Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

2 Board Foot Contest

Posts

2 Board Foot Contest

#1

2 Board Foot Contest

RussFairfield

>I hate to say it folks, but your response to this contest is pathetic. You are showing your appreciation to both Ellis and the sponsor (Jet) by sitting there doing nothing. And, that is a loss to all of us.

I read the poor response as that nobody is interested. Maybe the timing is wrong, or maybe the rules are wrong for this contest. Either way it will be a long time, if ever, before either Ellis, Jet, or any other Vendor will be foolish enough to sponsor another on-line woodturning contest for us. And that is our loss.

There are a couple of us who don't qualify because of the 25% rule, but the rest of the folks who post messages and pictures should be entering this contest. I see pieces of turned wood posted here every day that would be worthy of entery into this contest; there have been at least 5 that I can remember over just this past weekend, but they aren't there. Everyone is sitting on their hands. I don't understand it.

What is there to lose?? All it takes is $15 and 3 pictures. Ellis has extrended the deadline at least 3 times that I know of, and there are still only 9 entries showing. That insures that everyone who enters will get at least get one of the $25 Gift Certificate, and there is a 1 in 3 chance for getting at least a $100 Certificate. With odds like that, it is impossible to lose.

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

#2

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>I'll second everything Russ just said. The only thing anyone can lose is a little bit of pride in entering this thing. I am one of those disqualified from entering since I make my living doing this stuff, but I will never forget a quote by Ellis himself at one of our guild meetings. He said that amateurs had an edge over professionals in turning out quality work because they were not hampered by deadlines or economics. A lot of you can afford the time to make a piece as perfect as possible. It would be a shame to miss out on this opportunity.

Bill

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

#3

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

Rick Davenport

>I appreciate the efforts of Ellis and Jet.

And I am impressed by the entries so far.

Some day I may produce a piece worthy of entering.

Until then I will watch and learn.

And ask lots of questions.

Rick "tearout" Davenport

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

#4

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

Carole Valentine

>Russ and Bill, I agree and I feel like a real creep for not having made a bigger effort to find a piece of wood that would be suitable and large enough to qualify. I had nothing large enough for that size except sopping wet wood (gum at that.) That's no excuse. I could have bought a piece or cobbled something together if nothing else, but I didn't. I did have a piece that was 247", but I assumed that 2 board feet meant 2 board feet and before I found out otherwise, I had cut it into two blanks and had no photos. I really did not understand the purpose of having the size limitation, but it was certainly their perogative. I was originally intimidated a bit by the images on the opening page, but only for a minute or so. I do think that may have discouraged some other novices, however.

I stand justly flogged. Sorry, Ellis

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

#5

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

Norm

>I'll admit to being intimidated by the photo's on the opening page as well as the current entries, I had wanted to enter this contest, but having seen the current entries I changed my mind and decided my work is more in the class of beginner if that. In fact I had asked my wife if she thought I stood a chance, she too just looked at the opening page, and was brutally honest in telling me No you don't stand a chance, I then explained to her that these were not the entries but quality pieces I one day will be able to compete with:)

So if there is another contest (beginner I'm there!) A suggestion would be to not include the pieces on the opening page, as well as keep the current entries hidden until the contest is closed?

Also about the odds someone mentioned above, about there being more prizes than entries, I too took note of this, and used in my thinking of not deciding to enter, I feel that there should be a minimum # of entries for prizes to be awarded to make it fair to this site and Jet.

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

#6

***CONTESTS***

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Thanks, Russ. I appreciate the cheerleading, and I, too, wish that more people were entering this particular contest. I'm actually thinking of extending the deadline one more month to give people a chance to reconsider their participation (or lack thereof). Stay tuned. It doesn't help my credibility to extend the deadline indefinitely, but I want to give Jet/PM a great contest and an excuse to jump back in for a future contest.

Apropos of which, I just nailed down another contest that I will be announcing shortly. It will open in the next couple weeks and close in mid August. I think you will be pleased to see who the sponsor is and who the judges will be.

We are also on the verge of a contest to launch in November and come due in February. I think you're all gonna really like this one.

So, the good news is that the future of contests at WoodCentral looks so bright I gotta wear shades. And the Two Board Feet contest ain't over yet. I still think it is a great challenge that Betty has set for us, and I suspect we're going to see quite a few more entries before we close it off for judging.

