Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

CORING SYSTEM

Posts

CORING SYSTEM

#1

CORING SYSTEM

butter

>Which system is the best for coring? The Mcnaughton system or the oneway system.

Re: CORING SYSTEM

#2

Re: CORING SYSTEM

Rick Allen

>It depends what you are looking for.

You can fish for trout with a fly and a flyrod or a spinner on a spinning rod or with bait. Each of those methods and tools work great but each brings a different experince to the fisherman.

The same could be said of woodturning coreing systems. The Oneway might be the safer and eaiser system to use but provide the least enrichment of your woodturning soul. The McNaughton might make you feel more in control and better able to express yourself in coreing.

Re: CORING SYSTEM

#3

Re: CORING SYSTEM

Donna Banfield

>I've used both the McNaughton and the Oneway systems. I settled on the Oneway system, and sold my McNaughton for a couple of reasons.

First, as Rick pointed out, the Oneway system is much easier to use. I have no fear that I've incorrectly calculated the right depth or point of entry, to the point that I'll ruin the core and my bowl. That happened when I used the McNaughton; you can calculate the depth in comparison to where the knife enters the blank, but it requires a mathematical calculation, and I've always been 'mathemagically' impaired ;^) I get a consistent bowl and core each time I use it with no difficulty.

Second, because the cutter/knife in the Oneway system has a finger support guide, I don't have the fear of bending the crap out of my knife (as Steve Worcester so eloquently put it on another forum) if I get a sudden catch.

Last, an added bonus, when it comes time to replace the cutter, all I need to buy is the tip, not the entire knife.

As for the freedom of design, Rick is right; you have very little control over the shape of your bowl and cores. However, I'm willing to exchange this for the safety. I can experience the freedom of design in a number of other ways in woodturning, so it's a fair trade in my experience.

That said, the down side is, as with nearly all Oneway products, they are without a doubt, pretty pricey.

Re: CORING SYSTEM

#4

Re: CORING SYSTEM

robo hippy

>I actually have all 3 systems for removing curved blanks and find that I use the McNaughton and the Oneway the most. The Woodcut works better with the tailstock, and I never have that on my lathe unless I am turning spindles (PM3520). The Oneway is very predictable, and almost idiot proof (invent something idiot proof, and someone will invent a better idiot). I like the curves on the Oneway better, because they are tighter than the McNaughton, and match my standard bowls. I think McNaughton is working on that. The McNaughton can take any type of core from a cone, to a plate, in part because it mounts on the banjo, and you can come in from any angle. For the last couple of cores (smallest ones) Their micro set of blades win hands down. The biggest problems are just letting the tool work, rather than trying to force it, and aiming. I always know where to aim, but don't always hit where I am aiming (this is a problem I always had when shooting pool). It is faster than the Oneway because you don't have to stop the lathe to adjust the support finger. The Oneway is a bit harder to sharpen because of the point on the cutter. By the time I wear out a McNaughton blade (about $40) and a Oneway tip($30) I imagion that the costs will be similar. I have thought about adding a laser pointer on the McNaughton, but never seem to get around to it. Mostly watch the cut as it goes in, and you can tell after a while. the blade wants to track to the outside of the cut as you go in (actually, all 3 systems do this to some degree)and you can counter this somewhat by pulling the handle towards you (applying pressure to the inside of the cut)as you go in. This seems to help the blade self feed, so almost no pushing is required. I had a lot of problems using the McNaughton until I saw someone else use it.

robo hippy