Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Style or a rut?

Posts

Style or a rut?

#1

Style or a rut?

Carole Valentine

>I was told by someone the other day that I was developing a "style" and that she was beginning to be able to spot my work from a thumbnail. Today when I was getting ready to photograph these two little minis, I was struck by their similarity of form to each other and to a lot of the others in my cabinet. That got me thinking (I know - that's dangerous!) Do we develop a style or do we just settle into a comfort zone (rut?) with the things we turn? To me, a style is something unique, therefore I think I am probably in a rut and need to start exploring different forms! Do any of you ever think about this?


img

Re: Style or a rut?

#2

JL

Re: Style or a rut?

JL

>A good form is a good form. I became a turner to do legs and such for furniture. In the traditional styles, there are bamboo, baluster, arrowed baluster, etc. etc. Do I ever explore out of these styles? Sure. I might turn a single leg to explore a concept. I haven't really had time to explore many options - but I do think about other options and "styles". Perhaps you are developing a "comfort zone" for your mini hollowforms. Pushing the boundaries of the zone is a good thing. But again - a good form is a good form. Just don't be afraid to progress beyond that.

Off of a soapbox. My $0.02.

Re: Style or a rut?

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: Style or a rut?

Keith Tompkins

>HI CArole, I think you are developing a good eye for form....the forms you show here are very pleasing; that's probably the reason you duplicate them...not because you are in a rut.

I would suggest experimenting with other forms as well to expand your "vocabulary" a bit, utilizing the same sense of balance and proportion you displayed in these pieces.

Look at all the "signature" pieces by various artists ...they all have one thing in common..the underlying form is good. You are certainly off to a great start; the "Carole" style can't be far behind.

Re: Style or a rut?

#4

Re: Style or a rut?

Mike Schwing from Md.

>You will tire of your particular "style", and then you will try something else. Whatever that is, it will help you further develop a "style". It might be a decorative method, turning something different, or carving. Who knows. I can tell you, however, that I have thought I would be a (in no particular order)

1. Bowl turner

2. Hollow form turner

3. Platter turner

4. Weird little organic creature turner/carver

5. Painter

6. Only work in maple burl.

7. Spoonman

I think that in reality, we have no idea where we will wind up, and if you are happy working in a particular style now, just wait a while, things will change whether you want them to or not. Doing the same thing over and over again hundreds, thousands of times makes for excellence in that thing. Then when we tire of it, we move onto another thing, and refine your style again. Rare is the person who is excellent right off the bat. For the record, while your work is lovely, it does not represent a personal style to me, and I cannot identify it as yours from a photo. Keep doing it. It looks great. Eventually you will be able to add some style to it that will identify it as your own.

Re: Style or a rut?

#5

Re: Style or a rut?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Carole, This is a very nice form and you're comfortable with it. However, it is easy to get in a rut. Get out your sketchbook (you do have one don't you?) There are lots of places to get new inspiration. Look at some of the albums on WoW of people who's work you admire. Make some sketches with changes that you think might work. Play around with it. That's part of the fun of woodturning. Not everything will work. (You do have lots of wood to work with don't you?) Play with new curves. Try interupting curves with sharp transitions. It can go on and on. I know you have talent and imagination. Use it.

Wally

Re: Style or a rut?

#6

Re: Style or a rut?

Carole Valentine

>Wally,

You are going to beat me with a gouge when I tell you I don't have a sketch book. I will pick one up when I go out this afternoon...I promise! One for the shop, one for the house and maybe even one for my back pocket. Thanks!

Re: Style or a rut?

#7

Re: Style or a rut?

Carole Valentine

>Thanks, Mike. You're right - I guess everyone's work evolves or they would just quit doing it out of boredom.

BTW...are the bugs history? I sort of miss them. What ever happened to the one that got broken during shipping?

Re: Style or a rut?

#8

Re: Style or a rut?

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Carole,

I think it's a great way to explore design potential with this form...so to me it's a canvas, not a rut, make it go places and let us watch you go there..

Have Fun!!

take care,

Jim

Re: Style or a rut?

#9

Re: Style or a rut?

Carole Valentine

>Hi Keith,

I just looked at your web site (again.) Yours and other's ability to "see" abstract forms in your mind and then execute them is what makes a fine craftsman an artist. Wally says "use your imagination". I am wondering what it is like to HAVE that kind of imagination? Was it always there from the time you were child? Can imagination be learned, or at least freed (assuming we all have some somewhere deep inside?) Is it one of those things that either you have it or you don't? If I have any, I don't know how to use it yet!