Cheers, and thanks for stirring the pot,

Ellis

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

#7

Thanks, Norm

Ellis Walentine, Host

>That is valuable feedback. If people are seeing the pieces by Betty and other top-notch turners, that could be discouraging them from entering. I didn't notice too much falloff on the Coffee Table contest because of the two pieces I put on the entry page -- which happened to be old pieces of mine. Maybe that's why. :-)

Anyhow, I would encourage you not to be influenced by the photos on the entry page. Those are intended to inspire you, not scare you away.

Ellis

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

#8

Well shoot!!!!

Carole Valentine

>I just re-read the entry rules and I think I misunderstood them from the beginning. It says "Select a piece of wood that contains a MAXIMUM of two board feet of lumber." For some unknown reason, I thought you had to start with 2 bf, which now that I think about it, does not make much sense. I think that got lost in all the kaffuffle of what constituted 2 board ft. Sure wish I had pics of some of the wood I have turned in the past week. :(

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

#9

Re: ***CONTESTS***

john lucas

>Ellis In all honesty I guess I was just sort of lackadaisical after reading the words 2 board ft contest. I didn't even look up the rules and prizes or I would have worked hard on an entry. My fault, I was just too busy and decided I didn't need one more thing eating away my time. Like Carole said I feel bad about not entering but now time is too short since I have to work late the next 2 nights and won't get in the shop at all. I certainly appreciate your trying to spur us on by making contests.

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

#10

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

Marsh Pronneke

>Here it is Tuesday evening and just about time for bed and I noticed the post on the contest and still can't belive there are not more entries!!

I guess I should really be out in the shop finishing mine and get it's picture taken and entered. But I do plan to by the end of the day Friday with any luck.

I'v been very busy with work and other things here and not much time for the shop!

I also agree that if there are not enough entrys they ought to cancle the contest, it's not fair to Russ or Jet to put out the prize money and only a handfull enter and all win by default!

I put up a post last week or the week before about this same very thing and had no real responce.

So let's get some entries flowing in to the site.....

Marsh

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

#11

Re: ***CONTESTS***

Chris K in MD

>Ellis,

Like I posted earlier, I was ready to enter but the extension in this case put the thought into my head that I might turn something that I like more and would rather enter that peice. I will enter something I have the peice that I originally was going to enter. If I come up with something else better Ill change my mind.

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

#12

Re: ***CONTESTS***

Colin Spencer

>Ellis, Are non US based turners allowed to enter? If so I might just have time to do something for Friday?

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

#13

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

gtwilkins

>"All it takes is $15.00" "What is there to lose??"

Simple answer $15.00

The last thing I will spend money on is to enter any contest no matter who or what is sponsoring it, what is the fee for? looking at 3 pictures. Get real, I live on a disability pension. The idea of a contest is so that all can enter!

I really find your attitude and tone in your post objectionable, perhaps before announcing a contest you should find out if anyone is interested in it first!

Trevor

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

#14

All are welcome

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Sure, Colin. Have at it.

Ellis

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

#15

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

Ellis Walentine, Host

>Hi Trevor,

I'm not sure whose tone you find objectionable, but I'm the culprit who thought up the contest, and I might as well tell you that there are a couple more in the works.

In this case, I attribute the light turnout (pardon the pun) to the fact that we did not have widespread promotion outside this site, not that people aren't interested in competing for valuable prizes. Also, the instructions may have been confusing or intimidating to some.

Regarding your objection to the entry fee, rest assured that nobody is getting rich at the contestants' expense. Production, administration and judging all cost money. But, I can appreciate that it might be an obstacle for someone on a fixed income. Perhaps we should work on a reduced fee for folks in your category.

Thanks for the feedback.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

#16

Re: Thanks, Norm

bob davis

>what is the 2 ft contest..what are the rules?

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

#17

Re: 2 Board Foot Contest

gtwilkins

>Ellis, It was the first post from Russ I found objectionable, however when a company such as Jet decide to sponsor a contest, all their expenses are a tax write off for them, the administration,judging costs etc are part of the contest as well as the prizes. The company receives advertising far and above the cost of the contest.

I will state again, I will never, ever pay to enter a contest and I have spoken to several people here who's reply was basically the same as mine, they had a project planned but when a fee is charged for a contest there is no way they will pay to enter.

I had a unusual project halfway finished until the $15.00 came up when I finally read all the rules and that was that!

Ellis I appreciate all the effort and work that you have been doing and continue to do for the group, but I take umbrage when a professional turner of Russ's status, posts a message such as he did.

Trevor