Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Opinions please?

Posts

Opinions please?

#1

Opinions please?

Carole Valentine

>Thinking that maybe I need tomake the collar bigger. Does it look too small to you guys in relation to the size of the vessel?


img

Re: Opinions please?

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: Opinions please?

Keith Tompkins

>HI Carole...No, it's just right!(just my opinion). However, don't be afraid to play with the size of the opening in the collar. I think the collar would look better with a bigger opening. I also like to undercut my collars, rather that a straight 90 degree shoulder. Nice shape, and beautiful piece of wood....

Re: Opinions please?

#3

Re: Opinions please?

Gil Jones

>My overall opinion is that you have become very good at hollow forms.

I have never made a collar, but if you felt the need to make it larger, I would say to flare (taper) the outer edge step so it is less dramatic. It looks OK as is, but is maybe a bit abrupt.

Re: Opinions please?

#4

Re: Opinions please?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Carole, it's difficult to see the shape of the collar against that dark background. Have you ever thought of making a bead for a collar?

Wally


img

Re: Opinions please?

#5

Re: Opinions please?

Carole Valentine

>Thanks, Folks. I'll try another collar with a larger opening and modified base. Wally, yes, I have thought about a bead because I have seen them on some of your things before. Did I ever say you were not an influence? Well I lied! ;) I have not tried the bead yet because I have a looog ways to go when it comes to cutting good ones. I keep trying and trying but they always look like junk. I need to come to AZ and take a lesson! And maybe steal your magic beading tool.

Re: Opinions please?

#6

Re: Opinions please?

Curt Fuller

>There are several ways you could change that collar. But I think it would only be different, not necessarily better. I like it very much as is.

Re: Opinions please?

#7

Re: Opinions please?

Philip F Duffy

>Carol, The collar seems to be sitting above the lovely form. Is that true? Philip

Re: Opinions please?

#8

Re: Opinions please?

Carole Valentine

>Philip, no it's sitting flush, but I think the edge is too thick and that is what makes it look like that. Going to experiment with another one today, but I will probably use ebonized walnut or holly. Blackwood is too expensive to experiment with.

Keith, the small opening was pure laziness on my part...I have a 1/2" drill that has a #2MT which is so easy just to slap into the TS rather than digging out the drill chuck (which must be buried somewhere on my bench) and I use it on all my small forms. You're right - I think this larger one calls for a larger opening.

Re: Opinions please?

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Opinions please?

Keith Tompkins

>CArole, I'm not sure what technique you use to make your collars, but here's what I do...maybe it will help. I finish my hollow form, true up the hole, then glue in the collar. I finish turn the collar as part of the form, following the contour of the vessel. I can see instantly any changes I may want to make....Once I have a hole in the collar, it's easy to enlarge it with turning tools, or add accents. East to refine the collar that way, and usually doen't appear as an afterthought.

Re: Opinions please?

#10

Re: Opinions please?

Curtis TX

>I think the piece looks great. I really admire your work. I learn a lot from the photos you post.

I know my eye is not fully developed to rate forms but it looks great to me.

Re: Opinions please?

#11

Re: Opinions please?

Carole Valentine

>Keith, I know that is probably a better way to do it. I'm just not confident enough at turning collars yet to glue the thing in place first! LOL