Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

What does it need ?

Posts

What does it need ?

#1

What does it need ?

Bill Hale

>Mallee bowl 8 1/4 wide 3 deep

It still has a spigot for remounting.

The wood is so striking that I am not sure if I should add black gruves or something.

I like it as is.

This is the piece I traded to Joaz.

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ

Re: What does it need ?

#2

forgot pics 

Bill Hale

>


img

Re: What does it need ?

#3

Re: forgot pics

Stuart Johnson

>Beautiful piece. The only suggestion I have is to soften the sharp edges on the rim.

Re: What does it need ?

#4

Re: forgot pics

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>Bill, that is a beautiful piece. I would have to think about it for awile before I changed anything. For now I would leave it as is.

Norm

Re: What does it need ?

#5

Re: forgot pics

GaryG in MD

>Bill,

With all due respect to Stuart, I like it just the way it is. I think the sharpness of the edges is very important to the piece as one of its focal points. I tried to envision shadow lines, but IMHO, I think they would detract from your interesting rim shape.

It's a beauty. Let the beautiful burl speak for itself. I think you've more than done it justice.

It's done! Finish the foot and enjoy.

...Gary

Re: What does it need ?

#6

Re: What does it need ?

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>The ONLY thing I would do if it were me, is turn off the foot. It's perfect as is, but would be even more perfect without a raised foot. Just a small slightly concave bottom, probably with sharp detail grooves.

Re: What does it need ?

#7

Re: forgot pics

Bill Hale

>Stuart

They do have a very light chamfer. I do thia on all my pieces as sharp edges tend to chip.

Thanks all for comments

Bill

Re: What does it need ?

#8

Re: What does it need ?

Bruce

>A new home?

Re: What does it need ?

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: forgot pics

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Bill, Here is my critique....If you made the foot smaller, more of the curve aproaching it would be visible...and add greatly to its visual "dynamic" impact.....try drawing it to see the difference, and if you like it.

I like the heavy walls, however, the bowl interior seems to go only about halfway into the form. That may be just the image, I can't say for sure.

I beautiful piece of wood, and you've done a great job with it..Keith

Re: What does it need ?

#10

Re: What does it need ?

Bill Hale

>Welkl I guess the question is answered My wife spoke for the piece as is.

She saw it and said that is mine.

Thanks all

Bill

Re: What does it need ?

#11

Re: What does it need ?

Craig Daymon

>Beautiful job. Personally, I liked the sharper edge on the inside lip. Really defined the wonderful shape of the interior.

So what does that weigh in at? 75, 100 pounds? One of our groups turners turned a much smaller piece or Red Mallee, probably 5" in diameter...maybe 6", and it weighed every bit as much as his 14" maple burl platters (which he turns thick). That stuff really has mass!

-Craig