Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Masculine v. feminine

Posts

Masculine v. feminine

#1

Keith Tompkins

Masculine v. feminine

Keith Tompkins

>Let's face it...there is a difference in the way women and men are built. Adjectives that describe a female form would be graceful, beautiful, delicate. Words that may describe the male form would be utilitarian, strong, heavy-duty. Ferrari vs. diesel truck.

Could we use this same analogy to define our turned pieces? Furniture makers have been doing that for centuries. For example, a table with heavy, straight legs appears strong and durable. A table with tapered legs has a light, delicate appearance. A classic example would be the "Queen Anne" or cabriole leg.....a classic, graceful design.

To me, heavy, blocky bowls have the same masculine appearance, while lighter, flowing forms appear more feminine. WE, as turners, speak about how wall thickness, foot size, and form affect the way a turning appears; these same characteristics could be referred to as either masculine or feminine as well.

Appropriate? Any Opinions? A fair way of looking at our work?

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#2

Re: Masculine v. feminine

RevDoug

>You may have an idea there, Keith. As I look at my collection of pieces of both my work and the work of others, many do indeed have feminine qualities while other are definately masculine in nature. As I think about it, I also find it interesting that I prefer the more womanly shapes while my wife prefers the more manly shapes. Causes one to ponder. I know I'll have to think on this a bit longer.

Turn 'em round,

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#3

Re: Masculine v. feminine

Carole Valentine

>Keith, I think we can definitely apply male/female characteristics to turnings. I was looking though some pics of my very early turnings(groan) and the feminine and masculine form of two of them really struck me. (No comments on the craftsmanship, please...these were done about a month after I started turning! LOL) It take guts for me to post these awful things, but they are just one example of what I consider as feminine or masculine forms.


img

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#4

Re: Watch It, Boss

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>You'll get yourself branded as one of those sexist gender-typing elitist-type artists! "Male" can be just as graceful as female, and "female" need have nothing to do with "gentle". Given the same criteria, males of all species tend to be larger with more muscle mass. Beyond that, I think your assuming literary terminology that has been abused as justification for human male discrimination. Since the male/female distinction is essentially a sexual criteria, I'd leave it out of artistic anaylsis unless you're trying to determine whether the artist being reviewed resolved their Oedipal conflict.

|;-}}

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#5

Say what?

TDaniel

>

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#6

Re: Masculine v. feminine

Barry Turner

>Let's don't make this sex thing any more confusing.......

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#7

Re: Masculine v. feminine

Allen Neighbors

>okay..... which is which?

Allen

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#8

HMMMMM

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>"Adjectives that describe a female form would be graceful, beautiful, delicate. Words that may describe the male form would be utilitarian, strong, heavy-duty. Ferrari vs. diesel truck."

Kieth, I think you need to get out more. :-)

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#9

Re: Look out for this minefield!

JamieDonaldson

>This sexist labeling thing will only get you into trouble! I still remember my Mother's comments when returning from a church convention, where the old hymn "Onward Christian Soldiers" had been sanitized into "Onward Christian persons, marching as to conflict." Etc, etc, etc!!!!

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#10

Re: Look out for this minefield!

JamieDonaldson

>And now for my attack of "hoof-in-mouth disease," in these days of grossly obese anatomy, its often hard to tell the difference between male and female with their drapery on! I just received an email forward yesterday regarding a "topless carwash" and it was hilarious and disgusting!

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#11

Re: Masculine v. feminine

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>I'm with you Allen....In my eye they both look somewhat feminine to me? I think they both have graceful curves.

...and Carole these were a MONTH after you started turning! You have the gift my friend!

Jen

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#12

Re: Masculine v. feminine

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Keith I think for sure that there are feminine and masculine forms. I think what might be another interesting thing to investigate is....do women turn more feminine forms than men? I had someone comment to me at an art fair once that my work was so different from the male turners. That it really had a woman's touch. I wish now that I would have asked her about her comment. Instead I just said thank you.

This is an interesting topic for sure. You always come up with these thought provoking posts!

Jennifer

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#13

Answer

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Just remember Jamie....when us girls ask the question "does this foot make my bowl look big?"....there is only ONE correct answer!

: )

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#14

Re: Masculine v. feminine

Arch

>I suppose for those for whom the wood sings, soprano and bass voices are heard. The more artfully inclined probably can hear delicate contralto and tenor nuances. For those who can discern a vessel's gender: "Vive la Difference" :)

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#15

Re: Masculine v. feminine

Carole Valentine

>LOL! Well I guess it's not as obvious as I thought! To me the female has a definite feminine curve - hips taperin to a waist then out again. The male has no hips or defined waist, but has broad, strong shoulders. Guess it's just my way of seeing things. ;)

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#16

Re: Masculine v. feminine

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Ahh...Now I know that when I'm reaching a little too far with the tool inside a thin walled hollow form, that screeching that I hear has to be female. On the other hand, that rumble that I hear when turning the corners off a spindle turning must male.

Do we now refer to our turnings as a "him" or a "her"? Are my hollow forms "girls" or if they sag a little are they "old ladies"?

Wally

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#17

Re: Masculine v. feminine

Arch

>Carole, probably it's modesty, but what part of awful do these early pieces _really suggest? With no 'saccharine buttering up', I see them as well done and pleasing for what I see was intentioned. If others see faults that I missed and if you don't object, I and maybe others can learn something from an honest critique of your two vessels. Perhaps as a separate thread.

Thanks, Arch

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#18

Re: Answer

john lucas

>The only answer is to run. There is no correct/safe answer to that.

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#19

What?

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>What?

What?

Whaaaaaaaaa-t?

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#20

Re: Masculine v. feminine

Carole Valentine

>Arch, I don't have them anymore (they went into the burn barrel) but as I recall they were thick and heavy, with bad tool work and even worse sanding and an awful finish. You can see on one, by looking at the oil penetration, where the wall is thin in some places and thick in others. I suppose the exterior forms were not too awfully bad for a beginner, but like most of us, when I look back on early pieces, I tend to think "yuck!" ;)

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#21

Re: Masculine v. feminine

Tim Grenville-Cleave

>Arch, I may have a problem ... I do not hear Sopranos, tenors or altos etc just Blues, Joplin, Hendrix, Cream, Skynrd,Zeppelin and that sort of stuff. wonder if thats the reason I get things banging off the walls (or wasn't the chuck tightened up enough?)

Tim

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#22

LOL

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#23

Re: Masculine v. feminine

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi,

Well maybe there are Masculine and Feminine shapes in pens as well. I describe a "human shape" when I look for design in making a pen.

I often look at the cap as the "shoulders" and the lower portion of the pen as the "hips and legs".....some shapes attract different people more than others..

:-)

I will not answer the question "Do my fingers Look Fat on this pen?"

take care,

Jim


img

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#24

Re: Opps

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Jim,

I can think of about 6 responses to your post, but every one of them will get me in serious trouble on this board. Therefore I'll just say "nice (no gender statement) pen", and leave it at that.

|;-}}}

Re: Masculine v. feminine

#25

Keith Tompkins

Re: Masculine v. feminine

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks for the responses...that was fun. I do believe many female turners approach the lathe with a different attitude than many men do. for instance, men tend to power through a cut, using brute force if necessary. Dull tool? Just push a bit harder.

I have to remind guys to lighten up the grip, relax, and let the wood come to the tool. DON'T force the cut. The lady turners seem to do that instinctively.