Re: Style or a rut?

#10

Re: Style or a rut?

georgetroy

>Carole in my opinion, the more you do of your so called Carole style the better you do. Don't rush off on a tangent just yet. How many of the similar little vases have you done yet? When you do over a hundred then you might get concerned about it. This is a strong base for you expand from there when YOU think it's time not somebody else. Keep it up girl you have come a long way. Nice looking pieces and photos. GT

Re: Style or a rut?

#11

Re: Style or a rut?

Andy_B

>Carole - Martin Pidgeon said that if you turn 125 of something you get good at it. I would qualify that statement by saying, turn 125 but make each one unique. That is, if they were set on a display together each would be instantly recognized as different from all the others. The first 30 or so will be easy, after that you really have to think and get creative.

Re: Style or a rut?

#12

Re: Style or a rut?

john lucas

>Carol Imagination comes from repetitive turning. When you can produce a piece like you have been doing, you are developing the skills to produce anything else. By making the same shape over and over you are learning to see as well as turn. As you turn more you will naturally want to change something or add to it, decorate it or just change it entirely. Then it's a matter of trying to put a part of yourself into the piece.

Re: Style or a rut?

#13

Re: Style or a rut?

RK in Milw

>Hi Carole,

Imagination comes from lots of places. When you were a kid, did you ever play with a box and imagine it was a house? Unfortunately, schools, churches and other such institutions often do their best to cleanse us of our ability to use our imagininations. They don't like it when we ask questions. Stay between the lines when you color; memorize facts; walk in a straight line; girls can't do this or that; you get the picture.

Imagination comes from taking risks and from failing. We must learn to put fear aside. I'll bet you are already on that path. You had to deal with a certain amount of fear just to get started in turning. The only real security in life is in taking risks. The faster you fail, the faster you achieve success. Sales professionals understand that "the customers fear of failure is greater than his desire to succeed".

Imagination comes from copying what others have done and then moving on. Take Cindy Drozda's finials. The curve at the base is the same shape as the bell on a trumpet. Other shapes are simple ovals and vee cuts. The artistry comes from putting the shapes in a certain order with proportions that work. I have been trying to copy her shapes and it isn't easy. I see a lot of people who avoid copying, only to fool themselves into thinking that they are being original when all they can come up with is something clumsy.

Imagination comes from slowing down and soaking in information from around and beyond your peripheral vision. My biggest challenge with students in my hollow turning class is to get them to slow down, enjoy the process,work on form and practice fine finishing cuts. Everyone is in such a hurry all of the time. It's our culture. Hurry and rush to accumulate more crap from the big box store. Buy a closet organizer to store the junk and then sell it on ebay. What's the point?

I was resurfacing some walls with joint cement one day. I noticed the texture of the joint cement that had dried on my wrist. It resembled the cracked mud of a dry lake bed. It occured to me that I could coat a model's body with the stuff and make a a really cool photo ( I'm a commercial photographer). It did make for an outstanding photo. Some people think I'm weird for coming up with stuff like that, but I don't care. I'm not the one sitting in a cubicle all day letting my brain turn to mush. I don't watch clocks. I've got most of the toys and they are tax deductible.

Once you have learned certain rules, the next step is to question them. Rules and facts are launching pads to something new. They are the beginning not the end.

You have shown a great deal of imagination in your work. Compare those two pieces to your first turnings. Most important, you had the courage to ask the question, "Am I in a rut"? Most people never get to that point.

It helps to have a philosophy to guide you. Here are mine:

From and old cabinet maker I used to know; "Can't is just another word for don't want to".

From Sister Thomasita, an elderly nun who headed the art dept. at Cardinal Stritch College;

"Those who learn to create will never destroy"

And my own philosophy of business; "No one ever hired me to make a crappy photograph".

Imagination can be learned, or rather, re-learned and I think you are well on the way. Just keep at it.

That's my take on things.

Ron Nelson

Re: Style or a rut?

#14

Re: Style or a rut?

Chip Sutherland

>I enjoy your work. I think the photographic perspective of your two HFs was very appealing. Had they been two different styles, the photo would not have the same 'hook'. As far as style or rut....are you comfortable or bored? Your answer will probably be displayed in your next piece. I can't wait to see it!

