Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

Posts

Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#1

Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

TDaniel

>I am one who a few years ago would never have considered a truck that wasn't made in America and my sons were likewise. Last week-end my son traded my old F-350 in for a Nissan Titan. Reason? The F350 was basically a very good truck. Problem? Dealers ripping us off. $300 to fix the brake lights, $1000 for replacing the electric door locks and one window motor, $1000 to replace bearings in rear-end and another $1800 to have an independent shop do it again because the dealer busted the bearing race when he replaced the bearing. All this is no fault of the people who built this vehicle. Why don't the auto manufacturers investigate the dealerships and eliminate those who are ripping us off instead of laying off more workers? Bitch complete!

TD

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#2

Steven Antonucci

There wouldn't be a dealership left in the USA

steve antonucci

>With the advent of the internet and information availability, I think a lot of dealerships have lost a huge percentage of their profits on the vehicles they sell. In the old days, people guessed at what the dealer will take for a particular vehicle. Today, they walk out paying dealer cost and let the factory pay the dealership through rebates.

I just had a conversation with a buddy of mine who works on cars as a hobby. His girlfriend paid the dealership $300 for something he could have done for $60 in parts. Add in salary expense, insurance, taxes... and it's easy to see how it became $300. Where I stuggle with the whole way mechanics work is in flat rates- charging someone for 2 hours because you had it on the lift for 2 hours while you worked on three other cars seems like fraud to me.

In the end, it comes down to how many defects your vehicle has over it's life. Lots of people fail to maintain their vehicles, or expect too much (don't put 1/2 ton in a 1/2 ton truck...)

You are right however on the guilt factor of buying American, but what does that mean? Cars and trucks are designed in one place, parts from everywhere, and assembled in yet another... When is it an American truck? Oh, yeah- when you add the gun rack in the back window...

Steve

Driving my Nissan Frontier since July, two problems so far...

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#3

Re: There wouldn't be a dealership left in the USA

Jerry Whitaker

>Still driving my '04 F-150 truck with 24,000 miles, zero problems, 21 mpg....knock on wood! Still driving 2000 Ford Explorer, 90,000 + miles, very few problems....knock on wood, knock on wood, knock on wood!!! Friend has an '05 GMC truck with nothing but problems. You never know what you got till you plunk down thousands of $$$ and then it is too late. I think we should be able to buy vehicles from Walmart, drive them a few thousand miles and then take them back if we don't like them.

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#4

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

Peter Teubel

>TD wrote "All this is no fault of the people who built this vehicle."

===================

So why not go to a different dealer with a better reputation?

I was considering the Titan when I was shopping for a new truck. It had good specs but wasn't available with a long bed. I ended up getting a better deal on a new (left-over) heavier-duty Dodge diesel.

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#5

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

Ron Bauman

>When Ford owns (in part or wholly) Mazda, Volvo, Jaguar, etc. What is a foreign Car-truck? In this world wide economy I think our responsibility is to reliable brands and our pocket books.

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#6

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

Bill Hale

>TD

You can go on line and buy an extended warranty for your new vehicle for about $ 2000.00 that gives you a bumper to bumper coverage for 7 years and 100,000 miles. Tailor your purchase to how you drive, miles to years.

Be sure to read what is excluded. I allways buy the best they offer and seldom have I not come out ahead. It is nice to be able to walk in to a dealer and say fix it and know there will be no charges.

Bill in Casa Grande

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#7

DODGE IS A FOREIGN OWNED TRUCK MANUFACTURER

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>DAIMLER-BENZ

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#8

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

Tim Grenville-Cleave

>The problem is not confined to the USA, we in the UK have been suffering from that since time began. For years I would not buy anything manufactured here ... why? because the workmanship and quality was beyond belief !!

If you wanted good workmanship and reliability you had to buy Rolls, Bentley, Aston Martin or suchlike. Now they are all owned by overseas companies and to be honest ... to me they have lost some of the ..... je ne sais quoi (sp) The attidue of our Trade Unions did not help much either (nuff said).

Trying to get a good job done by a dealer for a reasonable price is almost as difficult as getting my son to do his school homework!!

