Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Yesterday's Project

Posts

Yesterday's Project

#1

Yesterday's Project

Barbara Gill

>I have never tried to put a single piece collar on a hollow form before; so I thought I would give it a try.

This maple vase is 3 1/4"tall x 3" wide. The base is 1 1/4". The top opening is 1 7/8" O.D. The collar is cherry.

I learned several what not to do's when adding a collar.

Any helpful comments welcome.


img

Re: Yesterday's Project

#2

Re: Yesterday's Project

Carole Valentine

>Hey Barb,

Glad to see your getting into these! Couple of comments from the peanut gallery (who really has no business critiquing!):

I personally would have made the collar a little smaller for that form both at it's base, it's opening and it's height. But then I guess it would look like mine and that's not what you are after! Just my two cents worth as I head off to try and make a collar myself. ;) See ya in chat later.

Re: Yesterday's Project

#3

Re: Yesterday's Project

Don Henthorn

>Gues I agree with Carole, but what the heck? For your first one I would be proud. Keep them coming.

Re: Yesterday's Project

#4

Re: Yesterday's Project

Bill Stehman

>Barb,

considering the size of the form, looks great to me. Nice work.

Re: Yesterday's Project

#5

Re: Yesterday's Project

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Thanks, I will make the next one smaller.

Re: Yesterday's Project

#6

Re: Yesterday's Project

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I would have no problem at all with the idea of making a piece that looks like one of yours.:-)

Re: Yesterday's Project

#7

Re: Yesterday's Project

Bob Elliott

>Barb,

I like the way the collar blends with the overall form. To my eye, the collar is a little on the big side.