Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Non power sanding question

Posts

Non power sanding question

#1

Non power sanding question

Curtis TX

>I've been turning for about 6 months and have become addicted. No surprise, right? I am turning bowls, boxes and HF's on a Jet mini. I read the posts daily and learn a lot from this group. This forum is great about posting pictures and honest critiques.

Now for the question. Sanding is proving challenging for me. I am using the box of 4 rolls of 1" sandpaper. 150 to 400 grit. I end up with sanding rings on almost very project. I will stop the lathe and sand with the grain to remove the rings. I am sanding by hand. I am considering an alternative to hand sanding. I see lots of posts about power sanding. However I don't see anything about the non-powered sanding tools. Like the Sorby Sandmaster and others. They use the rotation of the lathe to spin the disk. Are these a good alternative? Do they reduce or eliminate sanding rings? Or will I end up put this on the shelf and spending big bucks on a power sander?

Thanks for your time.

Curtis

Re: Non power sanding question

#2

Re: Non power sanding question

Carole Valentine

>Hi Curtis,

First of all, what are the grits you're using? Are you going from 150 to 220, 320, 400? 150, 180, 220, 400? Seems to me with 4 rolls you are missing a grit somewhere. I am not sure 220 can work on 150 grit scratches nor can 400 work on 220 scratches. When I sand by hand, I make sure I keep the sandpaper moving back and forth sideways fairly fast and run the lathe at a low speed (100 to 180). Be sure and wipe off the grit and dust from the previous grit before going to the next. As for power sanding, do you have a power drill (cordless or corded)? If so, just get the velcro sanding pads and mandrel. Many places offer the kit (Woodcraft, Packard, etc). I use the 2" pads but I don't make big stuff. I have one of the inertia sanders but don't like it very much.

Re: Non power sanding question

#3

Re: Non power sanding question

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>I happen to like power sanding, but the self-powered sanders work.

Make your own. Take a hardwood dowel, drill a hole, just slightly larger than the shaft size of a sanding mandrel, 3/4 of the way through it. Put a little furiture wax in the hole and put the sanding mandrel in it. Works as well as anything.

If you want learn how to make your own sanding disks, go here

http://www.markkauder.com/Tips,%20Tricks%20&%20Articles.htm

Mark

Re: Non power sanding question

#4

Re: Non power sanding question

tek-Brunswick, Ohio

>Hi Curtis

The Sorby sandmaster and the like do work well for some things. I think that you would find them most useful on bowls. There are a few of tips that may help you.

1. Don�t press hard on the sandpaper. Use a light touch.

2. Keep the sandpaper moving. Keeping it in one position lets the biggest grains dig trenches.

3. Don�t step up to a grit more than twice the number you are using, Example If sanding with 150 don�t skip to 320 use the 220 in between.

Power sanding does not need to be expensive. If you own a drill you have the power sander most of us use. 2� and 3� hook and loop backed sanding disks and the holders for them are available from most tuning tool suppliers. Hey have a �� shaft so they fit most drills. A cheap drill works as well as an expensive one. Some people find the angle drills more convenient; I have never tried one yet. I have some good drill motors but use my cheapie for sanding. Sanding is tough on drills because the dust gets into them. Why abuse the good tool? And the cheaper drill weighs a lot less so it�s easier to use for a longer time. When it dies I�ll get another lightweight cheapie to replace it.

Re: Non power sanding question

#5

Re: Non power sanding question *LINK*

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Carol,

You may be over-doing it if you are doing: 60,80,100,120,150,180, etc. I suggest 60,100,150,220,320,400,600,800 or 80,120,180,240,360, etc. You will notice under this system, each step is roughly 50% larger than the preceeding. I think I am as nutty about sanding as anybody, and it works for me, without having to stock all those grits.

If you have compressed air, it is also good to blow the wood off between grits - it knocks off any grit that may be stuck to the wood. It also cools the wood. Compressed air also work well for cleaning clogged sandpaper. I continue to say that an air compressor is one of the best improvements to my ship I ever made.

Mark


http://justwoodworking.com/charts/sandpaper.php

Re: Non power sanding question

#6

Re: Non power sanding question *LINK*

Mike Schwing from Md.

>In addition to the other good responses, here is a reprint of an article I wrote for a club newsletter on the subject.

http://www.woodturner.org/vbforum/showthread.php?t=594


Minimizing sanding scratches

Re: Non power sanding question

#7

Re: Non power sanding question

georgetroy

>I have all the power sanding equipment, but my favorite is the inertia sanders. I have the 3" & 2". They are great for my arthritic hands. I do not have a scratch problem. Only use power sanding where I can not access with the inertia. Packard is a good source for them.

Re: Non power sanding question

#8

Re: Non power sanding question

Scott Hogsten

>You are going to get as many replies to this as there are turners . Some things that might help. I always go through the full sequence of grits without skipping grits. Start with whatever grit it takes, if you need to start with 60 grit start with 60 grit. Also don't move on until you have removed everything that can be removed with that grit. If you have tearout sand it with a course grit paper until it is gone don't skip ahead and hope the next grit removes it.

Get a bright light to help you see any defects before you move on. If your paper is shedding grit while you are sanding get better paper and until you get better paper make sure all of the grit is gone before moving on. Keep the paper moving and easy up on the pressure at the end of each grit.

