Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Go or No Go Results

Posts

Go or No Go Results

#1

Go or No Go Results

Rick Davenport

>I posted a cracked piece of cherry a few weeks ago.

Asking whether to continue or bail on the project.

I decided to go forward and finish it.

Here is the result.

Comments/critiique are welcome.

Rick


img

Re: Go or No Go Results

#2

Bottom View

Rick Davenport

>Here's a pic of the bottom.


img

Re: Go or No Go Results

#3

Re: Bottom View

Jim Rutten

>Neat bowl. Nice recovery. Thanks for sharing.

Re: Go or No Go Results

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Go or No Go Results

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Rick, I'll make two comments... first, you did a nice job with the form, smooth, flowing shape. I would work on the foot a bit, as it appears to still have the dovetail profile from the chuck...to me, that gives an unfinished look to an otherwise good form.

Second, looking at that piece of wood, I would not consider turning it. Here in the northeast, cherry is plentiful, and there are lots of good sound pieces to choose from. A catch would have torn about a third of your bowl away, risking injury to yourself.

You will probably get many different opinions than mine, but I'm not one to advocate "saving" pieces, to me, they never look right.

Re: Go or No Go Results

#5

Thanks Keith

Rick Davenport

>I appreciate your constructive criticism.

Yes, there is a faint line in the foot from the chuck.

I thought I had sanded it out, but it reappeared when I finished it with walnut oil.

I am contemplating filling the cracks with a contrasting substance,

turquoise maybe? and when/if I do, I will definitely sand out the mark on the foot.

And yes, it was a questionable piece of wood.

Right now my wood inventory is miniscule but growing so I use what I have - I need the practice.

Plus I'm stubborn and I liked the shape it was taking.

I did take the precaution of masking taping it up when I hollowed the inside so I minimized the personal danger.

All in all, I'm glad I have taken it this far.

It forced me to use a light touch when hollowing and it finished up nicely.

I really like the satin feel to it.

Thanks again Keith.

Rick

Re: Go or No Go Results

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Thanks Keith

Keith Tompkins

>Thnk you for posting it! The chuck has a way of crushing the fibers of the wood, bruising it. It only shows up when the finish is applied. I must say, you took a marginal piece of wood (at best) and really made it work. I look forward to the pieces you'll be making soon enough. Nice job, Rick.

Re: Go or No Go Results

#7

Re: Additional comments about...

JamieDonaldson

>... this project. I saw your comment about using masking tape-NOT SAFE, unless you wrap a strong tape like filament shipping tape over it. Don't be too anxious to fill these cracks because the cherry will continue to move and pop out fillers for a long time as it dries. O'Tools Law decrees that marks and crushed fiber areas don't show until we apply the finish!

Re: Go or No Go Results

#8

Re: Go or No Go Results

Bill Hale

>Rick

I would rechuck and shorten the foot. To me it is to tall for the form. At the same time clean it up and get rid of the chuck marks.

When you have chrushed fibres you can, many times, get rid of them by wetting with water.

I too would have kept this piece and worked it. Nice save

Goo0d turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.