Having a Dealer complete a 3000ml service, new front brake pads and wiper blades all round on my 2001 Jeep Cherokee 4.0lt cost me �900.00 ($1,561.41) three weeks before Christmas ... I was not a happy Teddy Bear!!!!! (I had to have a Dealer do it otherwise bang went the Warranty)

It strikes me that now if you want anything at all done by anyone other than friends etc you had better be prepared to have your wallet hemorage money faster than you can top it up !!

Just my �0.02p (after tax)

Tim

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#9

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>After my vehicle is out of warranty I would never go to a dealer to have work done. In our town we have a small repair shop (10 or 12 employees)that is listed by AAA as one of the 25 best in the state. Prices are less and I believe that they are honest, which many big dealers are not. Every summer we take a 5000 mile trip to the NW. I always get what they call a trip-check. For $35 they check out all of the systems. Money well spent.

Years ago my wife worked as a bookkeeper for a large Cadillac-Oldsmobile dealer. They regularly performed work that wasn't needed and charged large prices for it.

Wally

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#10

So what?

Peter Teubel

>I wasn't making a foreign/domestic point. Just comparing my needs to what was available. I guess that I (technically) own a foreign truck.

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#11

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

John Lucas

>TD That's why I bought my Toyota. They are made in the US and they outlast most other trucks. I won't take it to the dealership which is a Dodge/Toyota. They ripped me off years ago on a set of brakes that I'm pretty sure they didn't change. You don't wear out brake pads in 10k miles. Unfortunately the dealership changed hands and even that particular mechanic dissappeared. My local garage guy is honest as the day is long. I'll pay him any day over the dealership.

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#12

Once fine day

David Breth

>My dad and I had a conversation with a very dear family friend back in the early 90's. He was an island hopper in WWII and was part of the occupation army in Japan. He was being fattened up for the mainland invasion when the war ended. He saw some terrible things, he's done some terrible things, in he's always been a total hero in my eyes. He's still around, scrappy as ever. In the early 90's, my dad and I both owned Japanese cars - Nissans. That friend said something that resonated with me. As best I can paraphrase it - "I spent years out there, tired, hungry. Sometimes I didn't think I would make it back home. And you go out and buy Jap cars."

Now, I'm not naive, I fully realize that the business of vehicles is international, everybody owns everybody, Japanese cars are made in the U.S., various parts are made in various countries, whatever, I get it. But I'll always remember what that friend said to me, and I don't think I could ever buy a Japanese car again, simply because he found it so hurtful, and if he found it hurtful, so do other WWII vets.

David B.

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#13

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

Ron in Drums PA

>We have two Toyotas, a 04 Lexus which has 69,000 miles and a 03 Highlander which has 15,000 miles. We also own a 02 Dodge mini van with 38,000 miles. I always have our local mechanic do all of the maintenance. Not only is he less expensive, but more honest than any Dealership I know of. As long as you show receipts for scheduled maintenance you will not lose your warranty. To Date, Zero Problems.

FYI

The Toyotas are made in America.

The Mini Van is made in Canada, and as we all know, is owned by a German company.

Look under the hood of any vehicle, no matter what brand, and you will find parts from all over the world.

BTW, We had a 1999 Lexus with 180,000 miles which we had no problems while we owned it, we traded it for the 04.

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#14

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

Jerry Whitaker

>Bill said, "You can go on line and buy an extended warranty for your new vehicle for about $ 2000.00 that gives you a bumper to bumper coverage for 7 years and 100,000 miles".

This is exactly what I do. If you plan on keeping a vehicle much past the warranty period, this expense is well worth it.

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#15

I Drive a Dodge Dakota-----

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

>

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#16

Further OT

Rick Davenport

>I have a '99 Astro van (14mpg) for my sharpening service and to tow my travel trailer.

Whenever possible, I leave it in the carport.

Instead, I drive a Taiwanese knock-off of an Italian scooter (75mpg) or my wife's new box on wheels (35mpg).

How's that for International even-handedness?

Rick

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#17

Forgot the picture

Rick Davenport

>I use a helmet when driving the scooter, of course.


img

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#18

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

Steve Mushinski

>TD,

It is something the North American parent companies seem to not get a handle on. Going for service should be a pleasant experience not an argument. Cleaning up dealerships seems to be something they cannot look into due to life long agreements sign years ago. Another poster is right about the profit per vehicle is much lower now. I could be wrong but they would get around 15% at one time and now they are lucky to see 7%. Therefore, they go after the repair dollars.

