks,

Bill

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

#14

Re: Negative Rake Scraper.....

Steve Mushinski

>Thank you Wally for your review of what you have learned. As you state it only last a few seconds and you have to touch it up to get the results. This is the key that I and many other miss when using this tool. - Steve