Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Mc Naughton System

Posts

Mc Naughton System

#1

Mc Naughton System

Vicmarc.fan

>I cored out four blanks for 16 bowls this morning. I got it to work most of the time but I still say this is not for sissies.

Ron

Re: Mc Naughton System

#2

Re: Mc Naughton System

Rick Davenport

>When you say 'not for sissies,' do you mean it takes excessive nerve, excessive strength, excessive skills, or all of the above?

It's been said on this forum (not by me) that Bill Grumbine can core bowls with the McNaughton system using just two fingers.

Rick

Re: Mc Naughton System

#3

Re: Mc Naughton System

georgetroy

>Way to go Ron. Wood for the future and more. You did not say what kind of wood it was. GT

Re: Mc Naughton System

#4

Dick Hines

Re: Mc Naughton System

Dick Hines

>But have you seen the size of Bill?

Re: Mc Naughton System

#5

Re: Mc Naughton System

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>In this picture, four fingers and two thumbs, but I can do it with two. It is all in the setup. This bowl is spinning at approximately 750 rpm.


There might be video of this soon!

Bill

Re: Mc Naughton System

#6

Re: Mc Naughton System

George Van in WI

>Congratulations Ron, you are on your way! This will be easier each time.

Re: Mc Naughton System

#7

Re: Photoshop Trick?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>No, it's not a photoshop trick! I've seen Bill show a "Sissy" how to do it. She weighed about a hundred pounds, had never even seen one of these before, and even she made it look easy with a walnut blank about the size of the one in Bill's photo. Bill is a great teacher, and properly set up and properly used, the McNaughton system works very well.

Maybe V. Fan's definition of "not a sissy" includes "we don't need no stinking instructions!" :^) Tongue-in-cheek. Maybe there's a subtle point about the tool rest adjustment that you didn't get quite right.

Re: Mc Naughton System

#8

Re: Mc Naughton System

robo hippy

>That description kind of reminds me, as a bowl turner, of learning to use the skew chisel. Trials, tribulations, and eventually success.

robo hippy

Re: Mc Naughton System

#9

Re: Photoshop Trick?

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Probably the biggest problem people have with this tool after it is set up properly is keeping it there. By that I mean that the tip of the tool needs to be at center on the bowl, with the upper edge of the knife firmly up against the gate. A lot of people can read that, watch me do it in my shop or theirs, and then miss a very small point that still makes things rough when they get to doing it on their own.

The natural human tendency is to yield to the force of gravity. I see this happen with just about every turning tool there is, and with this tool especially. The operator needs to hold the tool UP against that gate. This is counterintuitive as well, since we have the impression that we need to hold the tool DOWN to keep it from bucking. Once we get comfortable with holding the tool properly, the biggest obstacles to overcome are the angle of entry and rate of feed. The reason I am able to hold the tool in the picture so lightly is that I am holding it, or rather pushing it up against the gate so that it has steady pressure against the gate and with the tip against the wood. There is no bucking that can occur with this position.


This is the picture to which William is referring. Joy B and her husband Dan were attendees (along with a bunch of other people) at one of our Five Barns picnics, and I invited her up to core a bowl for the group watching my demo. She was a little nervous, but with some moral support and my hand on the tool, she cored this bowl with no trouble whatsoever, and the thing is just about shoulder height for her! On the negative side, if the handle droops, even I, with all of my weight and muscle mass, cannot hold it down.

Bill