Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

McNaughton system questions

Posts

McNaughton system questions

#1

McNaughton system questions

Ed Moore

>I am considering the standard McNaughton system for my Stubby 500. The Stubby has a 1" tool post and the clearance between the top of the banjo and the centerline is 2 1/2".

I. Does one specify the tool post diameter when ordering a system?

II. Is the 2 1/2" clearance sufficient for the McNaughton Post?

III. About how shallow a bowl could one core with a 10" diameter?

Thanks,

Ed

Re: McNaughton system questions

#2

Re: McNaughton system questions

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>By telling them the modle of your lathe, they should send you the correct post. With the McNaughton, you can make cores as thin as you want, I make a lot of platters with mine, so you could make several 10" platters or shallow bowls or what ever you want. That's the beauty of the McNaughton.

Re: McNaughton system questions

#3

Re: McNaughton system questions

Ed Moore

>Gary,

Do you have the standard or large set?

Ed

Re: McNaughton system questions

#4

Re: McNaughton system questions

George Van in WI

>Ed, I have the set, I use the standard set the most. I use the larger set next and the mini when I want to save burl and highly figured cores from small diameter blanks. I do not bother with cores from small cores from average wood.

Re: McNaughton system questions

#5

Re: McNaughton system questions

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>I have both the standard and large and use them regularly.

Re: McNaughton system questions

#6

Thank you

Ed Moore

>I appreciate your responses. It sounds like a Standard and Mini might work for me.

Ed

Re: McNaughton system questions

#7

Re: McNaughton system questions

Ed Moore

>George,

I was wondering about the Mini System. It is mentioned on Craft Supplis, but it is not mentioned on the Kelton/McNaughton site. Does Craft Supplies have the Mini set made just for them? I had to waste the interior of a bowl burl the other day and that is what motivated me to get serious about optimizing my burl and quality wood use.

Apparently you endorse the Mini system.

Ed

Re: McNaughton system questions

#8

McNaughton - swing problem

Ed Moore

>The Stubby 500 is a 10" swing lathe. From the top of the banjo to the centerline of the lathe is 2 1/2". It looks like the tip of the tool will end up higher than is recommended even with the tool support assembly all the way down against the banjo. Would even the mini system be too high?

Thanks,

Ed

Re: McNaughton system questions

#9

Re: McNaughton system questions

George Van in WI

>Ed, I bought mine from Lee Valley, they are a standard production size for Kelton.The advantage within their size range is that the kerf is smaller. This also means you have to watch chip ejection carefully.

Re: McNaughton system questions

#10

Re: McNaughton - swing problem

robo hippy

>Ed,

I was talking to Kel McNaughton about this very thing. I am doing a demo with this system in April, and the club lathe has a 12 inch swing. The standard McNaughton system sits too high to use unless I remove the bottom part of the tool rest (2 3/8 inch to the top of the rest). Please note this can be done, but is a "professional driver on colsed course, DO NOT ATTEMPT" thing. He said that a smaller rest just for the 12 inch lathes was a thing that had been on the back burner for a while, and they had plans drawn up, but hadn't made any. He was wondering how much market there would be for one. As far as I am concerned, the micro set is the best out there for smaller lathes, and the smaller cores. It has a smaller cutterhead, and needs less effort.

As far as coring, depth is more important than width. You can remove a very flat core from a 2 inch thick blank, but I usually won't core unless I have 3 inches, or if the wood is very special.

You could e-mail McNaughton and ask them about the mini tool rest, and your interest.

robo hippy