Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

Posts

Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#1

Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>TD and All,

Just wondering what the chat topic was for tomorrow night? I'd like to make a suggestion that we do not use the Wednesday night "reserved for Turning" chat time for chat that is related to the symposium. The reason being is because the chat room is for everyone here on the board to learn and communicate and I feel like it leaves people out who are not going. If we want to chat about the upcoming symposium and such then we can gather in the room another time. There are plenty of other opportunities for that. I was bummed when I read Wally's post about not coming to the chats if we're going to be talking about the symposium, and I'm sure others felt the same as Wally..and so I am making the suggestion that we make sure the topic encompasses woodturning and not specific to any one outing or an event that not all are going to be involved with.

I'd love to propose the topic of getting into ruts, slumps....or lulls in our woodturning. Time when we just aren't feeling inspired to get out in the shop and turn...or when we do get out there...nothing seems to be coming off the lathe that we feel really good about. I'm actually in a good mode right now but I have these lulls sometime and they really get me down and would like to know how others deal with these times. Where do you get your inspiration!

Anyway...just a few thoughts?

TD I hope I'm not stepping on your toes here.

Jen

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#2

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

Ken DeMarco

>"I'd love to propose the topic of getting into ruts, slumps....or lulls in our woodturning."

Sounds like a good topic to me Jen, I have not turned a thing for a month now for this reason, ( well that and work is busy, and building a barn, and rehabing the kitchen, and on and on) I also saw someone else posted recently about what he called the sophmore slump, and how to get past it

Thanks

Ken DeMarco

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#3

Re: I am joining Wally.

RussFairfield

>Lets me know when it's over.

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#4

Ditto

Ron in Drums PA

>

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#5

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

Rick Davenport

>I'm confused Russ and Ron.

Are you boycotting Jennifer's idea for this week's chat or the past topics related to the symposium and/or gathering?

Jennifer's suggestion sounds good to me, but it sounds like other ideas will be entertained as well.

I guess I will show up when I can and see if it's relevant to me.

Rick

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#6

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

RussFairfield

>Let me explain. The conversation in the Chat Room will be about planning for the Gathering until it is over. No matter what other topics are tried, it will always come back to the Gathering. For those of us who are not going, it is a waste of time to sit for 2 hours reading messages that are meaningless to us.

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#7

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Russ this is exactly what I'm suggesting we avoid. It's not fair to those who aren't going to sit and read about plans for an even they are not attending. It's just not good use of the chatroom during the weekly time (Wednesday evenings) that is set aside for the turning chat. The room is for everyone to enjoy. I certainly would be bored to tears if I weren't going and that's all that was talked about. Like you I would probably use my time in other ways. The people attending the Gathering can set aside another time to talk about that when the room isn't "reserved".

Just my opinion.

Jen

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#8

And it's a valid good opinion

john lucas

>I don't mind talking about the gathering but I certainly agree that this rules out people like Russ and Wally. As a long time turner I learn a lot from these guys and others to numerous to mention. I find it interesting although I have trouble keeping up with all the different conversations.

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#9

I tried an alternate room

Ed Kelle

>I set it up, even entered it, but the room name would not show up on the list of rooms. I logged in a second user and still could not see this other public room. Oh well, I tried.

If anyone else can get this to work that would be a great option for us to have when the room is reserved. I'll check in tonight and try again.

Not sure if this has something to do with my Mac.

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#10

Out of bounds?

TDaniel

>Last Wednesdays' chat was on a subject that was supposed to be relevent not only to the Gathering but to any event where we have to judge others' work. The topic was "how can we fairly judge the work of others?" The immediate need to do this will be at the gathering but setting up some sort of points system to eliminate politics in judging is something that is needed long-term for various events. Prior to announcing this topic I spoke to 2 collectors about the subject and they both said they would like to know what other turners thought of various pieces. Scoring a piece, as someone suggested...like the Boone and Crockett system for scoring deer racks...might add to the value of a piece. We strayed off the topic frequently but that has happened in the past. I am sorry if anyone felt left out.....it was not intentional.

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#11

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

Ron in Drums PA

>No, I'm not boycotting the chats.

I will not be going to the TDs next month, so there is no sense in me hanging around on Wednesday nights until we get back on schedule.

I'm going to miss them, especially the critques

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#12

Re: Out of bounds?

RussFairfield

>TD,

There is no need to reinvent any wheels. I am sending you a PDF file of a copy of the Newsletter of the Western Cape Woodturners. On page 6 there is an evaluation sheet for judging the technical merit of a piece of turned wood. It might be similar to what you are looking for.