Scott

Re: Non power sanding question

#9

Re: Non power sanding question

Rick Allen

>Hi Chris

Welcome to the world of woodturning. That sanding thing takes a while to figure out. Along that path you will also find that you are making better cuts with your turning tools. That will have a big impact on sanding.

The strips of sandpaper are okay for some sanding but you can easly put scratchs in spinning wood with the edge of those strips of sandpaper. It is better to use something round ro sand with as you will avoid long edges that can scratch.

As for power sanding, you are very likely going to be power sanding at some point. You can try all the other "sounds like that should work" ideas first if you want. Or just skip ahead to the power sanding. As I said above, improving your turning touch is going to have a bigger impact on sanding than anything else.

Re: Non power sanding question

#10

Re:Don't waste your money on....

JamieDonaldson

>...any non-powered sander. Set yourself up instead with several 2" Velcro-type sanding discs and a drill that you probably already own, and a selection of pads. A normal progression would be 80,120,220,320,400, and as your tooling skills improve you can start right off with 120. Do some sanding of problem areas with the lathe off, and don't crank lathe speed up too high- then the sanding is hitting only high spots.

Re: Non power sanding question

#11

Re: Non power sanding question

Tim Grenville-Cleave

>Me too, for Power sanding I use cheap mains drills and throw them away when they pack up. I also have a Kirjies motor combined with a flexishaft (you could use a drill mount with the mains drill and Shaft.

I have in the past cobbled together an old sewing machine motor(with foot control) a 3/8" chuck and a flexishaft, worked like a dream and flat out I could use carving type burrs etc as well !!

Just my �0.02p (after tax)

Re: Non power sanding question

#12

Re: Non power sanding question

Rick Davenport

>Harbor Freight has a close quarter, variable speed reversable drill for 30 bucks.

It's a great way to start power sanding inexpensively.

Rick

Re: Non power sanding question

#13

Re: Non power sanding question

Carole Valentine

>Thanks Mark. I have found that 150, 180, 220, 320, 400 works for me (mainly because that is what I have) but I really haven't tried any different combinations other than starting with a lower grit (80, 100 or 120) if I have some problem wood. I do sometimes go through higher grits, up to 800 or maybe even micromesh depending on the wood and what finish I am after. I will have to try the 50% thing and see if I like the results.

One thing that I am religious about is running fresh paper lightly over the edge of my lathe bed to take out any outsize particles that can leave unnecessarily deep scratches.

Re: Non power sanding question

#14

Mike, Thank you for posting this.

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>

Re: Non power sanding question

#15

Re: Non power sanding question

Curtis TX

>I am thankful for the time to put into your responses. Very helpful.

1. I use 150, 220, 320 and 400 grit

2. I am probably using too much pressure- I'll lighten up

3. I am not blowing off the dust/grit between grits. This will change.

4. I do have drill so I'll try some sanding disks.

Thanks again.

Curtis

Re: Non power sanding question

#16

Re: My home-made sanders

Allen Neighbors

>With the exception of the wooden-wheeled one on the left, all these are made from Roller-blade Wheels. They've never failed me yet. Here's how I make them: Rough the inside of the bearing with a file.

Epoxy 1/4 inch all-thread in the bearing, being careful to get the glue ONLY on the inside, or you'll glue the bearing (toothpick works).

Bend the all-thread about an inch back from the wheel, to a 45 degree angle, or so. Glue on a large dowel handle.

For the sanding pad, I cut a circle out of some old shower shoes (flip-flops), and epoxied it to the wheel. Then I glued some velcro hook to the pad. They work like charms.!!! This is an old photo. I've since made more, and have them all the way to 400 grit. I use the 3" H&L discs from Klingspoors. Hope this helps.

Allen


img

Re: Non power sanding question

#17

Re: Non power sanding question

bob davis

>carole your grits work for me

Re: Non power sanding question

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: Non power sanding question

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Curtis, I am one of the few proponents of hand sanding. Here are some of my methods....first, use a backing pad of some sort under the paper...your fingers alone will leave ridges. Don't hold the paper in one spot.....keep it moving, back and forth, never letting it stop in one place. Already, you will see an improvement.

Perfect your turning technique....a torn surface is difficult to bring to a satisfactory finish....bruising and torn fibers usually transfer to the surface when the finish is applied. When approaching a finished sanded surface, lightly dampen the surface and allow to dry....then final sand again. Deeper scratches will raise up, allowing you to sand them away.

Re: Non power sanding question

#19

Re:Don't waste your money on...I did.

georgetroy

>But Jamie I did and the inertia sanders works just like they did when I watched Vic Wood use his about 3 years ago. I brought one right on the spot and never looked back. I have arthritis and I need them badly. I can't even turn without my thumbs aching. No pain no gain, and use it or lose it. GT

Re: Non power sanding question

#20

Re:Don't waste your money on....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I disagree Jamie. I've been using an inertia sander ever since Vic Wood gave me one in Provo about 10 years ago. (Still using the same one) It doesn't work well on the inside of bowls, but then I seldom turn anything but hollowforms. I do have a Makita right-angle drill which I use for sanding under certain conditions.

Wally