Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Go or No Go

Posts

Go or No Go

#1

Go or No Go

Rick Davenport

>I get most of my wood from old firewood piles.

This piece of dried cherry is a good example.

I've finished the outside to a nice baby's bottom smoothness.

But that dang crack concerns me.

Should I go for the inside or move on to something more stable?

For size perspective, it's mounted on a talon chuck.

Thanks for you opinions.

Rick

"Life shouldn't be dull."


img

Re: Go or No Go

#2

Re: Go or No Go

RK in Milw

>Life wouldn't be dull if you hollowed that one. Looks laike a bad thing waiting to happen.

Re: Go or No Go

#3

Re: Go or No Go

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>You have what looks like a nice piece of cherry, so I'd say go with it. You have deal with the crack before continuing. Accentuate it. There are lots of possibilities. You can fill it with epoxy and a stone like turquoise, you can use epoxy and fill it with used coffee grounds (looks quite natural, like bark, etc). You can open it a little, and use ebony "butterflies" to tie it together. There lots of ways to handle it. Just use your imagination. I wouldn't use wood dust as some do. It'll forever looked "patched". Every time you do something like this you add to your experience and learning.

Wally

Re: Go or No Go

#4

Re: Go or No Go

Dave Belser in NH

>Rick if this was my turning and I really wanted to finish it here is what I'd do:

- Flatten the top and then use CA glue to attach a piece of 1/2" birch or other strong SOLID plywood. Make sure it's glued well around the rim of the piece

- Turn the plywood so it's about 1/2" larger than the rim of the piece.

- Wrap decent strong tape around the outside

- Hollow out through the ply and finish the inside

- Part off the plywood ring and finish the rim

- Remove the tape and your done.

I've used this technique on a few bowls that were missing large chunks of their sides. One aspect about turning that I really enjoy is pushing the limits -SAFELY- of what I'm capable of doing. Take your time and check the integrity of the piece as you go. Worst that will happen is it might fly apart - but you will be facing the top wearing a face shield, not in the line of fire while you hollow it. Also the tape will help contain it.

Good Luck & Be safe

Dave

Re: Go or No Go

#5

Re: Go or No Go

Paul in Phoenix, AZ

>I agree with Wally. I fill cracks like that with CA and used coffee grounds. This looks like the wood we have here in AZ (nice big cracks). Filling it with wood chips makes it look like partical board, YUCK!. And for an extra measure, wrape some tape around it when you hollow it.

Re: Go or No Go

#6

Bingo!

Mike Schwing from Md.

>Combine the bits of advice on these two posts - fill and wrap. You'll wind up with a very nice end result.

Re: Go or No Go

#7

Re: Go or No Go

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>I say go for it, but I'd rough-turn it to a wall thickness of 10% of diameter and let it sit a few days or weeks before doing any filling. If you fill it now, that will probably pop out--either the crack will expand, or contract, and the filling will be a waste of time.

Re: Go or No Go

#8

Re: Go or No Go

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>Rick, If you fill the crack with epoxy and whatever it will be plenty stable to turn once the epoxy has set.

Norm

Re: Go or No Go

#9

Re: Go or No Go

Lan Brady

>Rick,

I probably cannot help you, but thanks for posting this question. I have learned a great deal from the responses.

Only advice I have is:

If you are professional turner, and time is money. Throw it away.

If you are hobby turner. This is a great learning experience.

Lan

Re: Go or No Go

#10

Re: Go or No Go

Pete in Holland, MI

>Someplace I saw a piece like this being turned, but prior to, a donut of plywood saw turned as a snug fit to the piece, then taped in place. Seems the donut would be less apt for the wood to chatter each time the tool hit the gap.

Re: Go or No Go

#11

Re: Wally has the best...

JamieDonaldson

>.....suggestion- turn it wrapped in tape, and add butterflies when it stabilizes, not before hollowing because it will move as it dries.

Re: Go or No Go

#12

Re: Go or No Go

Ed Karch

>Go for it. Finish it then stich it with bronze wire and watch the customers admire that big crack. Cracks are beautiful don't fill them up with all kinds of gunk.

Re: Go or No Go

#13

Re: Go or No Go

Sean Troy

>I'd say stich it.

Re: Go or No Go

#14

Re: Go or No Go

Bill Hale

>Turn it as you desire. Drill stiching holes on each side of the crack and use wet streched rawhide to lace. When it dries it will be a neat opaque color and very very tight.

Most of all use your imagination.

Einstein once said " imagination is more important than knowledge "

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Go or No Go

#15

I like the ebony buterfly idea.

Eddie Pacheco, San Jose, Ca.

>I've also seen where a biscuit cutter is used to create a slot and then a contrasting piece of wood is inserted into the slot.

Re: Go or No Go

#16

Re: Go or No Go

ad de Crom

>Rick, this happened me too this week with a roughly turned cherry bowl. The same happened two years ago with another cherry bowl.

Cherry is a tricky wood.

Well I cut it out and maked fit a block of cherry and glued it together.

I always be aware of cracks in cherry, that's the reason I turn it always roughly in the first place.

Re: Go or No Go

#17

Re: Wally has the best...

Joe Herrmann

>Kelly Dunn wrote a nice article for Woodturning Design on making and adding butterflies to bowls. See Issue #3, Fall, 2004, Pages 33-35.

Joe

Re: Go or No Go

#18

Re: Go or No Go

Rick Davenport

>Thanks (ESPECIALLY Wally ;-)) for the varied and valid suggestions.

I haven't done anything with this piece since I took the picture.

I am going on a one week vacation starting Saturday and plan to ponder the plethora of possible plans.

One thing for sure, I am going to finish it.

somehow.

some way.

Rick