Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Ring of Fire

Posts

Ring of Fire

#1

Ring of Fire

Ed Kelle

>OK I want some serious feedback on this one, good and bad. Just finished an hour ago, it's most likely my entry for the Long Island Woodworking show this weekend. Most likely because my backup piece is the lidded cherry vessel with the texture I showed a few weeks ago. I think this one tops it. We only can have on piece judged, so I am hoping to pick the right one.

7" Cherry body, walnut textured lid, maple beam, and Pink Ivory flame. Thanks go to Scott Longberry for this Ivory, he generously gave it to me in the wood exchange. It is very dense heavy wood but finished up almost like stone. Not nearly as fragile as you might think on the narrow flames. The beam runs thru the flame and it about 1/8" thick where it goes thru, narrowing from the lid and also curving on top and bottom. The flames arch against each other, better shown in the next pic.

Check out the rest of the pics and let me know your thoughts.

Thanks!

E


img

Re: Ring of Fire

#2

insides

Ed Kelle

>Approx 3/16 thick, as consistent as I could get it, fairly lightweight body, and the inner profile does come to the same sharp transition as the outside. Underside of the lid has the mortise for the body and retains the gentle slope of the outside, though it gets slightly thicker at the top. Initially I wanted an open roof to this to imply a portico tye of look, so maybe sunlight would move across it. I decided it still needed something and then came up with the beam, which needed another way to pick it up. This led to a shape in walnut, but after a restless night, I decided to cut up that nice pink ivory and do a flame. This is really a box, and the bottom of the flame stops just shy of contacting the table when the lid is removed.


img

Re: Ring of Fire

#3

Re: Ring of Fire

John Lucas

>Ed I like everything about it but the cross piece that holds the flame. I think I might have made it curve up instead of down inside. Mount it slightly proud of the top by 1/8 or 1/4" and then slightly more curved than the top. Maybe even an oriental sort of curve going down and then up over the top and back down on the other side. I like the concept of a finial floating in space. Maybe the flame could start down below the piece and the wrap around the maple insert. Kind of like a gas flame where there isn't any flame for 1/2" or so and then the flame starts and grows bigger and then narrows to a point.

Re: Ring of Fire

#4

Profile view

Ed Kelle

>Really a roundish form, I countered with a gentle slope to the lid. I wanted to contrast the sharp uppercut on the rim area, and have a shadow area below the lid. Lid is about the same size, I hoped to create more of a unified shape by this.

Finish is oil and knocked down to a matte finish, I really like the natural almost unfinished look, It goes with the thatched style roof. Flame is slightly glossier on purpose.

I'd apreciate some feedback on this. Thanks!


img

Re: Ring of Fire

#5

Re: Ring of Fire

Carole Valentine

>Ed,

Very creative piece! Like John,though, I am not crazy about the single cross piece support for the flame. It just does not seem to go with the rest of the piece. Maybe try a circular support of some type? What came to mind was something like this, but I'll be the first to admit that I have not thought long and hard about it.


img

Re: Ring of Fire

#6

Re: Ring of Fire

Rick Davenport

>I am far, far, far from being an expert but here is my free opinion.

I hope you get more than you paid for.

I really like the lid and the flames.

They go together quite well.

A very Japanese/Samurai feel.

And both spectacularly well done.

But the bowl doesn't seem to carry on with that theme.

Perhaps the lid should be flush with the bowl?

For whatever it's worth......

Rick

Re: Ring of Fire

#7

Re: Ring of Fire

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>Hi Ed,

I like the workmanship, but the name doesn't jive with the piece.

Like the others I'm not a fan of the single support piece. I think the lid could have been a single piece with a curved recess in which the flame would be eminating. To me the flame, with the single glued in support, looks too much like an add-on. It distracts from the rest of the work. Right away I focused on the crosspiece holding the flame.

Being a novice at turning I may not have grounds to comment on this so feel free to let me know.

Re: Ring of Fire

#8

Texture ? ? ?

Barry Turner

>Very nice piece. How did you get the texture on the lid?

Re: Ring of Fire

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: Profile view

Keith Tompkins

>HI Ed, Here's my thoughts on your piece. The finial is a hit!...very cool. However, it does'nt seem to fit with the rest of the piece. To me, the base is a bowl, a very traditional bowl form which stands on its own. The lid and finial don't really add to its appeal,and seem to be just added on.

I think the hole in the lid is distracting, adding one too many elements. It also creates a problem of how to secure the finial in a pleasing way. Perhaps a solid lid, with a small element to visually seperate the lid from the finial. Another thought would be to pierce the lid in an area around the finial, which would create a similar feeling to what you have now, yet appear a bit more unified. These two options would elevate the finial and really make it the focal point.

Like I stated, the finial is very good....it really deserves a box designed just to show it off. If you can come up with that....another home run. I have a couple of thoughts..I'll contact you personally. Keith

Re: Ring of Fire

#10

lots to think about

Ed Kelle

>I've got a lot to think about with this piece now. But for the show, I will display it as is. Then maybe revist the whole concept to tie it all together a bit better. Like the last one, I've got to sit this on the back burner for a while until the answer suddenly appears. Thanks for taking time to make such insightful comments, I appreciate it very much.

Re: Ring of Fire

#11

Re: Profile view

john lucas

>I like the lid and the hole. This seems to be a cermonial vessel with a fire inside. It needs the hole for the fire. The texture feels like the right surface for a ceremonil vessel with a perpetual flame. I like that concept and think you will have fun changing this around. You could possibly put the flame in the very bottom and let it come out through the top so it's no longer a lidded vessel but a ceremonial piece.