Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Dust collection noise

Posts

Dust collection noise

#1

Dust collection noise

David Breth

>I picked up a dust collector after a lot of research. It is a cannister type, Grizzly G0548, and basically is the best machine I can find that will fit my basement ceiling. Unfortunately, it is producing more noise upstairs than anybody wants (my shop is directly beneath the family room, and you can hear it, at least faintly, anywhere in the house). My wife is a pretty good scout, but I think this could wear her patience. Here's what I'm doing so far:

1) The collector fits perfectly into an alcove in my shop, which sits directly beneath the fireplace. The walls have insulation on them, except maybe the bottom 18" inches of the wall.

2) I'm going to cram a bunch of insulation in the floor joists immediately above the collector, and then enclose those joists.

3) The alcove is three-sided. I'm planning on creating a door of some kind that will be have insulating material on the inside, and can be easily opened, rolled, or removed when I clean the collector out. This won't create an air-tight closet - the collector will still be able to "breathe", and the hose/pipe whatever will come through a hole in the door.

I'm not sure how much this will knock down the sound, I hope a decent amount. I'm interested in suggestions from anybody who has gone through this, particularly if you can suggest a way to muffle the sound on the motor. Budget-wise solutions are definitely welcome. I looked at getting cone-or-egg-shaped foam block or foam rubber, and the stuff is like gold. The insulating material I've purchased so far is a 4 x 8 sheet of 2" insulating board like you see at Lowes, which was $30. For a piece of high density foam rubber at Jo-ann Fabrics, a 24" x 36" piece that is 5" thick is $45 bucks. I think I'll line the basement with that stuff.....

Lastly, I'm having trouble discerning where the most noise is coming from - is it the motor or is it the resonance of the clear filter bag with all that air being shoved in there. I'd be interested in comments there as well.

Thanks very much for any input!!

David B.

Re: Dust collection noise

#2

Re: Dust collection noise

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>David,

I built a add-on to my shop to put my DC and Air Compressor in. I built it from 2x4 studs, and then packed in between the studs with the styrofoam insulation that you can get at the big box stores. Works pretty good. It is $6 a 1"x4'x8' sheet. I insulated (for heat/cold) my whole shop with it and it is cheap and easy to work with. All you need is a razorblade or sheet rock knife to cut it.

I can still hear it, but I think much of that is transmitted via the PVC piping..

I have considered adding the silencer that Penn State sells, but right now I am waiting. Would be interested if anybody else has tried it.

Mark

Re: Dust collection noise

#3

Bob Moffett

Re: Dust collection noise

Bob Moffett

>Do you have the dust collector mounted to the wall in your basement? If so, the noise problem may be from the vibration of the dust collector telegraphing into the house through the 2X4's in the wall. The best solution to this would be to make a frame not attached to the wall but standing on the floor and mount the dust collector to that. If you have a free standing unit, try putting some type of absorbant foam above the unit. You might could use foam pillows mounted between the joists for this.

Re: Dust collection noise

#4

Re: Dust collection noise

David Breth

>The collector isn't a wall mount unit - self supporting, on a stand. I think there is some vibration influencing noise, so I'm going to put a rubber pad beneath it. Tonight I crammed a bunch of fiberglass insulation (man, I hate working with that stuff) in the joists above, and enclosed it. Wore additional eye protection, cannister mask, long sleeves, gloves, the whole bit, and my forearms still itch.

Next is I'll figure out how to put a door of some kind to create a fourth wall in the alcove. I'm figuring on plywood, with insulating material glued to the interior. If I have room inside the alcove, I may add some additional materials.

This is why I like turning. When I make this door thing, I'm going to have to measure a bunch of things, figure out how many pieces of wood to do what, what is the width of the saw blade, subtract that twice, get things level, make a bunch of mistakes in my math, and eventually hack my solution into position. Conversely, math is not required for making bowls.

Like I always say, measure once, and....., hey why do that when I can just eyeball it fifty times????

David B.

