ca for segmented turnings
John
>Is it advisable to use ca glue for segmented work? I find myself a bit impatient to wait over night every time I glue up.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
ca for segmented turnings
John
>Is it advisable to use ca glue for segmented work? I find myself a bit impatient to wait over night every time I glue up.
Re: ca for segmented turnings
Ian
>john, my first reaction would be to say no if you are using it to glue up the rings and layers.
long term the joints willbe weaker due to wood movements. I do use ca for temp holding pieces in place and some of the complicated glue layups in the design rings.
IAN
Re: ca for segmented turnings
Nick Tuzzolino
>Ditto to what Ian said. Also, ca is very brittle and will give you nothing but headaches and frustration when you see the pieces flying apart.
Re: ca for segmented turnings
Keith Tompkins
>John, it seems that several segmented turnings done by Ray Allen using CA glue are coming undone as the glue deteriorates.....a rumor I heard. Major restoration will be required.
Re: ca for segmented turnings
Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL
>I would advise against. As the others have said, it is too brittle.
If your problem is your inpatience, I suggest a couple of things.
a) The obvious - maybe segmenting is not for you ;>)
b) Try HOT hide glue - you can't us it to do full ring glue-ups all at one time (cools/drys too quick), but it is very strong.
c) I find that except for with very dense exotics, I can turn a ring about 1 hour after gluing in normal weather. I use Original Titebond. I like it because it comes out of my clothes and off my band/hose clamps with plain water. It also displays less "glue creap" than TB II, and drys a little quicker.
d) Set a fan to plow on your glued up rings, and you can speed up the process a little.
Just my thoughts.
Mark
Re: ca for segmented turnings
john lucas
>John I'm a yellow glue user. I look at segmented work as an ongoing process so I glue up sections or whole rings depending on the complexity and while they are drying I go on to another project. It may take me a week to get all the parts glued together. I've also found that I have to wait extra long for the moisture in the wood from the glue to dry out or I get raised glue bumps after it's turned.
Patience is the key. BAck when I did a lot of these I would have several projects going at once. That way while one was drying I could work on another one. I still do that today with my inside-out turning. I aways wait overnight to let the glue set really good. I will often glue up 3 or 4 of these in one day and while I'm working on these glue ups I'll probably have another project on the lathe that I'm turning, so I can just take a break from one and go to the other.
Re: ca for segmented turnings
John
>I would like to thank everyone who responded. I went ahead yesterday and glued up one ring with ca and sanded it flat with the drum sander. I'm thinking of tossing it now and going back to work with some hot hide glue.
Thanks again
John
Re: ca for segmented turnings
John
>a) The obvious - maybe segmenting is not for you ;>)
Possibly....
b) Try HOT hide glue - you can't us it to do full ring glue-ups all at one time (cools/drys too quick), but it is very strong.
I will have to investigate this as a possibility.
c) I find that except for with very dense exotics, I can turn a ring about 1 hour after gluing in normal weather. I use Original Titebond. I like it because it comes out of my clothes and off my band/hose clamps with plain water. It also displays less "glue creap" than TB II, and drys a little quicker.
Is that about an hour using Original Titebond?
I've been trying to use TB III, very messy and takes forever to dry.
d) Set a fan to plow on your glued up rings, and you can speed up the process a little.
This I can do.
Thank you very much.
John
Re: ca for segmented turnings
RussFairfield
>CA glue has only one attribute that endears it to woodturners - it is fast. Other than that, there is nothing that it can offer that other glues can't do better.
Others have suggested a working shedule that makes use of the slower setting time of the yellow glues. I always make a segmented bowl in a series of continuous steps, always using the time required to do the current step to allow the glue to set in the previous step. Most ring assemblies can be unclamped and handled carefully in 15-minutes, and machined and clamped in 2-hours.
The following is the schedlye I follow for a bowl assembly.
1. Cut, plane, and do whatever is necessary to make the parts for the "feature ring".
2. Rip and plane the stock for all of the various layers in the bowl.
3. Cut fit, glue and clamp the bottom of the bowl. I use a segmented assembly for this.
4. Cut, fit, glue and clamp the "feature ring". Check the OD of the feature ring and make any adjustment in the OD of the rest of the bowl.
5. Cut, fit, glue and clamp the segments for the 1st solid color bowl ring. Set it aside to dry with the clamps in place.
6. Cut and fit the segments for the 2nd ring. Then remove the clamps from the 1st ring. Use those same clamps to glue and clamp the 2nd ring.
The glue in the 1st ring will be sufficiently set for handling but not machining and clamping. Set it aside.
7. Repeat Steps 5and 6 as many times as necessary to cut and assemble all of the rings.
8. The "Feature Ring" is now sufficiently cured for machining and clamping. Turn, sand, or do whatever is necessary to get it ready for gluing.
9. Mount the top ring in the bowl into whatever is being used for gluing and clamping. I have 3 choices. on the lathe with tailstock pressure for clamping. a "cider press" single screw clamping fixture, or individual clamps on a base while sitting on the work banch.
10. Sand to thickness, turn on the lathe, or do whatever else is necessary to get the 2nd ring ready for gluing.
11. Glue the 2nd ring into the stacked assembly.
12. Repeat Steps 10 and 11 as many times as becessary to complete the stacked assembly of rings.
13. Prepare the bottom for gluing.
14. Glue the bottom to the stack of rings. Clamp and leave it until the next morning.
DONE.
I will now have been continuously working for something like 7 to 8 hours, and I challenge anybody to find a single step that can be made faster or better by using a CA glue.
Now it has to be set aside for a couple days until all of the glue is fully cured. Can't wait that long?? Glue up another bowl the next day, and the next. Then turn and finish the first one.
Re: ca for segmented turnings
Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL
>Exactly, John. When people ask how I have the patience to do segmenting, I tell them that I enjoy it because I usually make bowls in batches. As you say, you glue one ring up, and while it is drying, you flatten a ring and glue it to a bowl, and while they are both drying, you can be cutting another ring, or turning the next bowl in the process. Always something going on.
Glue Creap: i.e. the bumps. When I first started doing segmented turning, I did one bowl at a time, and was impatient to move the process along. As a result, I would have a bowl done in a week, and 3 weeks after that, I could feel the glue seams. I found that by working slower, i.e. working on multiple bowls and finishing 6 bowls in six weeks (I wish), I would end up without the glue creap because every thing had the chance to dry before I got to the final sanding and finishing stage.
Mark
Re: ca for segmented turnings
Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL
>Well said, Russ.
Mark
Re: ca for segmented turnings
john lucas
>Russ I'm going to print that off. As my memory gets worse I may need a set of instructions to follow. Good job.
Re: ca for segmented turnings
Ed Heuslein
>Russ, as expected, your reply is well detailed. Right in line with your disertation on various glues posted a while back. However, I fail to find your glue recomendation. Your procedure is great. What glue do you prefer for segmentation? I value your sage advise. Thanks.