Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Benjamin's Best Gouges?

Posts

Benjamin's Best Gouges?

#1

Benjamin's Best Gouges?

Jim Swank

>I'm about to need a large bowl gouge for rough turning bowls - the one I've got now is about used up. I'm seeing these on eBay at bargain prices. Anybody have experience or comments on the quality and metal (listed as M2)?

Re: Benjamin's Best Gouges?

#2

Re: Benjamin's Best Gouges?

Bob Fawcett

>These are also available from Penn State. I bought a scraper to see what they are like. The scraper is only 3/16 thick versus my Sorby which is 1/4. Don't know about the gouges.

I found a large Crown bowl gouge at Woodcraft on closeout at about $20 off the normal price.

Don't have enough experience yet to speak to the quality of the steel, but the finish is notch below Sorby or Crown.

They are made in China.

Re: Benjamin's Best Gouges?

#3

Re: Benjamin's Best Gouges?

George Van in WI

>I bought some Jim, use them for special cut grinds. I do find that they turn blue very easily when grinding and do not seem to hold an edge for quite as long as my other gouges. Stewart Batty explained steels very well at the Dessert Roundup and said all M2 or other HS steel for that matter are not necessarily the same as tungsten and other properties vary. For a special purpose and under $20 they serve my purpose. I would not want one for my main bowl gouge.

Re: Benjamin's Best Gouges?

#4

Re: Benjamin's Best Gouges?

Bill Neddow

>i bought a 5/8 inch bowl gouge a year ago and use it every day, along with an equivalent Sorby, and Henry Taylor. They hold their edges equally well, so the steel is good M2 (in my gouge, anyway). I turn a lot (500 rouigh and 250 finished bowls a year) and the bowl sizes are all over 12 inches. Many are over 24 inches. So I have given the tool a real workout. I would buy another without hesitation.

However, there are some thing to look for. The 5/8 inch gouge is shaped like a proper bowl gouge. The 1/2 inch bowl gouge is not. It is more of a spindle detail gouge with very little flute in it. I saw this before I bought it, so I sharpened it and use it as a detail gouge. Again, another good tool at a very low price. But check the shapes before you buy, if you can.

Also, it will need sharpening before you buy it. I think it is being made in a factory that knows nothing about wood turning tools and some of the ground shapes are almost comical. Certainly unusable. But a few minutes at the grinder will fix that.

Certainly a good buy at the price.

Re: Benjamin's Best Gouges?

#5

Re: Benjamin's Best Gouges?

George Van in WI

>Bill, it is interesting to read your experience with the same brand knowing you use yours more than I would. Do you have a problem with bluing when you grind yours? I do not with any of my other tools but I find that it is next to impossible to use a light enough touch to avoid it on this one. Perhaps the steel in this is out of specs to their full line. I too have noticed the more �detail profile� on some of the gouges and was told they have re-styled their flute profile on the bowl gouges.

Re: Benjamin's Best Gouges?

#6

Re: Benjamin's Best Gouges?

Bill Neddow

>George, I have not run into a problem with blueing. It sharpens just like my Sorby. I wondered about that when I read your comment -- but if it does not seem to affect the cutting characteristics, I would not worry. High Speed Steel can blue a bit without affecting the hardness.

Re: Benjamin's Best Gouges?

#7

Re: Benjamin's Best Gouges?

George Van in WI

>Well Bill, in that case Sorby has the Gold Series, maybe I got the Benjamin Blue series :-)