Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Which Sthil or Husky to get?

Posts

Which Sthil or Husky to get?

#1

Bob Moffett

Which Sthil or Husky to get?

Bob Moffett

>Thanks for everyone's advice to get either a Sthil or Husky rather than a rebuilt Poulan. I have burned out 2 Craftsman 42cc and don't want to do that again. I went and looked at Sthils today. I seldom cut over 18" logs, usually between 12" and 16", but sometimes larger. I also want to be able to cut down the center of a log. I use a lot of Oak, Cherry, Walnut and Maple. I do a moderate amunt of cutting and not enough turning. Which Sthil or Husky would you recommend?

Re: Which Sthil or Husky to get?

#2

The best person to answer your question is:

T Daniel

>Your local STihl dealer. Just go there and tell them what you want to do and they'll be able to advise you better than anyone else.

TD

Re: Which Sthil or Husky to get?

#3

Re: Which Sthil or Husky to get?

Mike Schwing from Md.

>You will probably receive LOTS of different answers to this question, and they're all going to have validity. Ultimately the choice will be up to you, but I recommend buying the most saw you can comfortably and safely handle. A large saw can make short work of small stuff, but a small saw can only handle so much, no matter what you do with it. And in the case where you need a chainsaw in an emergency - bigger will be better. Even though you cut moderate sized logs, a bigger saw will do the job more quickly and tire you and your muscles out less, plus make you more likely to actually use your saw if it is not going to be a chore, as I have found underpowered saws to be. My Stihl can reduce what would be a 30 minute job with a small homeowner saw to 10 minutes. This makes me much more likely and eager to get it done.

Now as for what specific size - you don't want to mimic me unless you're as small as me - 5'5", 135lbs. I have a Stihl MS360Pro - a pretty substantial saw, but puny for a guy like Bill Grumbine. The pro version is lighter by about a pound, and I can safely handle it. I would have liked a bigger saw but I just can't safely use one.

Invest in a few different sized bars when you are able - I have a 14", 18", 20", and 25" and 2 chains for each. You will be glad you have the right size bar for each job. If you call Stihl they will tell you what size bars each saw can really handle - which is more bar than is advertised in their literature.

I do not own a Husky, but plenty of folks here do. I would buy my saw over again in a heartbeat, but doubt I'll ever have to do so.

Re: Which Sthil or Husky to get?

#4

JL

Re: I like the 55 Rancher..

JL

>

Re: Which Sthil or Husky to get?

#5

FWIW...

Peter Teubel

>I have a Stihl MS390 and its all the saw I need for bucking logs and cutting blanks. Full chisel, non-safety (yellow) Stihl-brand chain. I make no recommendations there (the usual disclaimers apply), but it works so well that's the only chain I run. The 390 weighs in exactly the same as the 290 (which is the saw that "sold" me on Stihl that I borrowed from a fellow turner), but has more power (64cc). Got a 20" and 28" bars for it. I also got an MS170 for the smaller stuff and for (future) carving (12" & 14" bars). Cuts much slower, but weighs next to nothing.

Re: Which Sthil or Husky to get?

#6

Re: Which Sthil or Husky to get?

Barry Turner

>I bought a Stihl 361 with a 20" bar last Spring. This is a saw that is on the lower end of their commercial line. I used it Saturday. It absolutely rocks. I have never seen a chainsaw that throws as many chips. Just keep the chain sharp and it will cut anything.

Re: Which Sthil or Husky to get?

#7

Re: Which Sthil or Husky to get?

Raymond Overman in SC

>That's easy. The biggest, baddest, most powerful one you can afford and feel comfortable running and want to tote around and want to maintain and want to buy parts for.

I personally own a Husky 350 with an 18 inch bar. My lathe won't handle but an 11" diameter piece of wood so I don't cut huge honkin trees to get my blanks from. I have Granberg's small Alaskan mill and as long as I have a sharp chain and a don't rush things, I don't have a problem with ripping through a 14-15" diameter tree with it for cutting out the pith and creating flats on each side. I wouldn't want to go into production lumber making with it, but it works fine for me for short runs.

The Rancher 55 is comparable but the only thing I have a problem with about it is that they've started selling it in the Big Orange Box. I don't know if this has become a second line saw for Husky or not.

