We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I find Mikes observation about Osage interesting and I hear this a lot on other woods as well. My friend Bobby Clemons and I were talking about turning hard woods the other night because the same thing came up at our club meeting. I've personally never had a wood I couldn't turn. Hardwoods require frequent sharpening and small cuts. It may take a while to hollow a bowl but it still cuts. Bobby said he thought the same thing. We've both turned woods like dry locust, pecan, osage and some exotics. The only wood that really gave me a hard time was Oak barnwood. When turning through the gray outside I would make one pass across the wood and have to sharpen the tool. After I got about 1/4" deep is cut pretty well.
The only woods that have given me a hard time were those that don't cut cleanly and leave fibers showing. We all have experiences with some wood that we don't like. Bradford Pear is my wood. Not because it doesn't cut clean but 8 out of 10 pieces I've turned have had wind shake on the inside that you can't see so the piece is ruined or has to be radically reshaped.
I can agree with you about the oak. The hardest wood I've tried to turn was some oak burl that had been kiln dried and then set around for about 20 years. The gouge wants to just bounce off.
>I also responded to the post about the Osage. Odd that you should mention Bradford Pear. I have gotten several pieces that were large enough to turn a 13 inch bowl and turned them green. I thought it was a wonderful experience. Cut like butter and made a beautiful bowl even if the grain were a little nondescript. Then I tried to turn some that had sat around drying for about two years. Very different. Also turned some small ornamental posts for my garden out of black locust that was very dry. The shavings were were very "prickly". They made me itch right through my smock, shirt, and tee shirt.
Even with my limited experience, I've noticed that when I turn wood within 3-4 feet of the ground, it has a dramatic effect on my glaser V15. I've had some green pignut hickory that would erase the cutting edge off of my gouge after 2-3 passes. I've cut ash that was buried in dirt, and it wasn't as bad as the hickory - love turning it tho.w
>I don't cut much stump wood. Not because I don't mind turning it but because it's more of a pain to sharpen my chainsaw after hitting a rock or piece of fence and other debri. It's pretty easy to sharpen my lathe tools so once I get the stuff I'll turn it, I just don't like to harvest it.
>I must be the Lone Ranger on this. I go to the saw mill and look for that first sqauring cut that is made at the trunk spread. That piece makes the most attractive platters that I have seen. Every one seems to have curl, burl or quilting.
The best part, it is always free because they do not want to chip, burn or move it.
>John: Your experience with Barnwood reminds me of a time when I had to clear away several logs of punky Oak that had been down for several years in order to get a path to some standing tres. The logs were so punky and filled with rain washed grit from the sky that by the time I got a path cut it was time out to file the chain again. I really had to file away, because the chain was well polished.
I have some sapele I got from work. Beautiful wood that looks a lot like mahogany. I cut a piece and turned a small bowl across the grain. It was much harder to cut than most of the other woods I've turned in my short experience. My wife wants me to make a 4 poster bed, so I planed to use the sapele since I have plenty of it and she likes mahogany. This wood was acceptable to her. I thought it would be hard to turn after my experience with the little bowl. I glued up a blank for a lower leg section and started turning it a few days ago. I decided it would be practice, unless it comes out good enough to use. To my surprise it cuts like butter. Must be the difference between cutting across the grain for a bowl and spindle with the grain running between centers. The bowl was not cut endgrain, excuse my terms, I am not sure if I am using them correctly
>Bob even though the bowl was not an end grain bowl you still may have been turning into end grain, it depends on the direction of cut and how the grain is oriented. Glad the spindles are working out.
I hear a lot of beginners having trouble with real hard woods, but not many experienced turners. I suspect this has much more to do with technique and confidence (and aquired sharpening ability) than the hardness or density of the wood. My general rule of thumb is the harder the better, as far as clean cuts and tool finish left behind (though there are some notably miserable woods like some species of Purpleheart, and any Wenge I've ever seen). Another, contrary example, is White Ash... Not as hard as some other woods, but sometimes pretty ornery as far as snooth cuts go. I find those relatively hard woods with large, concentrated pores (ring porous) are more trouble than the harder, fine-grained or diffuse porous species.
"Hard" usually equates to "dry", since even the hardest woods usually cut nicely when green. I have more trouble with dust and splintering with dry chunks of the harder species than difficulty getting tools to cut, so I'm much happier turning green wood. I suspect that some woods have tiny, unseen cracks that develop when drying in larger, turn-able sizes, making them pretty difficult to work smoothly. Thus, roughing a piece in green wood, then finishing after careful (slow) seasoning seems to work better than starting with a dry, 15-year-old brick, as I think the wood will dry better when you control the process, and the thickness you are attempting to dry.
I just did a little finish turning with a piece of Eastern Hophornbeam (a.k.a. "Ironwood") that I had roughed out about 4 years ago, and coated with paste wax. To be truthful, I couldn't believe how beautifully it cut -- much better than expected ! Dry Black Locust is similarly hard, but quite different, as it's pretty dusty and a little grainy, and doesn't seem to produce nice curly-q shavings like it does when green. Osage Orange is similar, and while I like to work them, most of the Mesquite's I've used didn't produce long ribbons regardless of moisture content -- just a property of the wood structure, I suppose.
Those are the hardest N. American woods I've used, and they're still not so very hard when compared to Cocobolo, African Blackwood, Snakewood, Leadwood, or Lignum Vitae... I usually find that the hardest woods cut the best (except those pieces conntaining sand, silica, etc...), and those that are especially fine grained can also be scraped or shear scraped to an excellent surface -- especially on the downward side of the learning curve.