I have used this system, and it works. I have a couple others available if I can find them.

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#13

Re: Technical Evaluation

RussFairfield

>If anyone else wants a copy, send me an e-mail and I will send you a copy of the file.

Don'task for it here, because I might not see it.

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#14

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

Carole Valentine

>Am I missing something here? Has anyone said that the chats from now through the 19th of April will just be about the gathering? I don't think so. Yes, there was one chat during which the topic was planning for the gathering (there were even some there who didn't even know about it and wanted to know more) and one for scoring pieces. So what? During all the critique chats, did we talk about the gathering rather than the topic? I don't think so. Maybe some of us mentioned it to one another during the open chat between 9:00 and 9:30, but is that not allowed? Are we now so censored that we are only allowed to talk about things that EVERYONE in the room is interested in? Well, I guess that means that I won't have to listen to chats about promoting clubs, which doesn't pertain to me since there is not and probably never will be a club here. And the hobbyists who don't sell won't have to listen to chats concerning marketing. Pen makers won't have to listen to chats about hollow form design and bowl turners won't have to listen to chats about pen making. And if some want to discuss their plans for Georgia in chat on a Saturday night, I suppose they will have to bar non-attendees from the room. Sheesh! Lighten up people! Not all topics are of interest to everyone. Be a pretty dull world if that were the case. If you are not interested in whatever someone is talking about, steer the conversation to a subject you are interested in (if it's an open chat), strike up a private conversation if it's not an open chat, or go out to the shop and turn whatever it is you turn, but don't make a federal case out of it. We are all individuals with a common bond and many different interests within that bond. That is what makes us friends and most friendships require a bit of tolerance.

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#15

Exactly what I was looking for

TDaniel

>I just printed it out Russ. It appears that they have spent a few years perfecting their standard and it is as fair as anything I have seen. Thanks Russ!

TD

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#16

Ellis Walentine

Russ, send me a copy...

Ellis Walentine

>... and maybe I can upload it somewhere.

I'm a little concerned about the "technical merit" designation, though. Where do aesthetics, materials selection, appropriateness, functionality, cost, etc. enter the equation?

I guess I should wait to see the bulletin.

Thanks for the offer.

Ellis

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#17

Re: Don't get me wrong

RussFairfield

>Carole,

You are reading a lot more into my message than what is there. Normally, I would be there tonight as I have been there every Wednesday night for the past 3+ years. The difference would be that when the conversation gets into who will be sleeping where, how the gallery and auction will be run, what you will be eating, who will be demonstrating what, and the general excitement before attending a big event, I would not participate.

There were a couple people last week who questioned why I had anything to say when I wouldn't be there. Since I have nothing to offer, and would offend some of those who did, I will take the same option as Wally, and stay away until it is over and things are back to normal again.

I have no ulterior motives, just a personal choice.

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#18

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

Allen Neighbors

>Yes Maam. :o)

Allen

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#19

Re: Technical Evaluation

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Me, too.....Me, too

Mark

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#20

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Nope Carole...nobody said that from now until after the Gathering that all of the chat sessions on Wednesday night were to be geared towards discussions of that...I was merely making a suggestion. Nothing more.

Jen

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#21

Re: Don't get me wrong

Carole Valentine

>Russ, one of my points was that, as far as I know, (and I certainly have been wrong in the past!) the chats are NOT dedicated to discussing the gathering until after it is over and I don't want people to get that idea and just "stay away" because they think that is the case...you, Wally and Ron included. Nor do I want to feel censored to the point that if I have a comment even remotely related that I have to do it through email or private chat. Even if a discussion does arise in a general topic chat, I see no reason why input from non-attendees is not valid (and valued!) if they choose to make suggestions. After all, many who are not attending HAVE been to similar events and probably have valuable input that would make this one, and perhaps future ones, a success. Whether or not they choose to share that knowledge is up to them.

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#22

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

Carole Valentine

>I know you didn't say that Jenn. My reply was not really directed at your post but rather to those who feel they should just stay away from the chat room "until it was over" because the chats from now until the gathering will be about nothing else. Not true! And your suggestion for a topic tonight was a good one, BTW.

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#23

Let us know where you put it, Ellis

Carole Valentine

>I am interested as well.

Re: Topic for Tomorrow's Chat ??

#24

Ellis Walentine

Here... *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

>The part Russ refers to is on pp. 5 and 6.

Ellis


Cape Rules