Re: Barracuda 2 Chuck
RussFairfield
>The following is a copy of what I said about these chucks in an article on my Website.
There are several new inexpensive chucks available on the market. While each supplier will argue the merits of their product, they all look the same to me, and like a copy of a Vicmarc chuck. All appear to be a good buy for the beginning and average hobbiest woodturner because they sell for less than $100, and some of them come with several jaw sets for less than $200. The PSI chucks are the only ones I can comment on because they are the only ones I have seen and used.
Don't expect to get the same steel as the other chucks at these prices. Testing them with a file tells me that the steel is probably a common "Mild Carbon Steel" rather than an alloy steel as used in the more expensive chucks. That means they are made from a softer steel, and that they will wear out quicker. A high volume woodturner would be better off spending the extra money for a better quality chuck. The hobbiest woodturner will never know the difference.
My only adverse comment about the PSI chucks is that the jaws on the ones I used were at a "true circle" when fully closed. That means that the grip will always be at the points of the jaws for all sizes of spigot, and always in the center of the jaw in a recess. That means I could never use the light but firm grip where the jaws and the sligot (or recess) were at the same diameter. Again, I would suspect that the average woodturner would never know the difference.
Other than that, they appear to be well made, and the machined fits were good. They are coated with a black coating that appears to something other than paint. If the coating is similar to that used by Nova and Oneway, rust should not be a problem.
The Vicmarc jaws could be used on the only Grizzly chuck I have seen, but only one of the screws lined up with the base jaw. The other screw was close enough that drilling out the hole in the jaw would have allowed both screws ro be used. I have been told by others that the Vicmarc chuck jaws did fit their Grizzly without any problems.