I have a 98 US built GMC truck that has never seen the inside of a dealership service bay. Not one problem with it over the 8+ years I have had it. Lucky I think not as I just picked us a new car for the wife that is perfect. I know it was prefect as it was checked in a bumper-to-bumper audit with everything within build specs. A Canadian built Chevy Impala SS, which I would recommend to anyone. I would not ever recommend taking anything to a dealership to be serviced out of warranty.

BTW: I work in the Canadian plant that builds the Impala. This plant just happens to build some of the best quality vehicles one can buy from any manufacture (Independent facts not my opinion). The bad part is they are closing one of the three plants in Oshawa. How many plants did they close in Mexico, which happens to have the lowest quality? ZERO

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#19

My Tundra

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>My Tundra was assembled just one hour away from me. Not only do I have total faith in it (being a Toyota) but I have a little regional pride incentive for buying it as well.

Tommy

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#20

I wonder about lathes & wheels

georgetroy

>We buy these high dollar cars and trucks. Why do I see some buying a el cheapo lathe; when it's better to buy something a little bit more and enjoy it longer without out all the limitations. Whew!!!! Maybe I should have kept all those muscle vehicles I use to drive. GT

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#21

Re: Once fine day

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I'm a WW2 vet. Fought in the Pacific. Saw lots of action. Two purple hearts and a 30% disability. Just as in this country, the leaders made war and the people had no choice. Get over it. I drive a Toyota.

Wally

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#22

Like you said before

Ron in Drums PA

>You get what you pay for.

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#23

Dealer problem

TDaniel

>Wally, that is what I am seeing. The dealers are putting the manufacturers out of business. Most of them are nothing but crooks now. I took my daughters vehicle to one of our local dealers for a noise in the front suspension; they wanted almost $500 to fix it. Then I took it to a front-end shop down the road and got it fixed for $30. Because of that we don't even go onto their lot anymore. I am not going to buy a vehicle from 75 or 100 miles from here and then have to take it that far for service. As I said earlier, this isn't fair to the people building these vehicles that are losing their jobs. Sorry dealers are putting Americans out of work. Both the Ford plant and the GM plants in Atlanta are closing. I get the Ford employee "A" plan prices but even that isn't enough to make me buy another. Don't the higher ups at Ford and GM read their mail?

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#24

Keith Tompkins

Re: Dealer problem

Keith Tompkins

>Hi TD, How do you think the poor slob working for the dealership feels? He is usually the one who really gets ripped off in the end. He is TOLD to replace parts he knows are not bad, and not given enough time to properly diagnose a problem, let alone fix it. Given the complexity of today's vehicle, the technicians must stay totally up to date on vehicles, and buy their own tools as well. If they take too long to repair a vehicle, they lose. Spend four hours to repair a vehicle....get paid for two....how long can someone live on half-pay before they get a bad attitude? Also consider, warranty time pays only half the reasonable time it takes to repair a vehicle. ANd you wonder why the dealership cannot fix your car.

People are people...no matter what their profession. A certain percentage are hard working, honest people. A certain percentage are incompetent, and should consider changing careers. And, a certain percentage are crooks....whether a professional or a blue collar worker. The car business is no different that any other.

I can tell you this about the car repair business...find someone you are comfortable with, and stick with them. If you trust someone, give them your business....they will respond in kind. They will value you as a customer, and do what it takes to keep you happy.

Recently a book was published, the original theme was to show how badly the car repair shops were ripping off the public....by the time the book was ready to be published, the writer had a change of heart. Many times when he expected to be gouged, it turned out the shop owner stayed late the fix the vehicle, just to make a satisfied customer, and charged a reasonable amount. He encountered this situation time after time....he realized there are many hard working, caring people out there. The trick is to find one.

NOW, let's consider my three day hospital stay with a 30,000 dollar pricetag.

Re: Totally OT; trucks, jobs, loyalty

#25

Re: Dealer problem

georgetroy

>Yeah Keith! It's your car and body. I hope you got what you paid for from the hospital. You race with what you brung. GT