Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

Posts

Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#1

Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

DaveAnderson (Pac NW)

>Hi to All,

My lovely bride of 37 years suprized my yesterday while I was turnig a bowl on my Jet mini. She said that I should buy a bigger lathe. WOOOO-HOOOO!!! The only thing stipulation, I had to stay reasonable. So I thought that I would seek the advise of a non- partison group. What is reasonable? A Oneway 2436? A PowerMatic 3520? A Jet 1642 2HP Vs? or maybe a Vega 2400 Bowl Master? Since I only turn for Pleasure, Maybe I should Go for the Jet and push my luck and see if I could swing a new Band Saw at the same time.

If I could only decide what is Reasonable!

Dave in the Pac NW

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#2

You gotta love a woman like that.

bert Workman

>Just for what it's worth, I picked up the 16" Jet vs and have been thrilled with it. I didn't get the 2 hp though. Actually, now that I think about it, they may be the same thing just wired differently.

I don't think you'll be dissapointed with any of the lathes you mentioned. You may want to dedicate the first piece you turn to that sweetie pie of yours :)

Bert

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#3

Re: You gotta love a woman like that.

Bill Crommett

>What's reasonable ? Remember that one mans treasure is another mans trash. Reasonable therefore has to do with values, ego. social position and resources.

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#4

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>Reasonable, All of the above and pretty much in that order. I have a Powermatic and love it. You have the chance to get the one you want within reason and that depends on what you can afford. Go for it or you will be sorry that you didnt.

Norm

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#5

choices

T Daniel

>If you plan to only turn bowls then you cannot beat a bowl lathe; after all, that is what they are made for. However, if you need versatility then you can't beat a sliding headstock lathe. Of the ones you mentioned the One-way is by far the best because of its superior banjo, #3 MT tailstock, and numerous other things that are overlooked by other manufacturers. If your budget could only go half that far then the PM3520 is a lot of lathe for the money. OK, the One-way ddoesn't have a sliding headstock, but it does have an outboard set-up available. Check out the 1640 One-way.

TD

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#6

Re: choices

Vicmarc.fan

>If you have the money for a Oneway go ahead and go first class and get a Vicmarc 200 or 300.

Ron

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#7

Re: choices

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I agree, consider the Oneway 1640. I love mine. As Terry said, the tailstock is awesome. If you ever want to turn larger, you can always get the outboard bed, etc. The long bed is really great. I have yet had to remove the tailstock to turn inboard, even hollow forms. Of course if you get into really big hollow forms, you would probably need to remove it.

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#8

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

Carole Valentine

>Dave,

I had a Jet Mini (still do) and needed a larger lathe at reasonable cost. I ended up with the Nova DVR and love it. I have come to rely on the swivel headstock more than I ever thought I would, because it lets me keep the tool against my body and I don't have to lean out over the bed. I have the bed extension so the tailstock never gets in my way. Just another option you might check into.

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#9

Richard Allen

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

Richard Allen

>You are one lucky man!!

With luck like that you should attend the AAW Symposium this Summer as you are likely to win one of the 5 Oneway 2436 lathes being given away as door prizes!!!

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#10

Re: choices

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

>Hi all,

As an option that is between the Oneway and Powermatic, pricewise, there is the General 260. It doesn't have a sliding headstock, but like Terry said, neither does the Oneway. I saw one in our local Klingspor shop the other day with a $3800 price tag on it. About a thousand more than the PM, but 1800 or so less than the Oneway.

I don't know if you can set it up for outboard for really big stuff? Maybe someone who has one could comment? The 260 is tops of my wish list for "someday" when I move past the Jet Mini I have.

I wonder for those that have a sliding headstock option, how often does it really get used? I'm just curious. It seems like it could really neat to slide it to the end and whamo, instant bowl lathe, but I've never turned on one.

Thanks,

Mike

Dreaming in General Green in Apex, NC!!!

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#11

Re: choices

Dennis Y

>I have the PM3520A and I use the sliding headstock all the time. I turn mostly bowls and hollowforms. I have a tailstock cart I built to facilitate the easy removal of the tailstock. Bad back will not let me just lift it off. It is so much easier to turn hollowforms directly from the end of the lathe. Dennis

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#12

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

Bill Hale

>My wife said OK to the Oneway 2436 BUT that I had to start doing craft shows to pay for it. And I did.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, Az.

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#13

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

georgetroy

>Well I'm also a lucky man I have choices. Like which one am I going to use today, sometimes it's all 4, not counting the Vic Mini lathe. Stair step in price is the Nova DVR, Vicmarc 175, Vicmarc 300 or the new Robust 18x25. Must be slipping today I was only using 3 of them. The ones I mentioned are all good. It's a personal thing, but I do not use lathes made in China or Tawian. Of course sometimes you don't have any choices and that particular machine or item is only made in China. GT

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#14

Re: choices

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>Well Dave, Your head must be spinning by now. I checked them all out and found that the PM was the best bang for the buck.

