Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Silent Air Compressor

Posts

Silent Air Compressor

#1

Silent Air Compressor

Larry Mart

>We are in need of a very quiet, almost silent air compressor to power a "Powercrafter" carver. These are glorified dental drill tools that rotate at 400,000 rpm. The requirements of the Powercrafter are 1.5 cfm at 40 psi. The important thing here is "quiet".

We've looked at airbrush compressors but they are too small. We also attended a demo by Gene & Peggy Kircus where they used such a compressor, but attempts to locate them have failed.

Does anyone have any experience with such a compressor?

Thanks, Larry

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#2

Campbell-Hausfield has one.

TDaniel

>

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#3

Re: Silent Air Compressor

John Lucas

>Larry Check with Binh Pho. He bought one designed for airbrushes and it is virtually silent. it runs the air grinders quite well. it was sitting less than 5 feet from me and I could barely hear it. Don't remember the brand.

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#4

Re: Silent Air Compressor

Phil Powell

>I run an air brush and other air quipment off of a CO2 tank with a regulator.

Absolutely quiet, cheap to refill and lasts for a very long time. My tank came

from a bar where, at one time it ran a beer tapper. Just a thought.....works

for me.

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#5

Re: Not-Quite-Silent Air Compressor *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Larry,

Woodcarvers Supply sells one that operates at 80db for $300. Item No. is 791006 at the link.


Wood Carvers

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#6

Re: Silent Air Compressor *LINK*

Rick Allen

>Silentaire makes these things. They are pricy when compaired to the pancake or twin tank compressors that we are used to. They are designed to be used in a doctors (dentist) office. The CFM is incrreased by ganging the basic unit with others.

For your use consider a double. Expect to pay between $1000 and $1500 for such a compressor.


Silent air compressor

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#7

Re: Silent Air Compressor

Larry Mart

>Thanks John. I sent an e-mail to Binh, but in the meantime I found out he uses the Silentaire brand. Very pricy little compressors!

Larry

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#8

Re: Silent Air Compressor

Larry Mart

>A CO2 tank might work for a couple of hours but this thing is being used every day and these carvers use a tremendous volume of air. We used to have one of those 60 gallon tank vertical compressors and I was surprised how often it had to recharge.

I'm afraid I'd spend more time and money getting the tank refilled then just biting the bullet and getting the compressor.

Larry

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#9

Re: Silent Air Compressor

Larry Mart

>I found the Silentaire site and after recovering from sticker shock I might have to consider one. The list price on the one we need is over $800, but I've found a dealer that sells them for $569. That's still a lot of money for a small compressor.

It is quiet...rated at 30db...about the same as your refrigerator.

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#10

Re: Not-Quite-Silent Air Compressor

Larry Mart

>I'm thinking 80db is still going to be too loud according to all the sound charts I've seen. The Silentaire model is a couple hundred dollars more but is only 30 db.

Thanks for the link.

Larry

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#11

Re: Silent Air Compressor

Bob Fawcett

>Try a Nitrogen bottle. Nascar guys use them to run the airguns at races. The large bottles (I think the big size is 220) hold a lot of nitrogen at 2000+ PSI, far more than CO2. CO2 is also temperature sensitive. You can usually rent or lease a bottle from a supplier.

I would guess that the $1000 for a silent compressor would buy a whole lot of refills.

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#12

Re: Silent Air Compressor

Bill Hale

>It sounds as if you are in a fixed area. If so consider putting a standard compressor in an inclosure and insulate with sound insulation. Pvc pipe to carry the air is cheap and the extra distance helps quiet.

Distance,sound diminishes with the square of the distance.

My compressor is outside of my shop in a small building that has standard house insulation and it is quite quiet.

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#13

NO PVC!!! Yikes!!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Bill and all,

PVC pipe must NEVER be used for air systems. OSHA has completely banned such use for high risk of explosions and serious, if not fatal, schrapnel wounds for anyone in range. PVC is fine for non-pressure water drains, and was used for low pressure residential water systems up to 60 psi. It is very prone to rupture if bumped when under air pressure, and the failure propels razor-sharp shards of plastic 20-30 feet with real force even at 90-100 psi.

If you have a PVC air pipe system, please, PLEASE replace it before someone you hold dear gets hurt.

Rant Off

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#14

Re: Silent Air Compressor

Larry Mart

>Bill, We are living in a condo type community with neighbors very close. No outside buildings are allowed. We have our garage to work in and SWMBO will want to do some carving on the patio, hence the need for the quiet compressor. She will use it most of the time and she needs to be able to move it around. A larger compressor or a bottle of gas would be too big and heavy for her.

Her birthday is next month so it is either a compressor or jewelry. Hmmmm.

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#15

Re: NO PVC!!! Yikes!!

Bill Crommett

>And furthermore: Talk to sopmeone who left his compressor on one nite and a small fire got started near the PVC pipe. If you have ever had to blow on some sparks to get a campfire going you will realize what 100 PSI blowing through a small melted leak could do to a shop. I believe i garnered this information from THE BADGER POND, and it took me two days to tear out my PvC and replace it with copper.

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#16

Richard Allen

Re: Silent Air Compressor

Richard Allen

>It sure is hard to justify that sort of cost for an air compressor.

Please note that the cfm listed is free air. Also note that the duty cycle is 50%. If you want to use 1.5 CFM at 40 PSI you are going to need more than the 2.15 CFM free air rateing that compresor has.