Re: Dust collection noise

#5

Re: Dust collection noise

Fog Tanner

>David,

I have a cyclone unit mounted on a heavy free standing mount, which rests on foam pads. I used sections of floor mat that comes in a roll at HomeDespot. This helps some, and the weight of the unit helps eliminate the rest of vibration noise. The only noise that I am getting from mine is the exhaust. As soon as I can find some 12" insulated ducting I am going to make a muffler or silencer. A 3'-4' section of duct on an square to round adapter will help reduce the noise as much or more than the commercial units. You get a tremendous amount of noise from the wind. I used to occasionaly fly my unmuffled race planes at the club field with other people around. Occasionally I would get a complaint about the "open exhaust" noise, I would stop the engine and bolt on a muffler (on the ones that would accept a muffler - the others I couldn't hear them talk), start the engine back up. They were always amazed that the same noise was there and it wasn't the engine. I also got the same noise when I bolted the prop to a router motor, it was all in moving the air. So if you can quieten the exhaust sound you will help keep the someone happy.

You would probably have been better off placing sound board between and around your joists. Fiberglass is not the greatest sound barrier, especailly sealed up, but it will work to help dampen some of the noise. You really need a dead surface to absorb the vibration/sound rather than reflect it. A smooth hard surface will vibrate and transmit some of the sound on the other side. Any sort of baffels you can make will help diffuse the sound and cause it work against itself, but you will still need a soft surface to absorb the energy.

Re: Dust collection noise

#6

Re: Dust collection noise

Rick Allen

>Hi David

It is all about the frequency of the noise you are trying to mitigate. The frequency of the noise is a wavelength. High pitched noise has a shorter wavelength than low rumble noise. The collector likely generates noise in many frequencies. But the noise that is heard in the house is likely in one range of frequencies. What this means is that the existing path for noise to travel is already attenuating some of the frequencies. There is no need to further attenuate those frequencies. Instead you need to concentrate on the frequencies which are being heard in the house.

A low rumble is more difficult to attenuate than high pitched sounds. Low pitched sounds have a longer wavelength. So the attenuating material needs to trap 1/2 of the offending wavelength to eliminate the transmission of the sound. Doing the math it works out that low frequency sounds need about 70" of dampening material. High frequency sounds nee about 1" of dampening material. There are very likely many 1" barriers between the dust collector and the ears in the house. But the 70" thick barriers are few and far between.

The math has to do with the speed of sound (about 700 MPH) and the time between peaks of a low frequency wave (actually 1/2). 700 MPH works out to about 14,000 inches per second. A low frequency sound would be about 100 Hz. So there are 100 peaks in that 14,000 inches. Which is 140 inches peak to peak. Well you get the idea. 100 Hz is a very low rumble. 1000 Hz is more of a "deep voice" like "Darth Vader" which would be 7" of sound deadening.

Because most of the energy takes place in 1/3 of that half wave length and because the offending frequency may be closer to 300 Hz you will find that 8" of sound deadening will significantly attenuate the offending noise.

If the offending noise were specific pure frequencies then placing barriers at specific distances would eliminate those specific frequencies. But noise is almost always a combination of frequencies so that filling the space between the barriers with sound absorbing material works best.

Good Luck

Richard

Re: Dust collection noise

#7

Re: Dust collection noise

Dennis Daudelin

>I've just installed a large cyclone collector and it needs to be silenced too! Our local lumber yard (not a big box store) carries sound deadening board in 4/8 sheets. It's supposed to knock something like 20 db off the noise just by itself. It's only about $6 or $7 a sheet.

They also carry resilient metal channel which allows you to mount sheet rock (5/8") off the studs in an isolated way, meaning less noise transmission. The sheet rock is very sound proof at that size.

Do a google search for soundproofing and resilient metal channel and you'll find some great sites explaining how to do this. They have inexpensive solutions and work themselves up to theatre quality stuff.

Hope that helps,

Dennis

Re: Dust collection noise

#8

Re: Dust collection noise

Bill Howatt

>If you have furnace ducting running near the DC it will pick up the sound and what's worse it seems to propogate it quite well. My wife always says the most noise comes through the heat registers.

Bill

Re: Dust collection noise

#9

Re: Dust collection noise

David Breth

>I've thought about this particular radiating problem a bit. I'm not especially close to heating ducts, but I am beneath the fireplace, which is probably perfect to serve as a speaker directly into the family room.....

Thanks everyone for the great responses. I think once I get the unit enclosed, we'll see how it sounds, and I can add on with different devices to continue to knock it down.

Once again - Thanks very much!

My shop is a total shambles right now. Everything is everywhere, and the lathe is just another table at the moment. Hoping to get this dust collector up and running soon.

David B.