Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

What kind of tree was this?

Posts

What kind of tree was this?

#1

What kind of tree was this?

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>This was cut yesterday in North Texas for a bowl turning workshop and I'd like to be able to tell the people what it is. It should be a native since it was back in a creek bed on a ranch, not near any houses. The closest I could come was Bigleaf Maple from the Field Guide to North Anerican Trees but I don't think they grow around here.


img

Re: What kind of tree was this?

#2

Red Oak

TDaniel

>

Re: What kind of tree was this?

#3

or Scarlet Oak or Spanish Oak

TDaniel

>

Re: What kind of tree was this?

#4

Definitely oak

Carole Valentine

>And as TD says appears to be red oak. Certainly not white.

Re: What kind of tree was this?

#5

Re: What kind of tree was this?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>It is definitely one of the red oak group. From your location, my distribution maps, but only one leaf, it is most probably Black Oak, Quercus velutina. It could also be be Q. shumardii, since you found it in bottomland. Would you clasify the bark as "black", or "grey"? I doubt it is scarlet oak, Q. coccinea since that one isn't native to North Texas, and it's leaves usually have more lobes than your example. Also, it's very unlikely to be Q. hispanica, which you can see here: http://bio.bd.psu.edu/plant_web/Fagaceae/Spanish_Oak_01d_Leaf.html

Re: What kind of tree was this?

#6

Re: What kind of tree was this?

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>The bark's very dark gray to black. The heart wood has a bit of red color once it dries out a bit but not as red as KD red oak I've seen. There doesn't apear to be any flecking. One of the guys rough turned some last night and said there are pin sized black dots in the wood. Spalting? It had only been cut for maybe 5 hours.

Re: What kind of tree was this?

#7

Re: What kind of tree was this?

Jim Pugh, Ohio

>Phil, one of the keys to identifying between 'red' and 'white' oak is that red oak has leaves with pointed tips and white oak leaves have rounded tips. There are many variations of each.

The dark flecks in the wood you have could possibly be what are called "mineral stains" and come from the soil the tree is growing in. One of the more common trees to exhibit mineral stains, in my experience, is black cherry.

Re: What kind of tree was this?

#8

A good ref

GaryG in MD

>Phil,

An excellent little book to have around is:

National Audubon Society Field Guide to North American Trees.

They have an "Eastern Region", and, I assume, a "Western region".

It shows a huge number of color photos of leaves, bark, flowers, etc., as well as having extensive verbal descriptions and a good index. Highly recommended.

Gary

Re: What kind of tree was this?

#9

Re: What kind of tree was this?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>The darker the bark, the more likely it is black oak, as opposed to the other species I mentioned.

The actural color of the wood is not very indicative in the oaks. Within any particular species there is a lot of variation between individual trees, both genetic and environmental.

In my experience, the small black spots in oak are most often caused by chemicals that the wood encounters during the working and finishing. Rust, from steel wool for example, can stain the wood black. Of course, depending on how the wood was treated after the tree came down, the spots could also be fungal.