Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

*** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

Posts

*** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

#1

Ellis Walentine

*** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

Ellis Walentine

>Good morning, folks. I wanted to check in and try to get an idea of how many of you plan to enter our "Two Board Feet" turning contest. I know there were some initial concerns about how to calculate the amount of wood in the project. This needn't be a stumbling block to entering the contest, as close is good enough.

How you calculate it -- whether by measurements or fancy arithmetic or even weighing it -- isn't the point. The intent of the contest is to see how creative you can get with a small amount of wood, as long as the lathe is part of the process.

I have extended the deadline to the end of March to give you all more time to complete your entries. If we don't get at least 25 entries, we'll extend the deadline again if necessary.

Please let me know if there is anything else you think we should consider to boost participation in this contest. And give me some ideas for future contests while you're at it. We have some great sponsors who are committed to turning excellence.

Cheers and thanks,

Ellis Walentine, Host


img

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

#2

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

John Lucas

>Ellis I've never been any good at figuring board feet. I pick up the wood. Guestimate the board feet. Multiply that by the price per board foot and then take it to the counter. It's always about twice as expensive as I figured. Does it go up in cost as I walk to the counter?

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

#3

Exactly!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>John,

The same thing happens to me too! I'm sure it has nothing to do with the fact that I'm mathematically challenged?

Even when I overestimate price....I always have sticker shock when it comes time to pay.

Jen :)

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

#4

Easter?

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Ellis,

I need more warm shop time, I'd like to get in on this, but it's not working out with my weather issues in my shop.

So in keeping with what looks like one of Betty Scarpino's egg themes can we ask for an Easter deadline..??

Thanks,

Take care,

Jim

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

#5

Ric Taylor

Easter

Ric Taylor

>Do I need a lathe that wobbles a lot to turn a piece like that? :)

Ric

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

#6

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

James McClure

>I am planning on entering and was very happy to see that you extended it to the end of the month.

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

#7

board feet

JKJ in East TN

>>Does it go up in cost as I walk to the counter?

Actually, it may go up in cost as soon as you REACH the counter. I found this out at the local Woodcraft. I figured board feet carefully but was surprised to see the cost higher than my calculation.

On investigation, I found they used a program with some limitations. (read: stupid program) One limitation is it could not accept all dimensions but rounded up in many cases. When I asserted myself (read: expressed my justifiable disbelief), they graciously entered suitable dimensions to bring the cost into line with reality. (I don't know if they still use this program)

The best line of defense here is a good offense - know the board ft and cost before you get to the counter! To calculate:

length in feet

times thickness in inches

times width in inches divided by 12.

For short pieces or odd lengths it is easier to measure everything in inches, multiply, and divide by 144, i.e.,

thickness * width * length / 144.

A calculator, tape measure, and notebook in the pocket are handy, of course. Use nominal dimensions where appropriate. Also, I generally point out and negotiate large end cracks and such.

JKJ

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

#8

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

Steve Mushinski

>I hope to have something Ellis. With the deadline extended till the end of the month and warm weather starting this week hope should change to will. - Steve

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

#9

Roughing It

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Let's remember that lumber is sold by the mill's board foot, not the "nice-smooth-planed" version in the wood store. Hense, if you glom that nice 11-1/2 x 12 x 3/4 board which is listed at $10 per board foot and hot foot it to the counter, here's what you'll find.

You, canny woodworker that you are, know that a board foot is 144 cubic inches. You also know that the board you're holding is 103.5 cubic inches so, bargain-of-bargains, that will cost you 71% of a board foot or $7.10. But when you get to the register you are offered no change from your nice new 10er. What happened, did this sleazy cretin of a clerk hike the price by 29% before you got in from the yard? Nope. You forgot that your 3/4" board was planed from a full 1" rough milled plank and you have to pay for that departed 1/4" which is actually cheaper than paying for the labor and machine cost to plane it so nicely for you. You also forgot that lumber is cut green to the full inch, usually in standard sizes 1", 2", 4", 6" etc. to the nearest 2" multiple. Therefore, to get that nice 11-1/2" board, they had to joint off the edges by 1/4" from the rough 12" wide board and, yup, samo-samo, you have to pay for what you don't got. We all pay for 2x4's, but we only get 1-5/8" x 3-5/8".

And so it goes.

|;-}

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

#10

Correction

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Not a 29% increase, actually a bit more than 40%. [duh |;-{]

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

#11

I plan to participate.

Chris K in MD

>With more time I may try to turn another peice, if I cant get it done I will submit the one I was going to submit for the first deadline.

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

#12

Both my son and I plan to enter.

Molly Winton

>

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

#13

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

bob davis

>the only answer is free wood.always calculates correctly

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

#14

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

bob davis

>i am intimidated by seeing john lucas entries.

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

#15

Re: Roughing It

JKJ in East TN

>You are correct of course, board foot measurements are based on rough cut or what I called nominal sizes. And even when buying dry rough cut lumber, don't forget shrinkage which can be significant. Even a rough 1x12 may not measure 12".

Just to be clear, the Woodcraft calculation I mentioned did not "err" based on rough vs finished size, but something worse. It's been a while and I forget the details but I think it may have had to do with the length of the boards, like rounding up to an even foot or something. They did acknowledge the shortcoming. Just something to be aware of.

JKJ

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

#16

Re: Selling It

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>THAT'S A NO-NO!

Good catch |;-}

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

#17

Re: Roughing It

Bill Crommett

>Mark: I still have a few OLD 2 X 4s that were miled out in the 40s, but around here we only get 2 X 4s that are 1 1/2 X 3 1/2 in.

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

#18

You're Lucky

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Round here, they're 1-5/8 x 3-5/8 and green wet. Of course, when they dry out, they're 1-7/16 x 3-3/8! [and twisted by 20* or bowed 4" out of straight, usually both]

|;-}

M

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

#19

I plan on it, I finally had a good idea.

Ed Snow

>

Re: *** Turning Contest Deadline Extended ***

#20

Re: *** I intend to enter

Ronny Eelen (Belgium)

>