Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Need your advice-Hollowmaster?

Posts

Need your advice-Hollowmaster?

#1

Need your advice-Hollowmaster?

Chris DiCiaccio

>Ok folks, I need your advice. I picked up a Sorby rs230kt Hollowmaster today. Haven't used it yet. Did a search and found some negative posts on it. (probably should have done the search first) Should I take it back and if so what would you recommend instead? Anyone just love this tool and recommend I keep it?

Re: Need your advice-Hollowmaster?

#2

Re: Need your advice-Hollowmaster?

Carole Valentine

>That tool has a fairly steep learning curve. I have one but I use my Kelton Hollowers almost exclusively because I like them better.

Re: Need your advice-Hollowmaster?

#3

Re: Need your advice-Hollowmaster?

RK in Milw

>There is nothing wrong with the Sorby Hollowmaster except the instructions for it are all wrong. The instructions show the bit on the wrong side of the tool, and the sharpening instuctions are wrong. Go to the Articles section here for suggestions on how to use this tool.

To reiterate: 1: Adjust tool rest height so that the cutter bit is at the center of your turning when the tool is parallel to the bed of the lathe.

2: NEVER use the tool with the curved part on the tool rest. Keep the straight portion of the shank on the tool rest or the tool will whip around.

3: Cutter should be as sharp as possible. Sharpen the cutter just as you would a scraper. Cutter should be on the RIGHT side of the tool when the flat is facing down. With a sharp cutter, you will not have to apply much pressure to get the tool to cut. Start out just touching the cutter to the wood. Apply a bit of pressure as you get used to the action of the tool.

4: See the photos in the article for cutter positioning in various sections of your vessel.

5. Practice on a bowl at first so you can get a feel for the tool while you can see what is going on.

I use the Hollowmaster regularily on vessels such as the one in the photo.


img

Re: Need your advice-Hollowmaster?

#4

Re: Need your advice-Hollowmaster? *LINK*

Bob Fawcett

>I am a little confused with the right-side left-side. Here is a video showing the tool in use. Is the right side you refer to the way the tool is shown when they show the tall vessel?


hollowmaster video

Re: Need your advice-Hollowmaster?

#5

Re: Need your advice-Hollowmaster? *LINK*

Carole Valentine

>Bob,

They show the bit in both postions in various parts of the video. If you are looking down on the tool in it's cutting position, the bit should be mounted at the top, not the bottom. You can use it mounted on the bottom but it is much more aggressive and harder to control. I know top and bottom don't make much sense either. I had a sketch I had posted but can't find it. RK's phot will suffice.


Hollowmaster

Re: Need your advice-Hollowmaster?

#6

Re: Need your advice-Hollowmaster?

DWFII

>Since this advice was first posted, I have used my Hollowmaster mostly with the cutter on the right side, but to be honest I can't say as it has made all that much difference. As far as I can tell there is no logical explanation for why the cutter would work better on the right side than the left, other than it might force you to change your angle of attack somewhat.

I think a sharp cutter and a light touch is nearly as important as what side the cutter is on. And if you want to do any undercutting of the top of your HF you will almost certainly need to have the cutter on the left.

I have the Kelton set too (medium size) and I have not found them to be as easy to use as the Hollowmaster. I get a lot of vibration coming up through the Keltons and a lot of unevenness that I don't get with the Sorby.

The one thing you can say for certain, however, is that if you get a bad catch with the Hollowmaster, it will be disasterous more often than not especially if you are working through a narrow opening.

Just my $.02...

DW

In the High Desert of Central Oregon

Re: Need your advice-Hollowmaster?

#7

Brad Vietje

Re: Need your advice-Hollowmaster?

Brad Vietje

>I don't have this particular hollowing tool, but many others, since I make many hollow forms. I think what Carole means by "top" is mounting the cutting tip furthest from the handle, at the end of the tool. The cutter is mounted on the bottom (flat) side of the tool.

DW is exactly right -- sharp cutter, and light touch.

Another thing the Sorby video clip does not mention is that on the inside of a hollow form, most scraping tools work best above center, though a small opening size may restrict your ability to do this. Don't cut below center. Bad words and exciting ballistics could result.

Safe Spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Need your advice-Hollowmaster?

#8

Re: Need your advice-Hollowmaster?

bob davis

>i use this tool hollowing with the jameison handle..works great with this system

Re: Need your advice-Hollowmaster?

#9

This should clear it up

RK in Milw

>In the photo, the tool is held up in front of you with the flat side of the tool facing away from you. Photo A shows the cutter in the CORRECTposition with the cutter on the RIGHT side of the tool. Photo B shows the cutter in the WRONG position with the cutter on the left side of the tool.

When the cutter is on the right, the center of torque goes through the center of the shaft. This way the flat on the tool shaft arrests the torque produced by the cutter. When the cutter is on the left side of the tool, the center of torque is on the left edge of the tool and the flat on the tool shaft can't be as effective at arresting torque.

It was the Sorby Rep who cleared this up for me. He admitted that Sorby's instructions are wrong but he blew me off when I asked him why they don't correct the instructions. As Carole pointed out, the video shows the cutter in the wrong position at first and then in the correct position later. Go figure.

I should also point out that you should cut on the tip of the cutter, not off to the side of the cutter.

Finally, the same instructions apply to the Sorby Multi-Tip tool.

Hope this clears things up for everyone.

Ron


img

Re: Need your advice-Hollowmaster?

#10

Re: This should clear it up

Bob Fawcett

>Thanks to all who answered. This was not originally my question, but I added the video link. Its clear now.

When I bought mine it came from Woodcraft with the cutter installed in the "wrong" position. The video shows it correct part of the time.

Re: Need your advice-Hollowmaster?

#11

My head hurts

Barry Irby

>Left, right, top, bottom, I feel like I'm driving in the wrong lane backward looking in the rear view mirror.