Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

McNaughton results

Posts

McNaughton results

#1

McNaughton results

Ed Moore

>Well, two out of three isn't bad unless you are sky-diving.

;^D

Ed Moore


img

Re: McNaughton results

#2

Lampshade?

Rick Davenport

>

Re: McNaughton results

#3

Re: McNaughton results

Juergen

>I have a few of those. Anybody have any ideas what they're good for?

Re: McNaughton results

#4

Re: McNaughton results

HeatherA in Anchorage, AK

>They make good planters, not that I would know!

Heather

Re: McNaughton results

#5

Top half of a hollow form :>)

Phil Joines Krum, Tx

>

Re: McNaughton results

#6

Re: McNaughton results

Dave Belser

>A funnel!

I made one myself just the other day. The figure is too nice to just toss it so I'm going to attempt a lampshade. If it dosn't work out I'll call it a learning experience!

Dave

Re: McNaughton results

#7

Re: McNaughton results

Pat Mulligan

>No pain,no gain.

Re: McNaughton results

#8

McNaughton results/explanation/Stubby 500

Ed Moore

>A good friend lent me his complete McNaughton system for a few days so I could find out if it would fit on my Stubby 500. It does fit and my first attempt using the system was successful. Then, as you may have noted, I got a little ambitious and lost the toilet seat in the picture. But the remaining core was still in the chuck. I removed it, took the pictured piece off, reseated the core and then cored it.

Despite my "learning experience", I ordered my own standard and mini McNaughton systems yesterday. I really like the idea of making more bowls from the same amount of chainsaw effort. If I had thought that the McNaughton system would fit the Stubby 500, I would have had one long ago. Live and learn. And be thankful for good friends.

Ed

Re: McNaughton results

#9

Re: McNaughton results

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Ed, I hope you still have that KM tool when I arrive in May! My posts are 30mm and 1 1/4", so mine probably won't fit. I have a couple of funnels in my history too. I have even kept the tenon on a couple of bowls because that is where the bottom of the inside is!

Bill

Re: McNaughton results

#10

Re: McNaughton results

Ed Moore

>Bill,

My KM system is being shipped today. And I'll be happy to receive some help.

Ed

Re: McNaughton results

#11

Re: McNaughton results

Phil in NJ

>Raffan makes a mirror frame out of one in one of his books...

Re: McNaughton results

#12

Columbus

Barry Irby

>The Joke about Christopher Columbus is that when he left he did not know where he was going. When he got there he did not know where he was and when he got back he did not know where he had been and did not accomplish his Original goal.

That's pretty much my experience with the KM system. If It's fair to call a loose assortment of parts a system.

Its RIDICULOUS to send knives that will not run in their own kerf with something called a center saving system. And the answer is to cut a wider kerf? Wait, Just for a minute I thought the purpose of the system was to allow me to SAVE that part, not grind it to dust to make room for a poorly bent knife.

I think I am going to re-bend my knives. It will make me happier with the system if it works. If it does not work, a set of replacement knives will put me back to where I am now. This is somewhat like trying to "square" a framing square by peening the metal. Why not take a whack at it? You can't break something that is already broken.

Re: McNaughton results

#13

Re: Columbus

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Hi Barry

My own experience with the KM tool is quite a bit different than yours in some respects, and the knives on my do "run in their own kerf" as you describe. However, I often need to back the knife out of the cut because of chip buildup. There is a lot of metal sticking into that peice of wood, and wood shavings piling up on both sides at high speed. When they are wet wood shavings, they heat up real fast, expand, and bind. I don't know what happened or is happening with your knives. I have bent a couple of mine in the past, but that is because I am impatient at times.

Bill