Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

How many of you collect?

Posts

How many of you collect?

#1

How many of you collect?

Chris K in MD

>I was wondering how many of you collect turnings from other turners? Do you buy them more often or trade for them? Who is represented in your collection now? Who would you really like a peice from?

My answers to get this rolling;

I started "collecting" turnings in December. I have a couple of trades that are due to me but I have also bought a few turnings, and won one from the AAW contest. I have purchased a couple peices that I really admired from two of our own, Mark Kauder and Ed Kelle. I really would like a very long list of turnings from many people several of them a regulars here, but the peices that are at the top of my list and way out of my reach are Cindy Drozda's and Binh Pho's.

I really look forward to hearing from you all.

Re: How many of you collect?

#2

Re: How many of you collect?

Mike Schwing from Md.

>I find this is a difficult topic to broach with woodturners because it is very personal. Being both a "collector" and a "trader" is a delicate balancing act. Do you ask someone to purchase, as a collector would, or might you initiate an offer to trade, as a turner might? Suppose the other person was not interested in your work? Should they respond by telling so, or give up what they perceive to be a valuable turning of theirs for something they see to have less value as to not hurt anyone's feelings? Should they tell the truth, or make up a white lie? If done as a group trade, as was done here over the holidays, that changes the dynamic and removes the potential conflict. I wish I had participated in that but other things got in the way. Maybe next year.

Someone pretty famous in this arena told me that he responds to requests for trades by stating that he turns to put food on the table, and he can't eat wood, so he thanks them for the gracious offer but declines.

As I look on my shelf at the office where I keep my friends' turnings, I see that I am more of a trader than a collector, but I have done both. I would prefer to buy tools and bicycles over wood turnings, so when the opportunity to trade with someone who's work I consider desirable, I accept. I rarely initiate the trade discussion. I admire those who desire others' work simply because they are friends, but I do not share that enthusiasm. I only trade or purchase becuase I truly wanted the work. It is, however, a great honor and humbles me every time someone asks to trade, especially if it someone on my wish list.

I purposely left out the names of those I've bought and traded, as for me, it is not important to the discussion.

Re: How many of you collect?

#3

Re: How many of you collect?

Gary Evans Tallassee, TN

>Hi Chris,

You aren't going to have anything special when you receive at least one of the trades that you are waiting on. However, I do want to add to this thread.

I've been lucky in my travels to pick up some very nice pieces from some familiar names here on WC. I have a Holly HF from our own webmeister. I think his name is Ellis something. I'd have to look at the bottom of the lovely little pot.

I have a lacquered piece that Phil Wall gave me when he was still in PA, from his Oriental period. I have a Spalted Sycamore HF that I got from Dick Tuttle. This thing is amazing. It is about the same size and heft as a chicken egg without the filling. In shape it resembles a miniature David Ellsworth piece. He hollowed it through a hole that is less than 1/4" in diameter.

I am also fortunate enough to have two Carole Valentine originals, as well as a piece from E.C. Dunning down in FL. A piece from Tom Dennis, formerly of NC, and a couple of pieces from my friend Kenny McCaffrey out of New Orleans pretty much round out my "collection."

Speaking of Cindy Drozda, I have been to a couple of symposiums where she has been a featured demonstrator. She has always donated several pieces to the auction to benefit the clubs that put on the shows. Some of her pieces have gone for much less than they were worth. It might be worth your while to track her symposium schedule and attend one of them. You might get lucky.

Gary

Re: How many of you collect?

#4

Re: How many of you collect?

Chris K in MD

>Mike,

You bring up some very good points, its an awkward interaction for sure (regarding the trading interaction you detailed).

For me I was getting sick of looking at just my turnings, so I was looking at work that I admired as it was very different than my own and brought some more variety to my display cabinet.

For the reasons you mention I think it says something to buy a turning, since as turners we could buy tools or some really nice wood with the money we would have spent. Someone must really like the peice to pay for it. Additionally I see that it helps the hobby since a portion of its success has been the sale of peices and the "art" status that continues to grow.

I am looking forward to the AAW auction as I think it will be fun. You had shared with the club that you bought a peice at last years auction, and I think that it should be a fun to try and participate.

I find I get as much out of giving a gift and seeing the people open it up. For people outside the hobby there is another sense of "you made this". In my case its actually spawned a couple sales, interesting they are sales for these people to give as gifts to others.

Re: How many of you collect?

#5

Re: How many of you collect?

Chris K in MD

>Gary,

Narissa's box was beautiful you are selling yourself short. You have aa nice litte collection going there, we havent seen a turning posted by Ellis in a long time!

Re: How many of you collect?

#6

Re: How many of you collect?

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>I have a modest collection of turnings by some well known turners. About a dozen pieces. Most of them were from trades initiated by the other person, which I find pretty flattering. Most were from pieces that I had displayed in instant galleries at symposiums. One of the perks of doing demos at symposiums is that you get to meet and sometimes socialize with the other presenters.

