Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

12V Motor Question - OT

Posts

12V Motor Question - OT

#1

12V Motor Question - OT

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I was having trouble with the 12V motor that runs my Wood-Mizer sawmill head forward and back. I figured it was the brushes (ruled out mechanical) so I ordered a new set as well as a new motor. When I took the old motor (<10 years old) apart to replace the brushes I discovered that the brushes were the same size as the new ones. It was the plate on which they rubbed that was worn. There was an abundance of oily soot that had a smell like hot electrical wires. I called the Wood-Mizer people because I was under the impression that the brushes are supposed to wear, not that plate. It was the first time that I got nowhere with Wood-Mizer. I couldn't get an explanation that satisfied me. Does anyone have a good explanation?

Re: 12V Motor Question - OT

#2

Re: 12V Motor Question - OT

Jim Swank

>When you say "the metal plate on which they rubbed" is it the face of a segmented copper ring? If so, it's called a commutator. It may have got grease or oil on it that sooted up as the brushes arced through the film. The brushes may even have soaked some of this mess up.

In my industrial electrician days, we used to clean up such a mess with trichloroethane, a nasty but non-flammable solvent. You could try lacquer thinner with adequate ventilation and let it dry well (overnight) before proceeding. If there's a little rut in which the brushes ran, you may want to smooth it out with a fine abrasive. You can do this with a fine abrasive in your lathe.

After all this is done, reassemble with the new brushes, saving the old ones just in case, and try it out.

If you have a good motor shop around, let them do the work for you. If you don't, you have little to lose by trying the above stuff.

Jim, aka arkie

Re: 12V Motor Question - OT

#3

Re: 12V Motor Question - OT

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Jim is it normal for the brushes to wear the commutator rather than the brushes wearing?

Re: 12V Motor Question - OT

#4

Re: 12V Motor Question - OT

Tim Grenville-Cleave

>In theory the brushes should wear and not the commutator, but it is not unknown for the reverse to happen. It's normally caused by contamination (ultra fine grit etc) getting trapped between the two components.

Not 3 weeks ago my mains powered Dremmel started screaming at me, My first thought was bearings but ended up being brushes/commutator I squared off the ends of the brushes and gently reprofiled the curve.

I put the whole armature in the lathe (2000 rpm) and tried to file out the wear grooves in the commutator, to no avail, so with nothing to lose I used an 3/4 oval skew (Do not remove too much there should be small gaps running parallel with the Armature Shaft). It worked, wear grooves gone ... Dremmel working again.

This can be a risky exercise, a tiny slip and the motor is history !!

Just my �0.02p (after tax)

Tim

Re: 12V Motor Question - OT

#5

Re: 12V Motor Question - OT

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Barbara,

It's not unusual to see the commutator wear. It's usually copper, which is pretty soft. You'd expect to see the brushes wear first, but some motor manufacturers spec harder materials to improve brush life. 10 years ain't bad on a motor that is used a lot.

Be sure after you sand the segments smooth to drag something sharp along the gaps between each segment. A lot of times you'll see some copper pushed across the gaps. Each segment needs to be isolated from its neighbor.

Gary

Re: 12V Motor Question - OT

#6

OK Thanks Gary

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: 12V Motor Question - OT

#7

Thanks Tim

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: 12V Motor Question - OT

#8

Re: 12V Motor Question - OT

Jim Swank

>No, but it happens at times, for various reasons. The most common reason is that brushes are not replaced when they should be, begin arcing, stick in the holder, arc even more. A little wear is normal, a rut is another matter and should be dealt with. I don't know how to give a good description in words, and don't have pictures. The best I can tell you here is be aware of the possibility, look closely, and exercise your best judgement if you have to do the work yourself.

Perhaps more important, the brushes themselves should look clean and smooth on the end that contacts the commutator. There should be no black sooty spots, no pits, and they should not have a glazed appearance.