Re: Style or a rut?

#15

Re: Style or a rut?

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Carole, I love these forms. A lot! I've often thought that the bowls that I make with a wide rim and smaller "bowl" inside are pretty much a rut....or comfort zone...I think the later sounds better :)

I wish my ruts looked like yours!

Jen :)

Re: Style or a rut?

#16

I agree....

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Carole, I agree with Chip. I forgot to mention it in my post above....I really like this photo too! Maybe play around with some black and while or sepia tone on it...it's very cool!

Jen

Re: Style or a rut?

#17

What a motivating post!

Carole Valentine

>Thank you, Ron! I have copied this to post in my shop.

Re: Style or a rut?

#18

Re: Style or a rut?

Carole Valentine

>Jenn,

When I see those bowls, I immediately think "Jennifer Shirley"! You have the form down pat, but you are also experimenting with embellishments which make them your own. That's what most of these folks have been telling me...get the form then make it yours. I still gotta find the "make it yours" part! LOL

Re: Style or a rut?

#19

Very Well Said Mike

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Style or a rut?

#20

Re: Style or a rut?

john lucas

>Ron Extremely well said. That should be posted somewhere on this board such as the articles and reviews.

Re: Style or a rut?

#21

Re: Style or a rut?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>IMHO there is nothing wrong with maintaning a comfort zone. It depends upon your reason for turning. I do it because I love beautiful wood and think that one of the most pleasing ways to display it is through turning. I think a simple classic form with a lovely piece of wood is hard to beat.

That doesn't mean that experimentation is bad. It all depends upon what you want to try. Heck, I even use gesso every once in awhile. :-)

The older I get the more I appreciate simplicity.

Re: Style or a rut?

#22

Re: Style or a rut?

Mark Kauder, Phenix City, AL

>Carol,

I have not read every response, so someone may have already stated it, but.....If that is a Rut - Throw me in. This form is beautiful. Fantastic curve, great balance, etc. Now, explore all the parts of that rut - colars, pieces with Finials, various woods, etc.

One man's rut, is another man's quest for perfection.

Mark

Re: Style or a rut?

#23

Re: Style or a rut?

RK in Milw

>Blush. Thanks guys. Glad I could help.

John: Feel free to try the joint cement idea. Of course the hard part was finding a model who would let me do that to her and could stand still for two hours ;)

Ron

Re: Style or a rut?

#24

Re: Style or a rut?

john lucas

>Ron Everything we do has go through a committee before it goes to print. I gave up being creative years ago. Nothing unusual or even remotely "arty" will get through. Consequently my art is now my wood, not my camera. Fortunately I get to photograph a lot of artwork to try and get the artist's noticed. That's the only fulfilling part of my job. I did get to photograph a $70,000 9 foot tall chest on chest last week. It is an incredible piece. I will post photos sometime next week. This piece had lots of veneer, lots of carving and some turning, along with case work. Alf Sharp is the artist.

Maybe the President would let me cover him with drywall mud for a photo.

Re: Style or a rut?

#25

Keith Tompkins

Re: Style or a rut?

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Carole,Thanks for checking out my site...I must appologize that's it's not finished. Soon, I hope.

Yes, I have always had a "vivid" imagination. I always had to take things apart to see what made them tick. By eight grade, I had read all the architecture books in the school library. I was especially drawn to the work of Frank Lloyd Wright. I constantly drew pictures, usually of airplanes or majestic buildings.

You know from my website that I worked as a furniture maker and designer. That experience really allowed me to use a lot of imagination and creativity. I also designed special fixtures and tooling to produce some of these pieces, so I got to use a bit more imagination.

What's it like? Have you ever played around with auto-cad programs? It's like that, I suppose. Before I make a piece, I usually have it worked out in my head first....I can visualize a piece, rotate it to view from any angle, cut it apart, reassemble it in different ways. Cut it into slices, and shift the slices to produce various patterns. If I go to sleep while thinking of a design, it's usually figured out when I wake up....I have to write it down immediately, or it will be lost.

Can someone be taught to use their imagination? I don't know; but I believe all of us can learn design techniques. Like

Wally said, start drawing and sketching, letting your imagination run free.

It's funny...a famous turner examining my work stated...these aren't turnings, they're architecture.