If I were to buy one today, and I had the extra nickels, I might go for the 359 just for that extra power if I needed it.

Re: Which Sthil or Husky to get?

#8

Husky 353

Jorge Castaneda

>Like Mike I am a small guy, 5'7" and 125 pounds, and a lot older than him; I like to use the lightest saw that can do the job, I live in the woods and heat with eood, so I do lots of cutting, my choice is the Husky 353, with a 16" bar, it is a sweet saw, powerful enough for all the cutting I do amd I feel safe and my back is thankful.

Re: Which Sthil or Husky to get?

#9

Re: Which Sthil or Husky to get?

Fog Tanner

>I have the Sthil 290 and love it. But, I wish I had spent a little more and got the next size up, the 360. I have a 20" bar on mine which will get through most of what I want. The size and weight is right for me (5'6" 200lbs). Twenty years ago, when I was much younger, my father and I were going to cut up a lot of cedar logs. He was going to buy a new chain saw, I told him to get a 36" bar. He came back with a 30" bar, disappointed I figured "we could make do". By the end of a long day, the bar had grown to 48" and weighed all of 80 lbs and I was glad that he hadn't got what I wanted. So the 20" bar is fine for me, but there are a few times I would like a 24".

The only problem I have had with mine was a couple of weekends ago, a number of us were out cutting wood and three of us had the same saw. It got to be fun keeping track. Out of six saws, there were four Sthils, one Sears, and one Brand X. The one that got the most use was the Sthil 360.

Even though you have a 10" lathe, this can change. Also the larger saw will let you cut bigger pieces into sizes to fit your lathe.

Re: Which Sthil or Husky to get?

#10

Re: Which Sthil or Husky to get?

JKJ in East TN

>I have a 250 and a 361. The 361 is more powerful but heavier. I find myself using the 250 with the 18" bar for most things because it is lighter, easier to handle, and because of that, I think a little more safe. I can easily cut a 24" tree with the 250.

For bigger things the larger saw is easier. The biggest I've cut is a 4' white oak with a 24" bar on the 361. I haven't tried ripping a long tree with either.

JKJ

Re: Which Sthil or Husky to get?

#11

Husky Rancher 55 + safety gear and sharpener

Dale Sherman - Manlius, NY

>I've got the Husky Rancher 55 with an 18" bar. It has performed flawlessly for me. The biggest tree I took down was a 36" maple which was too much for the bar I had. However, the saw had the power to keep cutting without bogging down. It could have handled a longer bar, but the 18" was right for most of my cutting needs.

I wouldn't go any smaller, but, since I drive a desk a good share of the week, a larger saw would have been more to handle than I wanted. As it is, I'm tired after a few hours of bucking up logs (Note to self, go to the gym more often).

Bottom line, size the saw for your needs and physical ability, then see who has the best deal for you, Stihl or Husky. Don't forget chaps, shield, hardhat, hearing protection. I also recommend getting a good sharpener and extra chains. Files are nice for touchup, but not for dinged chisel teeth.

Dale

Re: Which Sthil or Husky to get?

#12

Re: Which Sthil or Husky to get?

LT

>Bob,

I recently bought a Husky 350 with an 18" bar and I am very pleased with it. It has plenty of power and the power to weight ratio is very good.

I looked long and hard at both the Husky and Stihl (and got great advice from this board), and it was really a toss up. I went with the Husky because it had a slightly better warranty and was slightly less expensive than a comparable Stihl. I don't think you can go wrong with either choice.

Re: Which Sthil or Husky to get?

#13

Re: Which Sthil or Husky to get?

Tom Sweeney - Coatesville, PA

>I'm going to my local saw shop tomorrow & buying a Husky 455 Rancher. I haven't used it yet, but I'm sure it will do everything I need. You can buy this saw on-line for about $330 - $360. I went with this saw instead of a stihl because the shop is right down the street & has a good reputation. The guy is giving me the 455 with a heavy duty 20" bar & a .580 (I think) chain for $360 & throwing the case in for $10 more. On-line the case is about $35 & you get a standard duty bar & chain - so for a few bucks more I have the convenience of the shop right down the street if anything needs fixing. Check the local saw shops - the guy said he can almost always meet or beat the box stores prices.