And the chat subject tonight is????
Rick Davenport
>
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
And the chat subject tonight is????
Rick Davenport
>
judging other's work for the Gathering
TDaniel
>I should have announced this sooner but heve been busy getting ready for the BIG EVENT.
I mentioned earlier that we would have a juried art auction on the last day of our gathering. Guess who will be the jurors? We have to come up with a set of standards that will be fair to all. So many points for form, so many points for proper wall thickness, so many for a perfect sanding job, so many for the beauty of the wood, so much for the level of difficulty, etc. What we need to dicuss tonight is how many points should we give to each of these? And should a time consuming oil finish be potentially be given more points than a flawless lacquer finish that might have taken less time or should they be equal? The artistic value of each piece will be done by an art professor so we will be judging only the craftsmanship portion. What we come up with could be used by clubs as well so this isn't just for the gathering. Join us tonight around 9 pm eastern for the howdies and we'll start the topic at 9:30.
Re: judging other's work for the Gathering
Wally Dickerman in Arizona
>Seems like the Wed. night chats for the next few weeks are going to be reserved for those that are going to attend the gathering. See you later.
Wally
I'll chat with you anytime Wally
John Lucas
>
Universal need
TDaniel
>Wally, all clubs should be able to judge work in a fair way. We have an immediate need for judging work at our gathering but I am sure every club will have the same need at some point. What would be wrong with taking the time to sort things out and come up with a way to give a piece a certain number of points? With a universal points system we could go to a gallery with a piece and say "this piece scored a 98 by the _____ scoring system." Don't you think it is worth a try?
TD
Re: Universal need
John Lucas
>Actually I don't think you can arrive at a scoring system. There are too many variables in the art world. How would you score a todd hoyer piece. The walls would be too thick and some aren't even sanded at all. Some have chainsaw marks and others have been left in the sun or buried in the ground to age. There's no way these would fit the scoring system your talking about and yet they are fabulous pieces.
Re: Universal need
TDaniel
>John, you may be right. I think there will be some pieces that will defy any standard system and I have some of those pieces myself but what about things like "no sanding marks" and "no tool marks' and good form or appropriate thickness? What can we nail down and what must be left to the art judge? These are the things we need to discuss. The whole thing may be futile but we don't know until we discuss it.
Re: judging other's work for the Gathering
Keith Tompkins
>Terry, I won't be able to attend the gathering, I probably won't be able to make the chat tonight either (deadline next week).
HOwever, there are a few things to consider....the jurying process could create a few problems. NOT having a piece juried into the auction is bound to create some hard feelings, especially if that turner was counting on auction proceeds to cover some of their travel expenses. Driving several hours to discover your work just wasn't good enough would be a tough pill to swallow...never mind the drive home. It would be good if time permitted to include all entries, and let the buyers decide with their wallets.
In my humble opinion, if you must use the jury process, then good design must count more than everything else combined. Here's my take:
Form: 5 Points: The turner absolutely nailed the form. Less from there. To me nothing else comes close to this category in importance. I have seen far too many perfectly turned and finished pieces that give no consideration to good form at all.
Technical skill level: 2 points....expert, intermediate, or novice
Finish: 2 Points This would consider things like sanding scratches, polishing, etc.
Originality 1 Point. Everything else being equal, the piece showing some original thought wins. That's what the big galleries look for. Not everybody strives to make orininal pieces, so I only give that area one point.
A typical piece with a good finish, good technique would get a 5 or 6 score. A score of 8 or 9 would be a truly nice art piece, no flaws, wonderful form. A 10: shows something unique; the turner's voice can be heard loud and clear and the execution is superb.
It would be nice if the art professor chose the pieces for the auction.
This is what we are after
TDaniel
>How many points should the art professor be allowed to give? This is what we are after. Should we allow him to give 50% of the potential points? Should we turners be able to evaluate things like sanding, finish, and form? Originality is great but what about flawless execution of skills? This is what we need to discuss tonight.
TD
Re: This is what we are after
john lucas
>TD I'll be there if I can get my work done. That means I need to get off here and get to work. See ya later I hope.
Re: This is what we are after
Bill Crommett
>TD: I like the idea of a scoring system. Lets call it "the Boone and Crockett" system.
buyers like the idea
TDaniel
>Every buyer I have spoken to likes the idea of having a piece judged by a panel including other turners. I think a system can be worked out that will be more fair to turners and would also insure that the buyers don't get shorted. This is worth pursuing.