Wally

Re: How many of you collect?

#7

me

T Daniel

>Chris, I have several pieces from other WC'ers and fellow club members. If I go visit another turner I try to take an item with me....not to trade but to reward them for putting up with me. I saw Mark Kauder's work at the SSS a few years ago before anyone knew him and by the quality I knew he would be known shortly so I bought a piece from him. It has appreciated in value much faster than bank interest. I also enjoyed the exchange that David Probst put together.

Re: How many of you collect?

#8

Re: How many of you collect?

Ed Karch

>I have a collection of 7 pieces. Some are famous some are not yet. All but two were gifts or trades. My three favorites are from women turners.

Re: How many of you collect?

#9

Re: How many of you collect?

Carole Valentine

>I have pieces from several WC folks. Molly, Mark K, Terry Quiram, Ed Karch, Dick Hines. I treasure them all. Being able to hold and examine other's work is important to me. I learn a great deal from it, but it happens too seldom. I am really looking forward to seeing other's work in person in April at Terry's. I would like to have some pieces from other accomplished turners, many of them in WC, but they are far out of my reach!

Re: How many of you collect?

#10

Re: How many of you collect?

Wayne Kuhn

>Mike your thoughts on the subject are why I will not participate in my clubs upcoming swap. My piece would not come close to what I would recieve. Too many talented turners in our group.

Maybe in a year or two, as my skills, specifically design skills get better I will participate.

Wayne K.

Re: How many of you collect?

#11

Re: How many of you collect?

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Wayne, I would encourage you to participate anyway. Speaking from experience, you will never be 100% totally satisfied with your work, and if you become famous - just think of how valuable, even if only for bragging rights, one of your first turnings will be? The person to receive what you don't think of as worthy now might be thrilled down the road. Plus, everyone participating in a group exchange acknowledges the risk up front. And there's nothing like being reminded of your first turnings every now and then...

Re: How many of you collect?

#12

Re: How many of you collect?

chris rolke

>i would love to start collecting

currently i have 1 piece from the WC exchange

i have contacted a couple of people but alas right now i cant afford to do anything ( we are expecting our first in the next month so money is tight )

Re: How many of you collect?

#13

Re: How many of you collect?

Chris K in MD

>Congratulations on the family!

One thing that I should note is that I really like the growing trend of turners adding miniatures, they are usually less expensive and allow you enjoy a fine peice without breaking the bank. (The couple peices I have bought have been smaller scale items)

Of course you can get into the minatures where the price climbs again.

Re: How many of you collect?

#14

Dick Hines

Re: How many of you collect?

Dick Hines

>I have 2 pieces by Carole Valentine and 2 by Wally Dickerman. That's a perty good start

Re: How many of you collect?

#15

I collect

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>My collection is a combination of several purchased but most are gifts. Several were turned here when the turner visited. These turners are represented: Mac Ray, e, Richard Allen, Carole Valentine, John Williams, Martin Pidgen, Larry Hancock, Ruth Niles, John Cotten and Patrick O'Brien.

Re: How many of you collect?

#16

Re: How many of you collect?

Don O.

>I sort of "collect" demo pieces from well-known turners that I have had the pleasure of seeing in person if possible. Most of them are from turners who have been to our club or our symposium. Right now I have pieces from Al Stirt, Mike Hosaluk, Ray Key, Russ Fairfield (x2), Bonnie Klein, Rolly Munroe, Bob Rosand, Ernie Conover, and just this week got a piece by Stuart Batty from Totally Turning 2005. Looking forward to lots more as I get to see more demos.

Re: How many of you collect?

#17

Re: How many of you collect?

Colin Spencer

>Chris

I would like to collect but to date I only have two pieces, one form a turner in the UK who did not sign his piece that I bought about 10 years ago before I got into turning and the second from David Peebles as part of the Christmas exchange here on WC. As someone who has recently taken early retirement I am getting used to living on a smaller budget and don't have the disposable income at present to purchase some of the pieces that I would like to.

The challenge that I have is where I live, Spain, there are very few turners here and the nearest that I am in touch with regularly is over 300 miles away. I do miss contact with other turners that I had when I lived in the UK. Travelling to symposiums in the US at the moment is out of reach.

I would be more than willing to swap turnings with others no matter how experienced, we all had to start somewhere. As Mike said I am sure that we all think that we could have done better when we have finished a piece. I have always found looking at others works in magazines and books an inspiration but there is nothing like holding a piece to get true inspiration.

A couple of thoughts, could we have a regular event like David Propst orgainsed at Christmas 2/3 times a year, or creating a list somewhere of turners who are willing to swap pieces? If the latter is an option we would need to set some sort of limit so that an individual was not inundated with requests. I would be willing to explore something along the lines of keeping a list as I do have unlimited space on my webserver if it is of interest.

To finish if anyone does want a swap with me (don't all rush at once) please email privately.