Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

Posts

Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

#1

Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

Devon Palmer

>Heyas All,

Whats the deal with "V" vs "U" shaped flutes on bowl gouges, I've heard that V shapes are better for exterior and U shapes are better for interior (depending on grind of course).

Any insights as to the advantages and disadvantages of each flute shape and their best application? Is one suited better for side grind?

- Devo, Columbus Ohio

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

#2

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

John Lucas

>Devon I have both and have never been able to tell the difference. Both clog occasionally with really wet shaving and both seem to throw them out effectively most of the time. Maybe it's the wood I turn.

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

#3

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

RussFairfield

>And don't forget that there is a parabolic flute that is halfway in between the "V" and the "U" shapes. Which anyone uses is a matter of personal preference.

An interesting thing about bowl gouges, more so than other turning tools, is that we learn to use the one we have, and then argue that it is the only tool worth using.

Some swear by the "U" shape because they claim it cleans out green wood better. Some swear by the "V" shape because they like the shape of the grind they get from it, and they say that it doesn't clog any worse than another flute.

I prefer the parabolic flute of the Taylor and Onway tools because I like the profile aqnd tip radius that I can get, and I use the Oneway because I like removing the handle for sharpening and I like the M4 high speed steel that Oneway uses.

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

#4

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

Scott Hogsten

>I kind of prefer the U or parabola. If you like to use a symmetrical grind instead of a swept back (aka, Elsworth, Irish, etc) it is very hard to get an nice tip on the grind. I've had some beginners come to my log to bowl class and we have ended up putting a swept back grind on the gouge to make it more friendly.

Scott

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

#5

Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U" who makes which?

Bob Fawcett

>Who makes which grinds. I am new to this. I have a couple of bowl gouges, but not sure which kind I have. I have a Sorby and a Crown.

Guess I need to go examine them more closely.

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

#6

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

Fog Tanner

>My prefernce is the one I have in my hand at the time. I use primarily the 5/8" Henry Taylor Superflute shape, but I also use the 5/8" U shape. One of the gouges I use the most on the outside of the bowl is a 9/16" shallow gouge. I use it for both roughing and finishing, its M4 and goes longer between sharpening. On smaller bowls a 1/2" shallow gouge. I got that from Raffan when he was here, better to use a cheaper piece of steel that will do the same job, instead of grinding away a high priced deep fluted gouge.

I think it is all in what you get used to and how it is ground. try both and see which one suits your style. And its a lot like Chevy vs Ford - whatever is in your driveway is the best, otherwise you wouldn't have it.

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

#7

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

Bill Neddow

>I am with Russ on this one. I have five 5/8 inch bowl gouges that cover all three shapes. I sharpen all five in the morning and keep going until all are dull. All work the same. The differences are the quality of the steel and the shape of the handle.

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

#8

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>I have heard it said that the V shape is better if you use the tip to cut, and that the U shape is better if you do alot of shear cutting/scraping (dry wood) because the U shape does not pack up as easily. From my experience, this seems to be true. This is one of the things that Stuart Batty says, and one of the reasons that he liked Sorby gouges. He likes the metal on Glaser gouges, but not the V profile. Now that he has bought out Glaser I believe that he is changing that profile. Will see in Louisville.

I cannot comment on what Russ said, as I do not have any of these gouges.

Mark

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

#9

That would be nice...

Peter Teubel

>If Glaser comes out with a U/parabolic shaped bowl gouge, I'd buy it. I bought one of his V gouges and didn't like it. Ended up selling it a week later. Constantly clogged with wet wood (just about the only wood I turn) but it really held a sharp edge FAR longer than regular HHS.

Its really just personal preference.

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

#10

Not really just preference...

TDaniel

>though that is part of it. The U shaped flute does eject the chips better but the big difference is for those who cut with the side of the gouge rather than the tip and this normally happens if the turner has a lathe that has a toolrest that will go low, like 2" below center. We all adapt to what we have and part of this adapting is to the toolrest height. If the toolrest will not go lower than a half inch below center then you are forced to cut with the tip of the gouge but if the toolrest can be dropped much lower than it is better to cut with the side of the gouge. I will demo this at the Gathering soon.

TD

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

#11

Can't put an Ellsworth grind on a P&N V shape

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>You end up with a little "hook" just the tip. I don't know if it's a problem with the other V shapes.

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

#12

Correction.

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>Should have said "hook" just behind the tip.

Sure wish I could edit my posts :>)

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

#13

Re: Its U for me, and me for....

JamieDonaldson

>....the Sorby style wider flute, which has a wider cutting edge at the bottom of the flute. I have Oneway Mastercuts as a close 2nd favorite, on down thru Crown to P&N,and the more narrow flute is harder to sharpen without ending up with a spear point that is more grabby.

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

#14

I agree

TDaniel

>The "V" shaped flutes are harder to sharpen for me too.

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

#15

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

Glenn Hodges

>I am like Mark, I use the one I am with. When the need occurs for the sideways cut I find Glaser clogs so I reach for a Crown, P&N, Packard, or whatever more of a U shaped gouge. When I am into roughing I use the Glaser. It is also useful to me when I start removing wood on the inside. I use the Glaser most of the time for a number of reasons that have been stated here.

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

#16

Re: Ellsworth grind on a V shape

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Phil,

I use an "Ellsworth" grind on my 3/4" A-11 Glaser gouge. I like the tool much better that way because I use it with the handle high and the shaft nearly parallel with the ways. May as well let the lathe and the tool rest do the work.

I use the Wolverine Vari-grind holder. That "hook" you speak of usually means you need to change the angle of your holder or lowerthe contact-point on the wheel. Have you measured the nose/point angle of your grind?

Mark

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

#17

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U" *LINK*

Bob Fawcett

>Found this on the WEB. Looks like Mr. Child may be th originator of the Taylor Superflute. Nice drawings and explanations.


Bowl Gouge

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

#18

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Bob,

Interesting coincidence that you should provide this link. My turning friend from New Orleans came up on Thursday and stayed a few days. He had with him a book that he bought on woodturning back in 1971. The author? Peter Child.

It was eye opening to see how things used to be done in the "old days." No scroll chucks back then.

On this link, I particularly liked Mr. Child's comment about "egotists" with their "woodturning dogma." I've run into a few of those over the years. 8^]

Thanks for the link,

Gary

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

#19

Re: Bowl Gouge Flute Shapes - "V" vs. "U"

justwannaturn

>Stuart did not buy Gerry Glaser. He was hired by this new company CET to design the cryo tools for them. I saw him at Louisville. I guess he has been designing tools there.