We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I have a perceived problem, whenever I see somebody else's projects, I'm afraid I might be overly influenced by it. Viewing solid pieces is not a problem, a curve is a curve and so is workmanship and techniques. It's in the enhancement whether it's a lid, carving, burning, painting and sculptured work. Segmented turning is also a problem with me; I just flat don't won't to see the other person's work. Beautiful designs in the feature areas are retained back in my mind someplace and if I design something similar then I don't think it is my own. Does anybody else have a similar hang up? I like to feel that I�m a creative person and don�t lack for ideas. Please do not respond with the copy and plagiarize threads, to me those are wore out. GT
>George anything you come up with regarding enhancements more than likely has been already been done by someone, somewhere. Even when you think something is an idea that belongs only to you, chances are it is not and it will be said that you have been influenced by "so-and-so". Better to be influenced and make changes that are uniquely yours (if that's possible) rather than shying away from viewing the works of others. Viewing others work is half the enjoyment of this addiction, I think.
There is a difference in COPY and similar. There is a round shape to almost all of our work but that does not mean that it is a copy.
I love the basic indian shape of vessels and I do a lot of them. This is not a copy per say but a duplication of form.
To copy is to make an exact duplicate. I question anyones ability to rember any others work after time has past where you make an exact duplicate. I know my old memory is that I could duplicate a design unless it was in front of me.
I find it hard enough to make an exact pair of candlesticks unless the first is in front of me.
>George, I have often thought it would bee interesting to see the work of a turner that had been totaly insulated from other turners and there infulences, or to not to have had any infulences from other turners myself. Would the work be totaly unique and inovative. Or would it be very elementary and purely functional? I tend to think that we are all standing on the sholders of the turners preceeding us. I also agree that sometimes I wish I hadn't seen some others work, especially when I have been pondering an idea, and see someone else do it first. It's very interesting how often two different turners will post similar turnings totaly independent of each other. I agree with Carole, Its all been done before, so it comes down to how well you do it.
>Hi George....I enjoy this topic! It's ok to draw inspiration from other turners and their work. Much of the fun of a symposium for me is to walk through the instant gallery and analzye the work in depth, and marvel at the creativity displayed there.
I would suggest, instead of just viewing other's turnings, begin to study other art forms. The media of glass, even though I have no interest in persuing the field, fascinates me....the colors, the forms that can be produced are stunning. I visit the Philadelphia Home Furnishing Show each year....just amazing to see what's out there. I like to visit museusms and art exhibits as well...I leave these events with ideas swirling inside my head.
We are all influenced by the things around us to a certain extent, but we are also each uniquely different. For instance, give 20 turners a 6x6" block of wood, and ask them to come back in a week to show what they did with it. No two will be the same; everyone will come up with their own interpretation of what their piece should look like. The trick, I think, is learning to tap into our own creativity, visualize a piece, then produce it....adding our own personality into the piece.
Take a look at some of your earlier work...what do you like or dislike about a particular piece? How could it be improved? Can you draw inspiration from these pieces? What are your interests and experiences? Could they inspire new work?
Here is an example...As a kid, I was an avid fisherman, and later started a collection of antique fishing tackle.I made many home-made fishing lures from wood. When my grandson was born, I started making him a tackle box filled with my turned fishing lures...a special gift to my grandson. I turn these lures two or three at a time, then part them off. One of these sets of three had been sitting on my workbench for a few months...then WHAM! I started to laugh, as the way they were arranged, one lure appeared as though it was eating the other.Later that evening, I started making sketches....I liked what I drew, so I began to make a few items. Fish eating fish! Each one I did gave me new ideas, new challenges of how to make them. Most important, I think they show a bit of myself. The result..a new direction in my turning career...I now have many of these on order!
>Thanks to all who have replied. Don't get me wrong on this. I see your work Keith, Wally, Mark, Carole, etc. and it's keeps me motivated. I do approx 75% segmented work and have the books on Malcom Tibbets and Ray Allen, WOW what a pair. Even as a 20 year plus turner I still get somewhat bothered by looking and wanting to do something similar. So I hope you other turners don't get on my case if you spot something you had in mind also. For example I have 20 solid pieces to burn, carve and decorate. There is another 15 pieces of segmented work to do something way. These are plain with out the segmented features, but will get decorated. There's more, how about a dozen vases with and without lids to enhance. For me all of this is a dilemma, I guess I will just muttle through. May ramble some more on this subject. Thanks again GT
>I say just dive in! Don't worry about whether you're influenced by anyone else's work. As long as what you produce is something that is of interest to you, and is a joy to produce, you win.
>George, this thing of copying others has been way overblown. If you like a form that I've done, or an enhancement that I've done, for Pete's sake copy it. Hopefully you'll be inspired to add your own touch to it. I see forms being done all of the time that I've been doing for years. I probably was motivated by something that someone else had done. Along the way I added my own touches to it. Just about everybody copies, whether they know it or not. There's very little being done by turners that's original.
>I have been making segmented turnings for several years that obviously have a Southwestern Native American influence in both form and decoration. More recently I have been exploring techniques to make bowls and hollow forms whose similarity to some of the Mata Ortiz artists is quite obvious.
Their reaction has been interesting. Several of their artists have purchased my segmented turnings, and they have given me a nice compliment and one of the small number of links they have on their own website.
Obviously, these folks who originated the art forms don't have any problem with my being influenced by them. So, why should I care what a bunch of woodturners think.
>Russ, the Mata Ortiz bowls are my favorites of the SW Indian pottery. I have two of them and admire them very much. The road in to the village of Mata Ortiz in Mexico has recently been improved, so I'm planning a trip down. It's just under 300 hundred miles from my home. There's a down-side to the road improvement...now tour busses go there.
>George, the way I see it is that if I like a piece made by someone, I like to try to make somehting similar, just to see if I can. That doesn't mean I am copying them or stealing anything from them. It means that I hope to learn something by making something like what they made. If I am successful in my endeavour, then I have learned something. And that is a good thing.
>I came up with what i thought was a totally new idea and turned a couple of forms. When other turners saw them they said that looks just like soandso's work. I never saw soandso's work or even met the dude. Maybe it was something in the water.
>If you were planning to design yourself a new house would it look like other houses? If not it would likely be pretty gaudy and totally out of place. In order to be completely unique it might have to have the driveway going up a ramp to the second floor or it might have all round rooms, maybe the kitchen in the basement, the front door entering through a bedroom....in other words to be different you run the risk of being "odd" or too far off the main line of thinking. Small things can be changed to give a design a personal touch but big changes that one might call unique would also likely be called "ugly". Very few get away with a totally unique design and those usually come when one is trying to cover up an "uh-oh" event.