Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

To bolt down or not??????

Posts

To bolt down or not??????

#1

To bolt down or not??????

Bernie

>Have a PM4224 pretty heavy lathe 850lbs

what is your thoughts on bolting that down???

Thanks,

Bernie

Re: To bolt down or not??????

#2

Re: To bolt down or not??????

Bill Hale

>I have a Oneway 2436 at a little over 1000 lbs and they say to bolt down.

I do have to say that mine is not and I have no problems.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: To bolt down or not??????

#3

Re: To bolt down or not??????

Ruth NIles

>Bernie, my lathe is less than 800 lbs. and it's not bolted down. I was told, it's not good for the machine to be bolted down because the insides will take more of a beating or have to absorb the extra stress of unbalanced rotations. Not that it's a good thing to let the lathe "walk" around the shop. The guy that told me this is a machinist and has seen lathes and other expensive machinery wear out faster because of the extra stress.

Just passing along advice I received.

Re: To bolt down or not??????

#4

JL

Re: To bolt down or not??????

JL

>You can always add a ballast box if necessary (or lead blocks).

Re: To bolt down or not??????

#5

Re: To bolt down or not??????

Ron in Drums PA

>Ruth is right, it's not a good idea to bolt down machines.

Bolting down equipment causes stress to the frame which in the long run can cause problems.

Re: To bolt down or not??????

#6

Thanks I'll add ballasts

Bernie

>

Re: To bolt down or not??????

#7

Try roofing shingles.....

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Bernie,

I took the advice of another forum user and put two roofing shingles underneath both ends my 600+ pound General lathe. This was just what I needed to stop the shimmy and vibration that I was getting from it sitting directly on the concrete floor of my shop. When your shop warms up enough the shingles allow the feet of the lathe to seat in the softened material and it really does work wonders. I was also in the "to Bolt or Not to Bolt" quandry when someone told me about the shingles. I went to Lowes and they had a half open box and just gave me 4 of them. Try it. It might be just the ticket?

Jennifer

Re: To bolt down or not??????

#8

Re: Alternative *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Bernie,

Follow the link for a very interesting alternative. It ain't pretty like Dominic's deal, but it works. Don't need it on my Stubby, but have seen it used on a 1236 to good effect. Remember, though, that you'll still need slow speed for out-of-round rough pieces that you can increase slowly as the piece comes round.

Problem with bolt-downs on lathes is that all the vibration gets transferred into the bearings which then wear abnormally fast.


Damper

Re: To bolt down or not??????

#9

GREAT IDEA I WILL TRY IT

Bernie

>

Re: To bolt down or not??????

#10

Leo Van Der Loo

I'll add ballasts, Concrete slab is also ballast, *LINK*

Leo Van Der Loo

>There is no difference, bags of cement, lead blocks or concrete floor.

The real problem is being able to turn bigger heavier and more out of balance, AND DOING THAT, when you add ballast or bolt to the floor.

Yes your lathe could wear out faster or even break doing this, however don't blame it on the lathe being bolted down, lots of large machinery is bolted down in industry, or have house size rubber dampened concrete blocks where the machine is bolted to.

Get the lathe you need for the work you want to do, and if you are not able to afford that size, than bolting to the concrete floor, or adding ballast will afford you some leeway, just know what you are doing.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo


http://homepage.mac.com/l.vanderloo/PhotoAlbum25.html

Re: To bolt down or not??????

#11

Re: To bolt down or not??????

RussFairfield

>Here is what I have to say about bolting the lathe to the floor. This is from the FAQ Page on my website.

2 - Should I bolt my lathe to the floor?

The answer to this one depends on the weight and strength of the lathe. The lathe must not move when it is used to turn wood. Your asking this question tells me that you are having a problem with the lathe moving. The easy answer is to start turning smaller pieces of wood that better fit the capabilities of the lathe you have. If you don't want to do that, there are two choices - a bigger (heavier) lathe, or bolt this one to the floor (or table). If bolting it to the floor causes damage to the lathe, then you needed a heavier lathe. If the new lathe is heavier, you may not need to bolt it to the floor.