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#17

Re: Silent Air Compressor

jared

>buy the compressor, you can always buy jewelry later. Besides the compressor would hold its resale value better and should be tax deductable if you have any sort of business that you could run it through. Jared, who once bought my wife a week eater for our anniversary.

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#18

Re: Silent Air Compressor

Ed Heuslein

>Howdy Larry: I recently met a fellow from Houston who makes silent compressors of any size you need (his words, not mine). I gave the card to a DAW member. Contact me by private message and I'll get you the info. Remove "nospam" from my email address above.

Howdy to Judy.

Ed

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#19

Re: Silent Air Compressor

OB OBrien In Pensacola

>Larry; I've been looking at all the replys for a quiet air compressor. Here's an idea that I have been kicking around for a while. I would also like a silent rig so I could run a dental handpiece when camping. Scuba tanks are available that hold 40, 72, 80 and 100 cubic feet of air at 1250 to 3000 PSI. A 1st stage scuba breathing regulator puts out 125 psi. There are accessories in a scuba diving shop that can be plugged into the regulator to air up tires. So by hooking up a dental handpiece to a scuba tank you should be able to run the drill for (100 divided by a cfm of 1.5) about 66 hours on one tank. Tanks are fairly lightweight and can be refilled for 10 to 15 bucks apiece. I'll hook one up (maybe today) and give it a try. OB

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#20

Re: Silent Air Compressor

OB OBrien In Pensacola

>OH I forgot. You will need another regulator to reduce the 125 PSI to about 30 PSI for the dental drill. Maybe even an automatic oiler in the line.

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#21

dunnit

TDaniel

>OB, once upon a time I exhibited machinery at shows where I needed compressed air which was very expensive to get for a 2 day show. I started using the compressed tank of, I think, CO2 with a regulator. Not positive on the contents of the tank but it worked well. Then we began using a small piston type Craftsman compressor and built an insulated box around it with a small opening for air intake. This was very quiet and worked perfectly. It is much cheaper to build an insulated box than to buy a quiet compressor.

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#22

Re: Silent Air Compressor

Larry Mart

>"So by hooking up a dental handpiece to a scuba tank you should be able to run the drill for (100 divided by a cfm of 1.5) about 66 hours on one tank."

Wouldn't that be 66 minutes instead of 66 hours? But anyway, thanks for the suggestion. I think I've found a practical solution with a sound insulation cover. See my other post in this thread for the long version.

Larry

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#23

Silent Compressor Fix-LONG Reply!

Larry Mart

>I also made a few inquires to turners that use the Powercrafter tool and asked what they use for an air source. John Lucas mentioned Binh Pho who is probably the most well know user and he just replied to my email. I'll quote his answer:

Hi Larry,

Quiet compressor is very expensive that is why you don't see many people use

them except the dentist or Lab work.

The Powercrafter requires 3CFM to run at the recommended speed. The one I

use at the demo only produce around 1.8 CFM, but I was able to use it for

demo because I didn't have to pierce continuously, while I was talking, I

allow the compress air building up in the tank. I don't use my quiet

compressor at home, it intended for demo only because it's not enough power

to run continuously. At home I use the noisy one just like every one else,

but I have 80 gallon tank so it only comes on once in a while, I also put it

in the different room to reduce the noise.

However if money is no object to you, here is where you can get the quiet

compressor. The one I have, it around $1,000, but if you want to get the

proper one for the continuous use, it will cost you around 2,000 -3,000.

Go to this website and check it out: www.silenaire.com

Good luck

Binh

I also called the manufacturer, Silentaire, and they told me I'd probably burn up the $800 compressor using it that much.

Another friend checked with an aircraft acoustical engineer at his work and he sent me this:

"He can use simple plywood for the enclosure box - 3/4" thick gives 24 to

35 dB transmission loss across all frequencies which is equivalent to

dropping the noise level to less than 1/4 of what it is unmuffled.

He'll want to seal around all the seams in the box with a common sealant

like silicon since small leaks can really degrade the acoustic

performance.

More challenging is the air intake. He'll need to make a duct that is

lined with foam and is as long as practical given his work space. He'll

want to make the duct as narrow as possible so that the passage between

the foam walls is thin. I'm guessing that the dominant compressor

frequencies are rather low so he'll want 4-6 inches thick of foam - not

sure what Home Depot has for material but mattress egg-crate foam would

probably work. If this duct could be 5-6 times longer than it is wide

(in the narrow dimension) and if the opening could be pointed away from

the work space that would be best. I'm guessing he could run the air

hose out of the inlet duct to avoid making another opening in the

enclosure. I'm envisioning a tall narrow inlet duct with the sidewalls

covered with foam, the floor is one "wall" and the top of the duct may

be covered with foam too. If this could be 4 inches wide between the

foam (16 inches wide including the foam), and a foot tall, perhaps 2

feet long it should work well. "

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#24

Re: Silent Air Compressor

Brenda Barnett

>We have a brand new DeVilbiss 1 HP that is sold with the Powercrafter tool. My husband's utilizes the Powercrafter's in his firearm engraving business (we actually have 3 in service at all times with different burs in them). We bought a used Powercrafter from an individual about a month ago which included the air compressor. But we don't need it, because we have a large compressor set up right outside the shop and plumbed in to the work area. The woman we got it from had never opened any of it. We opened it to look at it, but it has never been used. I would be willing to sell it if you are interested, but I cannot attest to how quiet it may or may not be. Thanks

Re: Silent Air Compressor

#25

Re: Silent Air Compressor

john lucas

>Brenda I'm looking for something I can use in the house and isn't very expensive. If you think this will fit the bill e-mail me and let me know how much.