experimental piece
TDaniel
>I just tried a lidded box with a domed lid and finial. Is it doomed?
Size is 5.5" diameter
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
experimental piece
TDaniel
>I just tried a lidded box with a domed lid and finial. Is it doomed?
Size is 5.5" diameter
Re: TD-the turning is fine, but ...
JamieDonaldson
>... the focus is wanting. Sharpen up!
Re: experimental piece
Mark Wollschlager
>The shape is interesting. Sort of a tureen.
It might sell well to a fan of the occult with that dye job.
Although I don't want to know what they might use a tureen for.
mark.
Re: experimental piece
Dennis Y
>Hi Terry. I think that a traditional dome would have been a better choice. The ogee just doesn't do it for me IMHO. Dennis
Re: experimental piece
Keith Tompkins
>Hi Terry, I've been studying this piece for a few minutes...my initial impression was that the piece resembles a bowl with a lid. Th
My critique, if you don't mind...It seems the shape of the lid and the shape of the base fight each other for attention. Either one on its own seems fine, but together, they seem to clash. Maybe the base looks too much like a bowl, and I'm having trouble getting past that. I would suggest(on the next one)working on the shape of the base to flow with the shape of the top.
I absolutely love the shape of the lid. Flip it over, and to my way of thinking, it's the perfect bowl form. Flip it back over, and it's a stunning lid. You nailed it.
The finial....I like the idea of the "natural edge" on the top, it has a dramatic effect. To me, it needs to slim down to the point where it meets the lid; this would add visual interest as well...as would dying it black...possibly adding a small golden bead to separate the colors. A combination of red and black is rich.
Doomed? Absolutely not. I would enjoy seeing more of these.
I'm probably the last person
Don Henthorn
>who should comment on form, but as a utilitarian bowl ot is fine. I think I would have given the bowl part a more pronounced Ogee and a smaller bottom. But then it would have been my bowl not yours.
yeah, it was a night shot under the flourescents
TDaniel
>
Re: experimental piece
TDaniel
>Mark, the finial is a small piece of burl that I hollowed. The color is actually bright red but the light makes it look pink. I think it would look better without a foot and will try that next time.
Thx Dennis
TDaniel
>I am not sure if the dome is too high or not. I will try another without a foot and see if that helps. Something needs refined but I am not certain what.
Thx Keith
TDaniel
>Is it the foot? Or is the base too short for the lid?
Stay tuned
TDaniel
>I am going to try this again.
Thx for yourcomments.
Re: Thx Keith
Carole Valentine
>Terry, Keith sees exactly what I said to you in chat...the curves fight each other and he did a much better job of expalining it! I think redefining the curve of the base to compliment the top is in order. You could still have a foot if you wanted but it would need to be much smaller.
Re: Stay tuned
Keith Tompkins
>Terry, do me a favor...and try this. Your lid fits perfectly into a triangle, which is a teaching method I use to work with form.
Print out a photo of your piece, then draw a triangle to outline your lid. Then, draw one around the base. You will notice, the foot won't fit in the triangle. Then, experiment with various triangles for the base until you find a balance between the top and the base. You will notice the triangle will also create a well proportioned foot.
Here is a very rough sketch of my idea, and how it would work. You can experiment with the size of the base this way to see how it looks before you turn it. Let me know what you think....
Re: experimental piece
Gil Jones
>Not doomed at all (though I am not a dye fan).
Looks nice to me. Maybe a bit less dome.
better pic
TDaniel
>I shot this with some daylight thrown in; any better?
Re: better pic
georgetroy
>Why change anything Terry? You don't won't cookie cutter projects on experiments. I do see a bruise around the edge, I guess the dye likes it better. It will probably change in time any way. Looks fine the way it is too me. The comments reminds me of some of my experiments I do with burning, painting and carving. What you see is what you get, if it doesn't taste good don't buy it. You get an attaboy here. GT
Re: better pic
Allen Neighbors
>I agree, GT. It's different, but I like it. Keep experimenting, TD, you give us all some more ideas.. :o)
Allen
Re: better pic
Mac
>Naw...still sucks...he he
Thx GT and Al
tdaniel
>
Kiss it Mac :)
tdaniel
>