Norm

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#15

Dick Hines

Re: choices

Dick Hines

>Mike, I have a PM 3520 and use the sliding headstock all the time. I work most of my bowls from the end and all of my hollow forms too. My tail stock is only on the lathe when I am turning things where I need the tail stock to drill holes.

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#16

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

Barry Turner

>A Stubby 750 is pretty reasonable in my opinion.

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: choices

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Mike, I have the general 260. Yes, you can turn outboard. In fact, I like the long bed.....I can set up my hollowing rig, then turn outboard without having to disturb the rig. It's almost like having two machines. It's been absolutely trouble free....going on three years.

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#18

Hey, you must be a real old guy

JKJ in East TN

>>..My lovely bride of 37 years

Married 37 years? You must be real old! (My bride and I will celebrate our 36th this year!!)

My sweetheart told me to build a bigger workshop and get a new truck and a sawmill. (One down, two to go) What will I ever do with that woman??

As for the lathe, I've had a 2hp Jet 1642 for a couple of years now and it is without doubt an outstanding machine. Plenty of power, quiet and smooth. I may eventually get another one just like it or the big brother PM.

JKJ

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#19

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

Rick Davenport

>Check this place out.

They took great care of me and they are nearby (Auburn).

http://www.equipmentsalesandsurplus.com/productDetail.cfm?type=new&productID=882&categoryID=10

I've had my PM 3520 for less that two weeks and I can't say enough about how good it is and how well Equipment Sales and Surplus helped me out.

Rick

Edmonds, WA

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#20

Re: You gotta love a woman like that.

Jerry Whitaker

>You must have misunderstood her!

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#21

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

John Irvine

>I got a PW 3520 in december and havent had a secound thought

it has been great.

you are lucky to have a wife so willing

good luck with your choice

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#22

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

David Breth

>I'm gonna try that too. Next week, I'm gonna buy a Nova DVR, and then I'm gonna say "Thanks for telling me to get a bigger lathe, honey!"

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#23

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

Guy

>Just my 2 cents. It's always fun to help people get a new toy. First get some numbers from her (our reasonable and their reasonable can vary drastically). Then figure out which lathes fall around that price range. Get the biggest one with the most motor. This prevents you wanting more later on. I prefer longbed lathes for the versatility. If you want a montstrous bowl you can usually hang them off the headstock. Smaller bowls are easily accessed. Instead of leaning way over I just go over to the other side. Works fine for me with no acrobatics. Tailstock slides to the end so I don't have to lift that cow. Sliding headstock lathes work fine too. When I bought my lathe a few years back I researched forever and the conclusions I basically came up with were: The PM3520 appears to be a best buy/bang for the buck. Nice heavy cast iron lathe. Who cares if it is made overseas. Nowadays only one lathe is made here and that is the new Robust lathe. All our iron toys are foreign made. The Jet is a mini Powermatic. Those that have them love them but are probably closet Powermatic lovers. Oneway has the best marketing/customer service in this country. Good product but they have their kinks that their loyal fans dismiss. They also tell you that you can turn outboard but they don't tell you it will cost. The top of the line 2436 with a bed extension on each end, outbard accessories etc, 3hp motor will get you closer to 10K than you thought possible. Still they are a very high quality product with a high quality customer support system. The VB36 is a monster but a lot of quirks and very specialized. best left for the pros. Vicmarc (ended up my choice) are cast iron, heavy, traditional styled lathes. Prices fall between the Oneway and Powermatic. Buy Aussie version or US version. After the sale service depends on who you buy it from and sometimes you have to get creative and have a lot of patience to get any help/support. I tried Oneway, Powermatic, Delta and had my old Teknatool. The Vic locks down and doesn't move, very smooth. The more I use it the more I like it. In Europe it seems to be the lathe of choice if you want top of the line. The Stubby's are loved by their owners and shrouded in mystery, secret handshakes etc. Another high quality piece and I know more/met than a couple people who have them and who can afford other brands. They are very versatile, very powerful and are just cool to look at. These were number two on my list and the only thing that kept me away was that my Vic has a 50 inch between the centers (which I have used already. Promised LOML bedposts). So please just take this for what it's worth, just my opinion based on talking to people, research forums like this and some personal experiences. Good luck and oh yeh, take her out to dinner (a couple times)!!

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#24

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

Ed Karch

>PM 3520 I only use the sliding head stock 8-16 times a day. At least back and forward then back for every item turned.

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

#25

Re: Wife Said Buy a bigger Lathe

Scott Greaves in Blackfoot Idaho

>Hi Dave,

If it were me, reasonable would be the Oneway 2436.

If it were my Wife saying that, reasonable would be a Jet 1236!!!

Good luck!

Scott.