Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

McNaughton system

Posts

McNaughton system

#1

McNaughton system

Vicmarc.fan

>When I said the McNaughton wasn't for sissies I guess I used the wrong word. I have some time in getting the wood mounted, turned to shape outside and getting everything set up to core. What ever you call it, I call it fear of failure, I have an urge to just make a bowl and not ruin this wood by not starting at the right angle with a blade I am not sure is the right one and going too deep or not deep enough so the bottom is too thick or thin. If I didn't try again I would be a sissy. This is what I meant. Nothing to do with size, strength or gender and if I offended anyone I am sorry.

Ron

Re: McNaughton system

#2

Re: McNaughton system

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Well I can't speak for anyone else, but I did not take offense at anything you wrote. This tool is a tough one to get used to, and can be scary when it is not used right. I beat myself up something fierce before I figured it out. When I bought mine, people were selling them left and right because they could not get the hang of it. There are some of us who have gotten the hang of it, and we go about spreading the good news. I would encourage you not to give up on it, but to keep at it, as it is a valuable tool to own and use.

Bill

Re: McNaughton system

#3

Re: McNaughton system

Allen Neighbors

>I surely hope I get to see a demo of the McNaughton system in use just once... maybe at TD's???

I sure do hate to waste all that wood when I'm making a large bowl.

But then, with my lathe, bowls can't be very large... :o)

Allen

Re: McNaughton system

#4

Re: McNaughton system

GeeSeaWhy

>Aim for a core that is smaller than you think you can get away with. If you need to cut some off the inside of the outer bowl, that's OK. The alternative was cutting out the entire inside. Better that than losing the biggest bowl by making it too thin.

Mt problem with the McNaughton is going too deep before I reach the center. It always seems that the blade is being deflected deeper into the bowl than I want it to go, although the real problem is probably that I'm not setting it up quite right.

Graeme

Re: McNaughton system

#5

you got it Al

TDaniel

>Greg Jensen will be showing us how to use the coring tool at the Gathering. There will be a number of "How to" classes on various tools. While these are going on there will be other classes in various locations. I'll try to post a schedule shortly. And for those who just want to hang out around a lathe with other turners and see what you can come up with that will done also.

TD

Re: McNaughton system

#6

Re: McNaughton system

Barry Irby

>I am experimenting with an "aiming system". It a rectangular piece of clear plastic about 7 X 14". I clamp it in my chuck, between the jaws. I mark the size of my bowl on it with blue tape and magic markers. Actually, just the depth and diameter. I have a line on it that represents the center line of the shaft and another that is about a half inch out from the face of the jaws, where I want the bottom to end up. Then I set the tool post so that the two smaller posts on it cause the curved cutter to run from the larger diameter of the core to the line that represents the bottom of the bowl. This way, the cutter can cut a smaller core, but not a deeper one, ruining the large bowl, unless I allow the cutter to bend or spring. I could post a picture if anyone is interested, I had one, but it went into the computer abyss. If find it is not perfect, but takes only seconds to do and gives me somewhat more confidence. I hate the idea of ruining the larger bowl.

Re: McNaughton system

#7

Re: McNaughton system

Bill Hale

>Ron

This tool has a very tough learning curve. Get hands on help, watch someone using it, but don't try to learn by yourself.

Some of the things you do with this tool don't seem correct until you do it after watching others. If you can go to the meeting these guys are talking about and you will learn a bunch.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: McNaughton system

#8

Re: Aiming device for McNaughton system

Barry Irby

>This is just a piece of plastic that is about a tenth of an inch thick. I just happened to have it.

What I do is mount the bowl blank either between the centers or on the screw on the chuck and clean up and shape the outside and cut a chuck foot on it. I like the 100mm shallow jaws because the woodworm screw works well in them and they hold a dovetail tennon better than the deeper powergrip jaws.

Once I have the blank shaped, I remove it from the screw and remove the screw from the chuck. I set the piece of plastic between the chuck jaws and sight through the other crack between the jaws to get the center line in place. The blue tape marks either the diameter of the big bowl or the diameter of the inner lip of the big bowl. I put a tick mark on it to mark the depth of the blank. With the tool post in place, I choose a curved knife and run it through the post and swivel the post clockwise until the two small posts guide the knife to a point near the center of the bottom of the bowl and "shallow" of the line on the plastic. That line is about a half inch "out" from the face of the chuck jaws. At this point you can slide the knife in and out and watch its path. The knife cannot move closer to the bottom of the bowl, You can make the core smaller and the big bowl thicker, but if you don't move anything, the knife should not be able to make the big bowl thinner.

At that point, I remove the piece of plastic and install the blank in the jaws. Because I have used both the diameter and the depth of the blank in the setup, the post is not into the way and the blank slips right into the chuck. You do need to allow room for the knife in the post as far as left to right goes.

My goal doing this is to save the center if I can, but to preserve the big bowl. The core is a bonus. Without the coring system, I was going to grind it to shavings, so if I get useful pieces, its a boon.

I start coring and cut in about an inch. I stop and cinch everything down good and tight, again. I find that fairly high speed helps. 700 to 800rpm. Clearing the chips helps. Marking the top of the blade to indicate full depth helps. I use the butt end of the handle as a hammer to break the piece loose. I hit "into" the chuck and if it does not release I cut a little deeper. I also made a curved chisel out of a piece of flat steel that I bent to match the shape of the knife. I don't like cutting them completely free on the lathe. I am afraid they will fly around, but actually they don't seem to be as fearsome as I thought they might be.


img

Re: McNaughton system

#9

Re: you got it Al

Allen Neighbors

>Thanks, TD. I received a good report from my Dr today. I can do anything I feel like doing, and can go back to fighting range fires next week. I'm dancing a jig!!! Can't wait for April 25!!

Allen