WE MOVED...
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

How'd the Chat go last night?

Posts

How'd the Chat go last night?

#1

How'd the Chat go last night?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>I wanted to be there but sleep came first. So did we come up with a scale to grade by?

Jen

Re: How'd the Chat go last night?

#2

Re: How'd the Chat go last night?

Ed Karch

>Mark came up with the idea that allowed us to dodge the bullet of scales and judging. Basically let the market decide by having a silent auction with the top scoring pieces moving to the live auction with the silent auction high bid as the starting bid in the live auction.

Re: How'd the Chat go last night?

#3

Nothing in concrete yet

TDaniel

>Jen, some want a critiques session, some want a juried auction, and some just want to have fun and keep everything non-competitve. We are still kicking things around. Maybe after a little time to think about it and more input we can make a decision. We have to keep in mind that the purpose of the sale is to help each attendee to cover some or all of thier travel costs. I think we all agree that a table or two of items for sale that are pre-priced and unjudged will be one of the means to sell. Some think this would be non-competitive but it really will not be. The good stuff will sell and the bad stuff probably will not. We do not want a flea market atmosphere with this sale because that will hurt us all now and next year if we decide to do this again. Next tier would be a silent auction. This would allow each of us to buy from each other and would also allow outsiders to buy. The final tier must be judged in some way. Do we pick the top 30 items from the silent auction? If we do this then the biggest items will win, not the best. EXample: a small well made hollow form that would sell for $275 might get beat out be a much larger vessel of less quality that might sell for $300. I do not feel that this would serve us well. I maintain that we need to jury the pieces in some way. Should we elect a panel of jurors? Should we allow every attendee to vote on each piece? We cannot allow every piece brought in to be auctioned as that would take several hours possibly. Any way that we attempt to narrow things down to 30 pieces for the auction will be considered judging. There is no getting around this. So how do we make the judging fair? I like Keith's suggestion posted earlier. Our potential buyers will also have a say in the final decision because they are the ones who will ultimately make this successful or a flop.

Comments?

TD