Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Question about Ebony and Blackwood

Posts

Question about Ebony and Blackwood

#1

Question about Ebony and Blackwood

Carole Valentine

>When using these woods for collars (not finials), are they dense and fine grain enough that you can turn the collar end grain? In other words, can I just slice a piece of the appropriate thickness off the billet or should I rip it to thickness then cut the piece so I am turning face grain? The stuff is so darned expensive that I feel it would be less wasteful if I could orient it end grain. Just thought I would ask before diving into it.

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

#2

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

Ed Karch

>End grain nshould not be a problem. Entire woodwind instruments are turned end grain from blackwood. Ebony can be a bit brittle but again should not cause a problem end grain. Look at all the Victorian era gewgas turned from ebony. I am sure most finials are mend grain. This expertise is brought toyou by a dude that has never tried it himself.

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

#3

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

Carole Valentine

>Thanks, Ed. You just made me realize something. I always turn finials that way and base of the final (which is basically exposed end grain like a collar) does just fine. Duh!

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

#4

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

John Lucas

>Carol I wish I had a dollar for all the "DUH" moments I've had over the years. In fact sometimes it hits me before I finish asking the question.

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

#5

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

Carole Valentine

>LOL! The problem is, I find them to be getting more and more frequent, John! I am going to start waiting a week between the time the question arises in my feeble head and the time I post it. Maybe that will cut down on my "Duh!" moments. ;)

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

#6

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

Paul in Phoenix, AZ

>Hi Carole, I have better success with the thin ring collars turned side grain. For the larger collars with more mass, I don't think it matters. Like you said, get the most efficient use of that expensive wood.

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

#7

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

John Lucas

>Carole if your like me if you wait more than 10 minutes you will forget the question.

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

#8

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

John Lucas

>I think a lot has to do with how you mount the collar. If you only turn a slight rabbit in the collar then end grain will be weak. If you turn the rabbit in the vessel you are essentially mounting the collar on this and the collar can be weaker. If you turned the vessel endgrain the neck portion will be kind of weak anyway because it's end grain also. However this means that if you put an endgrain collar on you have endgrain to endgrain so the wood movement will be more closely matched. Of course to know for sure you would have to look up the amount of wood movement in both species which none of us ever does. I did for one project because I suspected that I would have problems and had to know but 99 times out of 100 I just pick a collar material and glue it up.

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

#9

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>Carol and John, You guys are just kids. Wait until you get old.

Norm

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

#10

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

John Lucas

>Norm Carole's the oldest but she's probably smarter and better looking. (Gotcha Carole)

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

#11

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

Carole Valentine

>Question? What question? Did I ask a question?

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

#12

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

Carole Valentine

>Thanks guys. Good points. My shop is not climate controlled so I never glue collars or finials in place until the pieces have stayed in the house for few weeks. I know this doesn't account for seasonal changes in humidity, but I guess it's better than nothing. Is there a decent glue that is slightly flexible? Seems to me that would solve any problem one might have with slight wood movement.

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

#13

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

Lan Brady

>Carole,

You have discovered a new reference for time.

It is called an oh-no second.

It is the length of time from when you hit the send button until you go Oh No!

Lan

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

#14

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

Bill Hale

>You should have come to the AZ. Desert Roundup. Paul Porter did his thing on just this.

He did not make any special point about grain direction.

He did say to use the new flexible CA.

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

#15

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

Carole Valentine

>There is a flexible CA? Sounds like the answer. Of course I would have to pay $4.50 for the glue and $8.50 for the shipping. :( Guess it will just have to wait. Thanks for the info.

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

#16

JL

Re: If you are patient, you can wait..

JL

>Highland Hardware and Woodcraft aren't far from Ellijay and I'm sure that someone can pick some up for you and bring them to Ellijay.

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

#17

Carole, I just figured out today

Don Henthorn

>that I spend as much for gas to go into Austin as I would spend havong dmall things mailed. Took me twenty years to figure this out.

Re: Question about Ebony and Blackwood

#18

Re: Carole, I just figured out today

Carole Valentine

>Hi DOn. That can happen. But the nearest place for me to get anything like that is 130 miles round trip and a $17 toll. :)