There can be a problem with turning large and/or unbalanced pieces in a lathe that is bolted to the floor. If the wood wants to move and it cannot, something else will �give�; and that is usually a fracture in the bolting pads at the floor; but it could be a failure of the spindle bearings. For this reason, many will advise that the lathe should NOT be bolted to the floor because that will let the entire machine move as a warning.

3 - How heavy should a lathe-stand be?

This question has the same answer as No.2. There is no such thing as being TOO heavy. If it moves, it isn�t heavy enough. If it wiggles, it isn�t rigid enough.

The heaviest stand in the world will not save a lathe that is too small or too light for the turning tasks that you are asking it to do.

Re: To bolt down or not??????

#12

Russ

Bernie

>I have a Powermatic 24" 4224

Not much avail larger than this lathe.

I do turn large pieces but any out of

balance piece will rock any lathe no

matter how large. It looks like bolting

it down is not the best idea. I will try the

shingles and add more weight to it.

Bernie

Re: To bolt down or not??????

#13

Re: Russ

Joe Herrmann

>Dale Nish answered that very question in the "Ask Dale" column in the last issue of Woodturning Design. He answered that he sees no reason why is shouldn't be bolted to the floor. He did offer some precautions to take, however, such as making sure that it is level and secure. He also suggests that the lathe not be abused or used to turn things that are beyond its capacity. Speed is also an issue.

Joe

Re: To bolt down or not??????

#14

Re: To bolt down or not??????

Fog Tanner

>Bernie,

I have a 24" Vicmarc which weighs in at 1000 pounds. I went down to HomeDespot and got a couple of feet of the gray rubber mat used around machines. Its a little over 1/2" thick. I cut two 6" strips for the feet to rest on. The machine is not bolted and runs rock solid. If I turn some really out of balance pieces, the machine will rock a little - depending on the speed. Sometimes I can drive through it, if I can't I just back the speed down till it stops. I would rather have the lathe move and let me know to slow down instead of replacing bearings.

One if the turners in our club that does really large off center pieces on a Oneway 2436 outboard, has his machine bolted to a 4'x8' sheet of plywood. This adds a lot a stabiity to the machine but will let it move "if it has to". These are pieces that he has to use a chain hoist to get onto the machine.

I've worked in several machine shops where none of the machines were bolted down for the reasons mentioned.

Re: To bolt down or not??????

#15

If you want to bolt it down...

TDaniel

>use rubber pads under the feet and leave the bolts loose so the machine can rock a little. This will keep the machine from turning over and will keep it from walking around the shop. Like everyone else has already said, If it rocks you need to back the speed off til it stops rocking.

Re: To bolt down or not??????

#16

alot of great info THANKS

Bernie

>

Re: To bolt down or not??????

#17

Re: If you want to bolt it down...

joaz

>Both of my lathes, the 800lb antique and the 24" Vega are bolted through rubber pads,through the floor, into cement columns with half inch bolts. I do leave the nuts a little loose. This has worked great for me as far as getting rid of vibration.

just my 2pesos.

Re: To bolt down or not??????

#18

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: To bolt down or not??????

Dennis in Southern Oregon

>Ruth, Ron and Russ, I have to take issue with you on the bit about bolting the lathe down increasing the risk of damaging a lathe. This is an old spouses tale that comes up every now and then in the woodturning forums. A simple argument will show why that is not so. First, bolting has no effect unless the force of the unbalance is large enough to lift the lathe off of the floor (or topple it). Second, for any amount of unbalance, the greatest stress on the spindle occurs when the "heavy spot" is accelerating upward, that is pushing downward on the spindle, because at that time it adds to the total weight of the turning. After the "heavy spot" has reached top and starts accelerating downward, thereby tending to lift the lathe, the centrifugal force acts in opposition to the weight of the turning and produces a smaller net force on the spindle than in the previous case. Third, and more importantly, if the lathe actually lifts off the floor on each revolution, it will hammer on the floor and can produce stress far greater than in a bolted-down lathe. Dennis

Re: To bolt down or not??????

#19

Re: To bolt down or not??????

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>Dennis,I agree with you completely. I bolted my 3520a down and it has been such an improvement! I worked for 32 years in a large manufacturing plant and we bolted down most of our motors up to and including motors over 200 hp.